00s Band Mafia (Game Over!)

[diddin]

Unvote, Vote: Talapus

Backing down so quickly and not revoting? Bad.

[C-Worl]

Unvote; Vote: diddin

This is fun.

[Pine]

Unvote, Vote: Talapus

Backing down so quickly and not revoting? Bad.

Goodposting. That was alarming to me too.

C-Worl. Stop being an asshat. You're making me wish we hadn't agreed to give the fighting a rest. I swear to Jeebas, you're my kryptonite.

[nintendoaddict1]

No, what I mean is there's a difference in D1 and D2. D1 is normally a battle to see who ends up getting lynched, what they flip as, and then you can use that for the future. Therefore, I'm trying to see who is scummier and my methods while unconventional normally do work. What I'm doing may seem like sheeping but that's not what I'm doing.

Oh, ok. That I get. For a second there it sounded you you flat out didn't care and if you didn't, you're useless to the rest of us(No offense). I've played with several players that think this way and that kind of dad weight kills a game fast. So for now.

Unvote

You know that really makes it look like you voted for your scumbuddy just to say you did so if one of you flips scum the other looks a bit more inno, then unvoted so it wouldn't look like bussing.

[gorilla]

Talapus vote is a good vote. post #135 is really bad, reads like overcautious scum, wastes a lot of time lecturing nintendoaddict instead of commenting on his alignment (only goes so far as to say his play is "odd"), keeps talking about waiting for people to post on day 1 when there's already been plenty of content generated. Now, he votes C-Worl on what's basically policy (scum looking to give an excuse to mislynch) and immediately backs down.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Talapus

C-Worl is obnoxious in the extreme but I'm reading him as a VI more than scum.

[Scumhunter]

This gorilla guy seems townish.

[Talapus]

No, what I mean is there's a difference in D1 and D2. D1 is normally a battle to see who ends up getting lynched, what they flip as, and then you can use that for the future. Therefore, I'm trying to see who is scummier and my methods while unconventional normally do work. What I'm doing may seem like sheeping but that's not what I'm doing.

Oh, ok. That I get. For a second there it sounded you you flat out didn't care and if you didn't, you're useless to the rest of us(No offense). I've played with several players that think this way and that kind of dad weight kills a game fast. So for now.

Unvote

You know that really makes it look like you voted for your scumbuddy just to say you did so if one of you flips scum the other looks a bit more inno, then unvoted so it wouldn't look like bussing.

Bussing, really??? Dude, I get the whole scum buddy reference and all but it certainly isnt bussing. C-worl made what I thought was a blatantly scummy/useless comment and I called him on it. The only other vote on him at the time after he made his comment was for the reason of "sheep"ing another player. Now had I gone and voted him for the same reason, yes I'd agree with the bussing comment fully. But I didn't and called out an action I thought to be a bad move.

Also, I've never played with him before , I don't know his playstyle yet. I called him out on it and voted his ass as it puts pressure on him to give a response. He did just that and explained so I withdrew the vote. For the guys out there all ready to jump on board a lynch wagon and take me down for that relax a bit. Seriously, no one else called him out and questioned it and I think thats because you've played with him before, I haven't, so chill.

Now that I have more then 2 minutes I'll go back and reread a bit and see what else is here to post on.

[Talapus]

Ok at this point I'm ready to leave a vote on Goath. So,

Vote: Goath

Looking back at the arguments you made then about the player setup up it seems to mean you jumped to some conclusions that shouldn't or couldn't have been jumped too. With the alt player for instance that really shouldn't be a concern of yours as the Mod who ran the previous game is modding this. He's not just gonna let a bunch of multis in to screw us all up. With the whole PL and the potential scum buddies you draw conclusions that that when players defend eachother and then distance eachother on day one it's a good scum buddy tell. And honestly thats just BS in a game like this. I play very actively on another site and players do that all the time day one. Not because it means anything, but they are just used to giving eachother a hard time and messing around. Now should it continue and obvious distance is being put between then, then yes, big scum tell. But it's still day 1 and I think you're looking too hard at something not there. As for the whole player setup speculation it just seems odd how openly you put out a guess. As the mod did this in his previous game, I doubt he's using the same setup here as several players were in it. He of course has to change things up a bit.

Now these things have been touched on with you and you may have started to respond, however we don't get great answers. Instead your last post reflects that you are leaving until Sunday and just agree with several others that nintendo's claim isn't obviously town. Not an argument or case man, just restating the obvious.

