Aldusskel wrote:Finally, no one noticed only one nightkill? Either a scumteam nokilled (unlikely; little motivation for that here), YoYoGuy successfully protected (perhaps), or scum hit scum (most likely).
So if someone seems pretty convinced that someone else is scum for no good reason, that person might themselves be scum.
If scum hit scum we would have a dead scum, unless I'm missing something about the setup. I'm assuming it was a successful protection.
Alright, let's look at that wagon a little closer
Robocopter87 (7)- projectmatt silavor Kcdaspot Toro YoYoGuy435 Empking Hiraki
silavor, Hiraki and to a lesser extent matt all argued pretty vocally for Robo being scum, with the first two even presenting cases. I don't see those as being scummy actions. Hiraki's two-step around hammering Robo is bizarre, but I still think indecisiveness is more likely to come from town in this case, as they have less information to deal with.
With YYG being dead, that leaves Kcda, Toro and Empking.
Kcda in ISO
0-10: Lots of joking, a weird unexplained vote on Matt (possible bussing) and agreement with others. He only really seems to post to defend himself or agree with the consensus.
12: Distances self from Matt vote.
16: Asks for a pressure wagon on Hiraki. Looks kind of opportunistic.
19: Calls Matt dumb but town some more
24: His longest post of the game so far, and it's entirely about ponies
27-29: Beating the drum for the Robo wagon some more without adding any new analysis
32: Tells everyone to shut up and lynch Robo already
34: Pretty decent defense of the pressure wagon comment.
38: Says he's suspicious of emp, silavor and toro
39: Echoes Toro's vote on Hiraki.
All in all KCDA looks like active lurking scum. Lots of posts, but most of them are one-liners, and a lot of them are either jokes or calling Matt dumb but town. Finds convenient reasons to hop onto the Robo and Hiraki wagons once they've got going, despite not mentioning either as a suspect before voting them. Tries to discourage discussion a few times. Pretty freaking suspicious.
Toro in ISO
0-5: RVS and meaningless one-liners
7: Votes me for my response to the questionnaire. I think that's crap, but I might be biased.
9-12: Goes against Hiraki for not posting his wall or giving explanations.
18: Apparently Robo and Hiraki's walls have convinced him of Roboscum. Goes from voting Hiraki to voting Robo. Probably the worst post in here, as it's kind of a complete 180 from his earlier suspicions.
22-26: Pointless theory discussion.
32: Big case against Hiraki for flip-flopping earlier. This started the Hiraki wagon, so it can't really be called scummy.
Less scumposting here, although still some filler. Moderately suspicious.
LadyHaHa/Empking in ISO
LadyHaHa:
0: Shows up late, calls my answer suspicious and then votes Matt.
2: Votes Hiraki for the whole "I don't have to explain myself" thing.
4: Big post defending Robo and attacking Hiraki
5: Calls out kcda for not focusing on other players
Not many posts here, but they seem pro-town to me. The fact that LHH requested replacement shows that the lurking was probably not a strategy.
Empking:
1: Agrees with the wagons on both Robo and Hiraki without much explanation.
3: Votes Robo
5-9: Defends unexplained town reads. Says this is a meaningless theory argument in #9, but still posted a lot about it.
12-13: Defends the "third on the wagon" tell. More theory discussion.
14: Emptyquote.
15: Votes me with no explanation, still has not returned to find a reasoning.
This is kind of the opposite of the Tid/MPR slot for me: LadyHaHa's posting makes me think town, but then Empking comes in and does nothing but unexplained votes and theory discussion. Kind of hard to figure out. Will be watching Empking's future posts very carefully.
tl;dr: KCDAspot is scum, matt is quite possibly his buddy, Toro and Empking might also be scum.
vote: KCDAspot
