Mini 1148 -- Spare Me Mafia (Game Over)

[Freewill]

Ooooh AVATAR BETS

Just another reason

Fate > Free Will


YOU LOSE

What do you even mean here, Fate?

[Umbrage]

The air's much nicer out here than in your ass, huh Umbrage?

Well, you would be the one to know.

Also: NO OUTSIDE BETS IN MAH MAFIA GAME.

[Freewill]

yeah, yeah, yeah. I withdrew it. Not trying to win with it, just demonstrate how silly the bravado level has gotten lately.

[Duplicity]

Freewill, you've spent quite an amount of time this game pointing out how other players aren't "Thinking", yet when you're on the block now you're not attempting to state reads nor reasons behind your reads. Instead you're making trivial avatar bets and questioning Fishys claim (Which you say has a less than 20% chance of being fake).

I see no town-motivation behind any of those actions at all, if you're attempting to change someones mind into thinking you're town you're going to have to stop these antics and starting using some realistic reasoning.

[Umbrage]

Freewill, you've spent quite an amount of time this game pointing out how other players aren't "Thinking", yet when you're on the block now you're not attempting to state reads nor reasons behind your reads. Instead you're making trivial avatar bets and questioning Fishys claim (Which you say has a less than 20% chance of being fake).

I see no town-motivation behind any of those actions at all, if you're attempting to change someones mind into thinking you're town you're going to have to stop these antics and starting using some realistic reasoning.

Says the men saving confirmed scum...

[Regfan]

Umbrage - First of, you should have noticed my vote right now is on Tony. Secondly, I'd like you to respond to this:

Lets assume for a second that you're correct and CK is mafia, he has to have partners, therefore you can still aim to have them lynched today and end with a succesful result.

[Duplicity]

This two account thing is the most frustrating thing in the world. Obviously my post above.

[Freewill]

Freewill, you've spent quite an amount of time this game pointing out how other players aren't "Thinking", yet when you're on the block now you're not attempting to state reads nor reasons behind your reads. Instead you're making trivial avatar bets and questioning Fishys claim (Which you say has a less than 20% chance of being fake).

I see no town-motivation behind any of those actions at all, if you're attempting to change someones mind into thinking you're town you're going to have to stop these antics and starting using some realistic reasoning.

1. I said 20% chance of being fake in the way I stated. It's probably higher when considering other possibilities.

2. I'm not trying to change people's minds. I've come to the conclusion that my death here will illuminating and surviving will let Fate play his little tunnel games, serving as a distraction for further days. If someone thinks I'm town, by all means they should save me. But it seems unlikely to me given that those vocal in the game seem to either be swayed by Fate's idiotic trash talking or simply think I'm scummy because I've engaged in not-playing-carefully.

3. I'll give my reads before the deadline, don't worry.

[Protoss]

I have 31 pages to read, on top of the rules, so don't expect much from me until I wake up tomorrow in terms of posting.

[Protoss]

I just read Nacho in iso, and I see no reason to be sparing them.

Spare: No one

[Protoss]

FoS: Fishy

For doing setup speculation, the mark of the beast.

this...
Tony is onto something here, and given that Fishy had claimed to not have a vote, something sure is fishy

[Protoss]

uh no
because taht was fucking pregame
and if scum couldn't spare their buddies
they'd be fucking told that

stop playing stupid kthx

I agree with this as well in terms of Fate playing stupid

[Nachomamma8]

VEZOK

Spare me in your next post, or I'm removing my spare vote.

[Protoss]

However, Fate at the end of page 5 and the top of page 6 is giving me strong town vibes, so I suppose he was possibly playing dumb as a ruse, and not as scum.

[Protoss]

lol Nachoscum is frantic

[Protoss]

I NEVER EVER EVER EVER EVER SAID I HAD A TOWN READ ON YOU YOU ABSOLUTE DUMBFUCK.

lol umbrage?
more like dumb rage

[Protoss]

Chess and Dupe still look like very good people not to save.

@chess: why save Dupe?

Hmmm. I've been thinking, and I think it's worth claiming a little further -

My role doesn't interact with the saving mechanic in the normal way. I would rather not be saved today. This will not cause me to die.

I was thinking about going all jester on this; but I thought harder and it turned out to be a terrible idea.

what the fuck?
This is pretty much a scumclaim to me
I am seriously considering saving him for this

When you try to heal undead, what happens? Hmmm? Thoughts?

[Nachomamma8]

Protoss, for god's sakes, just put all of those damn posts into one catchup post so I can skim them without spamming the page down button.

[Protoss]

ok, so far I've read 7 pages, and I have town reads on Fate and IS, am leaning town on CK3, and am leaning scum on Fishy, Umbrage, and Duplicity. I would be happy if any of these 3 did not receive votes today, or, well, in Fishy's case, apparently, if he DID receive a vote. If noone talks me out of it, or if my read on him doesn't improve in the next 24 pages, I am going to be putting my vote there.

[TonyMontana]

Unless he is an SK that dies if he is spared.

Worst. Role. Ever.

[Fishythefish]

I know how you all hate thinking and all, but consider this:

If Fishy is scum and not actually lynch immune and we put 3 others up, then scum will get to choose who is saved. They'll pick fishy. Thus "confirming" him as what he said he was.

Very high risk - not a credible scum strategy. Also, I imagine we'd be informed of the resolution process. Naturally, me surviving the lynch doesn't confirm that I'm town, though - it might be possible to balance lynch-immune scum.

@Protoss: why is setup speculation scummy?

[vezokpiraka]

unspare Fate
Spare nacho

I'm sorry Fate. But nacho is my buddy. I can't let him die.

[Nachomamma8]

Now Protoss, save Fate and realized how futile everything you've done has been.

[Freewill]

Spare: Fate

[chesskid3]

FREWILL
YOURE THE SAME FUCK WHO TOLD ME TO SHOOT FATE AFTER YOU FLIPPED TOWN

NOW YOU SAVE HIM
WTF