Maxous wrote:Zepher - In this post I kinda feel he left himself a bit too much wriggling room on Silverbullet. Even though he did express suspicion of Subzero. Hmm :/
Silverbullet-251 wrote:
This is completely false. Are you really telling me that my questions to you and max are me just dancing in the air having a good ol time?
Are you attempting to say you were scumhunting me?
Silverbullet-256 wrote:What kind of shitty town are you to not want to pursue someone you think is scum unless your scum and... oh... now it makes sense.
Which is exactly what he did early game when he found a slight suspicion on Subzero and done nothing to pursue the suspicion or others.
He acted like mafia according to his own scumtell.
Posts like these always make me feel a bit uneasy. Mafia can uncommitally state this and wait to see what direction the town will go and then vote.
This vote then happened afterwards. I think Silver was on 5 at the time.
These are all good points that you bring up. This is good scumhunting, and seems to imply a town mindset.
Maxous wrote:MrZepher wrote:I just think it's interesting how 2 suspected likely scum are currently on the Mastin wagon buteveryone else is still arguing over 50/50 scum/town
I think there are more scum pushing for a Silver/Sub lynch then other, sense-making lynches.
1) Why is Nobody Special likely scum?
2) You think at least one of Silver and Subzero is mafia? Why are'nt you voting or giving any thoughts at all on them then?
3) What "other sense-making lynches?" You stated your suspects it was Subzero and Amor. The latter being mostly gut?
Yeah. Zepher is such scum for 2 and 3. But point 1 should be obvious. Multiple people have posted cases against NS.
DeityKabuto wrote:Subzero- Read post 279, that is my reason for voting silver. The reason I say silver has some innocence within him, say 40-60% is because other people have way different reasons. Usually, people's reasons for voting someone scummy are kind of the same (meaning they did something really really scummy) or their are multiple reasons (meaning they did many scummy things). Yet, the reasoning on silver, are mumbo-jumbo, all different and jumpy jumpy, get what I'm saying?
No. That doesn't make any sense. And having multiple reasons makes him more likely to be scum, not less.
Pine wrote:Noticed something from Vote Count. Mastin and Silver cannot be scumbuddies. Mastin's meta and obsession with VCA would not allow him to be on the secondary wagon with a buddy. If/when SIlver flips scum, Mastin is confirmed Town in my eyes.
Amazing point! I hadn't noticed that! And you are quite right.
MrZepher wrote:Also with the Silver wiggling room thing, that was my roundabout way of saying I'm not really sure on my read.
I want to think Silver is town, yes, but there are doubts. Hence why there's room for that to change. Make sense?
It makes sense from a scum perspective yes. Did you really just say that you are intentionally leaving yourself a way out of the wagon?
silverbullet999 wrote:-Max
Are the quoted posts of me directed to me? I'll answer if you'd like but I wasn't sure.
How does scum nhammen post?
Well normally he's really lurky and barely posts in the first few days. The posts he does make are normally short as well.
I'm not saying Nhammen is town he needs to live forever and ever. But he reads as town for me for now.
Ummm... I didn't think I was making short posts in TWBB. So is this bullshit reasoning, or something else?
Amor wrote:You don't see how "I'm voting for this person but I'm not sure if they're scum or town" isn't scummy? Your whole "sheep" schtick seems designed to allow you to hop on whatever wagon will get you a lynch without having to take responsibility for it afterwards. And the mindset you're referring to is being pro-town, you should try it sometime.
Maxous wrote:Who are the scum filling Silver's wagon? DK and KOC?
Them and maybe Pine. You and Mastin are right to say that it could be bussing, but I don't really get that vibe -- it seems like if they were bussing they would be making more forceful cases for town cred. In particular I don't think DK would be doing his "I'm just following the crowd" thing if he knew Silver would flip scum.
This is goodposting. In particular, the last sentence is well thought out. This means it is either silver or DK that is scum, but not both. However, this does not kill the Sub and silver bussing argument that mastin advocates. If you assume that Sub is scum, then this does look a lot like bussing.