[chesskid3]

CAN WE GET MY WAGON PLZ

[gorilla]

I don't follow your reasoning on EPM at all

[C-Worl]

EPM is scum, that's why chesskid wants to lynch him. How do you not follow that logic?

[C-Worl]

Unvote; Vote: EPM

Sorry chess, I got distracted by the pretty colors.

[gorilla]

I wasn't expecting or wanting you to answer for him

[diddin]

Unvote; Vote: EPM

Sorry chess, I got distracted by the pretty colors.

Remove chess's penis from your mouth kthnx

[Regfan]

Pages 7-9

Post #184 by Gorilla - His nervousness of my town-read on him reads as a geninue town-tell.
Post #185 by Tarsoniscolet - I like the format of the reads, but no reasoning behind them reads as if you're not acutally reading the thread.
Post #194 by Scumhunter My town-read on Diddin is due to the fact he was late to post and stated that he forgot the game started, mafia tend to focus more towards their games than town do intially as well as meta.
Post #197 by Talapus - No reason not to vote you? How is that reasoning for a vote.
Post #204 by Gorilla - Couldn't agree with this more.
Post #206 by Talapus - Reads as overdefensive.
Post #207 by Talapus - I agree with the vote, however the reasoning behind it is awful.

Town (From strongest to weakest):

Pine, Chesskid, Gorilla, Diddin, Evilpacman18, Parabollocks, C-Worl.

Null:

Nicodemus, DemonHybrid, Scumhunter, Nintendo.

Scum (From strongest to weakest):

Gaoth, Talapus, tarsonisocelot, Hiraki.

Scumhunter. I want reads from you in your next post, no excuses.
Chesskid, elaborate on your case on EPM becuase I'm not seeing it at all right now.

[C-Worl]

Unvote; Vote: EPM

Sorry chess, I got distracted by the pretty colors.

Remove chess's penis from your mouth kthnx

Why don't you remove it from your ass?

[tarsonisocelot]

TO isn't reading the thread. I mean seriously? No read or opinion at all on Nintendo or Gaoth? I can deal with getting lumped into the scum category, but this list as the only reaction to the thread so far is pretty scummy to me. I've seen TO as Town ([redacted]) and this bears no resemblance.

I clearly stated in that post that I had only just realised the thread was open.I read through it as quickly as possible and gave my first reads. The easiest to spot bit of weirdness was the C-Worl/Pine interaction. My first thought was that you were scumbuddies, then I realised that you were probably better than to do something so obvious as scumbuddies and revised my read accordingly. I don't buy you as scumbuddies, but I also don't buy you as both town. One of you is scum. I don't know which.

[tarsonisocelot]

Gaoth has contributed nothing so far except to state the obvious about C-Worl/Pine being weird atround each other. Could be the scumbuddy of whichever of them is scum. Leaning scum for now.

Nintendo has contributed little and I can definitely see where some people suspect them, but I got the feeling they were trying to help and just didn't quite know what would/wouldn't be useful information. I know that feeling. So I'm putting them as null slightly leaning scum.

Diddin I realise in retrospect I haven't heard enough from to have an outright town read. Revising read to null leaning town.

Chesskid I believe the miller claim of. Since then he's continued to feel town.

Regfan is obvtown.

Vote: C-Worl

of Pine/C-Worl, you currently seem the scummiest.

[Scumhunter]

im drunk ask me anything i swear i will answer honestly.

also regfan is never obv town ever don't you say that shit man. those are dangerous wrds you say man. hes gonna flip that shit around and ML u if hes scum man.

[chesskid3]

are you a tits man or an ass man?

[C-Worl]

tits man

[Scumhunter]

i like tits im kind of a large B to a small C guy but I can definitely appreciate a nice ass on a woman. Overall Tits guy

[Scumhunter]

ALso, I might as well tell you guys I'm sided with teh 2000s. I wish I was mafia because the players in this game seem willing to let me get away with providing no content and trolling for the most part which is the whole point of having troll meta only to waste on getting a town role and actually having to still try hard and think

[evilpacman18]

Chesskid, elaborate on your case on EPM becuase I'm not seeing it at all right now.

I'd like this too.


mod, votecount please.

Content after that.

[evilpacman18]

Actually that's unnecessary. There's just been a lot of vote-hopping in the last page.