Mini Normal 1187: Game Over

[hiplop]

VOTE: Nin

[nintendoaddict1]

There's no acknowledgement at all that Pine might possibly have been scum.

Actually, there was.

he could be mafia RBer quite easily...

Here's a recently completed game I was in where there was a mafia RB and they claimed town RB.

http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.ph ... 3#p3106933

Reply 814 he claims.

Unvote

Why don't you buy the claims, bob? I know the RB claim was a bit sketchy, but what about Barry?

[Heliman]

On top of him claiming, I said why I thought Pine was town earlier in the thread, go back and read it.

I said you never spoke out against the wagon. The entire reason pine was lynched was because he put off a big argument for the longest time and then just role claimed instead. In fact, you also said yourself in #666 that "the RB claim was a bit sketchy."

[nintendoaddict1]

On top of him claiming, I said why I thought Pine was town earlier in the thread, go back and read it.

I said you never spoke out against the wagon. The entire reason pine was lynched was because he put off a big argument for the longest time and then just role claimed instead. In fact, you also said yourself in #666 that "the RB claim was a bit sketchy."

Sketchy? Yes. Unbelievable? No.

[Heliman]

Reason enough to lynch? I, and six other players say yes.

[nintendoaddict1]

Reason enough to lynch? I, and six other players say yes.

What about it? Good for you, the seven of you lynched a townie. And yet I'm the one who looks scummy here.

[Heliman]

Because according to you the 7th person to vote is somehow deserving a vig kill before we even know the flip.

[nintendoaddict1]

Because according to you the 7th person to vote is somehow deserving a vig kill before we even know the flip.

No, just the hammer happened to be the 7th. And it was a

claimed PR

, how many times do I need to say that?

[Heliman]

Apparently as much as you can once pine is already dead. We didn't see you doing that yesterday, did we?

[foilist13]

Also, the only other wagon available at the time was on a

claimed PR

, and a significantly more believable one by most people's standards. So I'm scummy because we are approaching deadline, one wagon at L-1 the other a few votes away from a lynch, the threat of a no lynch looming, both wagons on claimed PR's, and I chose to hammer. That's what makes me scummy?

[nintendoaddict1]

Apparently as much as you can once pine is already dead. We didn't see you doing that yesterday, did we?

Yes, actually, I did do that yesterday.

why the hell lynch a claimed PR?

Oh, and Foil, I still think it's better to NL than to lynch someone who was probably town and a PR. If they were VT, however, it would not be as much of a loss, and would only be a null tell on you.

[Barry Allen]

Yes, actually, I did do that yesterday.

why the hell lynch a claimed PR?

Wait a minute...you're quoting that post to make it sound like you were warning us away from the lynch, when that quote comes from the post you made

after the hammer

.
Here's the link to the post you're quoting:.

VOTE: nintendoaddict

[nintendoaddict1]

All right, I'm the

Sensor

.

[Barry Allen]

OK, then, how many scum were on the BW yesterday?

[nintendoaddict1]

OK, then, how many scum were on the BW yesterday?

2 scum.

[Barry Allen]

OK, then, how many scum were on the BW yesterday?

2 scum.

If this is a true claim, then let's look at the votes from yesterday:
ace5993, Giitah, Scumhunter, archaebob, Barry Allen, Heliman, and foilist13 are the list of who voted for Pine. I'm tracker, bob looks VERY town, ace looks town to me, foilist looks more town than not, leaving 2/3 scum for:

Giitah
Scumhunter
Heliman

Part of me hopes the claim is not true, because how many roles are we gonna out in the first two days? But, assuming it IS true, I could actually believe 2 scum could be in that group. I'm gonna

UNVOTE

to keep a BW from getting too large before we have a chance to talk more.

[Giitah]

Hold up, what the HELL? Can somebody unvote and take him off L-1 before we get some gutsy fool to hammer him before we even talk?

At this point we're at L-1 and we've got no official vote count, assuming I'm counting correctly. If anyone votes Nintendo past this point they've got a good piece of shit to say, so I'm going to put this down before I start making any talk.

[foilist13]

WTF is a sensor?

[Barry Allen]

A sensor can tell how many scum were on the lynch vote from the day before. That's why I asked that question. I think we do need to pull off the votes for now until we can talk a bit more.

[Barry Allen]

btw - Giitah's post could possibly have been in progress when my unvote hit the thread. That leaves scumhunter and Heliman to hear from. Come to think of it, the nintendoaddict BW started with Heliman. Hmmmm....

[Barry Allen]

one last note - sorry for the triple post, but I have two things, actually.

1. I'm feeling VERY dumb for my vote having taken us to L-1, as that goes against everything I believe in, particularly this early. I just didn't count and am glad we didn't have a quickhammer prior to nin's claim.
2. If nin's claim is accurate, and if my assumption about where 2/3 scum would be given nin's claim that 2 scum were in that lynch vote, I think we should hear a defense from Heliman and scumhunter. Let's start that process:

VOTE: Heliman

[Giitah]

You're missing another piece of evidence there, Barry. I don't think we'd only have two scum in a game of 13 players, right?

Pine - 7 (ace5993, Giitah, Scumhunter, archaebob, Barry Allen, Heliman, foilist13)
Barry Allen - 2 (Valern, hiplop)
DemonHybrid - 1 (

Pine

)

Not Voting - LittleGrey,

DemonHybrid

,

nintendoaddict1

DemonHybrid's dead and nintendoaddict has to be town if we're even going to play with this evidence. Pine's also town by death call. That leaves hiplop, Valern, and LittleGrey (Jilyne's replacement) as possible suspects.

[Barry Allen]

We aren't that far apart in the count here. I personally believe we have 2/3 scum from you, scumhunter and Heliman, and that would leave 1/3 scum from Valern, Hiplop and LittleGrey (or whoever replaced LittleGrey). Personally, I think we have better odds going after the 2/3 first.

[Giitah]

@Nintendo
What warranted Foil to be vigged for having dropped a hammer vote?

[nintendoaddict1]

@Nintendo
What warranted Foil to be vigged for having dropped a hammer vote?

*facepalm*

You haven't been reading.
Pine was a claimed PR, that's what.