xvart wrote:What has Nobody Special done to make him town?
I forget the exact reason, TBH. But he gives me a feeling of sincerity.
@DGB: Why'd you change your mind?
Battousai wrote:Ludi 1161: Exaggeration or have you dropped me as a suspect, since I'm not on the xvart wagon?
DrippingGoofball wrote:This sentence:
"Andy - let me predict your future: you have a long and frustrating game ahead of you."
Here is how I see your xvart vote:Yosarian2 wrote:Herodotus wrote:Sheeping attacks on xvart, Cobbler, and Ludi.
Wrong on all three counts. None of those were "sheeping", unless "sheeping" means "any time anyone attacks anyone that anyone else has ever attacked".
I believe I asked you long ago something like "what led Cobbler to claim?"Yosarian2 wrote:The attack on Cobbler is particularly suspicious because Cobbler claims to be a town PR that cult can't recruit to serve their purposes.
Yes, it's a completely unconfirmable claim that town are very reluctant to lynch. That's why it's a great scum claim.
That being said, you'll notice I never actually voted him at any point today, because I'm uncomfortable with the risk that he might be telling the truth.
You should ISO Yos2 and search for xvart, like I did.Flameaxe wrote:On another, related, note: How moronic is this game coming to if we are using the same logic as the RVS two days before deadline? "I'm guessing XXXXXX would be a good recruit based on nothing in the 50 fucking pages of thread but pure speculation" shouldn't be a serious wagon this late into the day.
Not on day one of this game from someone who is likely to be lynched. I think it's null.Katsuki wrote:Come to think of it, a vig list is extremely anti-town.
This is obviously silly faillogic. I assume it's code for "gut or meta".Andrius wrote:NS is town (because I am town and I don't think we've ever been opposite alignments before).
Battousai wrote:The cult may be able to use their powers on the building and not just a player.
Herodotus wrote:This is obviously silly faillogic. I assume it's code for "gut or meta".Andrius wrote:NS is town (because I am town and I don't think we've ever been opposite alignments before).
xvart is right that the wagon on him is questionable; it's also full of parked votes and little argument after the first few RL days, which, on day one, are characteristic of a group that isn't scumhunting. BUT, assuming there are no teams of scum, I'm not sure this is much of a defense per se.
If you had been working all along like you have recently, the wagon on you may have gone away...
Katsuki wrote:EBWOP: Everyone ignored my post calling for a lynch over a week ago.
Katsuki, 1189 wrote:Apparently no one bothered to read that there are bankable days in play.
Yosarian2, 1198 wrote:DGB:
Mr. Flay wrote:
With 25 voters, it will take 13 to lynch. Nightfall will occur no later than the end of June 14th, server time;
Battousai, 1202 wrote:Seraphim- Reason for the xvart vote? Do you find him scummy? why?
Herodotus, 1209 wrote:You have said nothing about what makes you think he's scum other than his being a desirable recruitment candidate. I just checked again. Nothing, other than one point when you quoted a paragraph from Battousai and said you agreed, comes close to discussing xvart's play in this game.
Flameaxe wrote:You should ISO Yos2 and search for xvart, like I did.
Which doesn't show anything damning against Yos that couldn't be damning for about 5 other people. Your point?
xvart wrote:Herodotus, 1209 wrote:You have said nothing about what makes you think he's scum other than his being a desirable recruitment candidate. I just checked again. Nothing, other than one point when you quoted a paragraph from Battousai and said you agreed, comes close to discussing xvart's play in this game.
This is the predominate trend. You could ISO anyone and pretty much get the same result.
Herodotus wrote:Not on day one of this game from someone who is likely to be lynched. I think it's null.Katsuki wrote:Come to think of it, a vig list is extremely anti-town.
No.xvart wrote:Mr. Flay - can you answer this question: does overkill get indicated on kill flavor? i.e. "xvart was shot twice during N1"?
Battousai wrote:\
Yos- Since each side only has 1 scum, we lose a bit of tells. Combine that with the scum being able to manipulate us (as in, town at best has random chance at lynching scum D1), it's at a lower threshold. Also, please explain to me how not removing a town player from the game (mislynching) will make it easier for scum to fulfill their win condition than if we do mislynch?
Yos- tsk, tsk, tsk. Already distancing yourself from the lynch while helping it go through.
Herodotus wrote:Here is how I see your xvart vote:Yosarian2 wrote:Herodotus wrote:Sheeping attacks on xvart, Cobbler, and Ludi.
Wrong on all three counts. None of those were "sheeping", unless "sheeping" means "any time anyone attacks anyone that anyone else has ever attacked".
Yos: The scum will probably recruit someone of the following description: (general qualifications that about 1/3 of the playerlist meets)
With regard to cobbler and Ludi, they were both looking town (to me), but had wagons on them, when you started finding them scummy.
I believe I asked you long ago something like "what led Cobbler to claim?"Yosarian2 wrote:The attack on Cobbler is particularly suspicious because Cobbler claims to be a town PR that cult can't recruit to serve their purposes.
Yes, it's a completely unconfirmable claim that town are very reluctant to lynch. That's why it's a great scum claim.
That being said, you'll notice I never actually voted him at any point today, because I'm uncomfortable with the risk that he might be telling the truth.
But if you're town and confident that xvart is scum, why did you say so little about him and ask him no questions?
DrippingGoofball, 1215 wrote:Herodotus wrote:Not on day one of this game from someone who is likely to be lynched. I think it's null.Katsuki wrote:Come to think of it, a vig list is extremely anti-town.
It is. It is quite scummy. Think about it.
Tanarin, 1221 wrote:Ok it is post like xvart's last post that really make me feel like he is not part of a cult at this point. As was pointed out before, most of the main case against Xvart was the fact he was most likely a recruit choice and it pretty much has stuck all game.
Unvote
@Yos2: Ok you believe Cobbler is scum, yet you are on xvart? Still feel that is the right place to put your vote?