Mini 1228: 80's Mafia: Everyone wins. (Mod error)

[Maruchan]

Its the third time I have heard this argument, Scum supposedly answer questions so as to get off topic on useless tangents that distract town.

However, every time I have seen them asked, it causes town interaction, like so. The refusal to answer makes you curious, so you ask why, then they have to explain the nit starts back-and-forth.

Wouldn't it make more sense for the asker of the questions to be scum? Although I see your point, we shouldn't be getting into pointless arguments when we could be scumhunting.

@DRK - It says RQS is good, but only if you ask good questions.

/facedesk.

Yes I meant ask not answer

[Maruchan]

RQS TIME!

1. DRK, would you marry me?
2. DRK, would you marry me?
3. DRK, would you marry me?


RQS OVER

[Captain Corporal]

Step 1. Maru asks RQS questions.
Step 2. DRK now wants to kill Maru, but still marries him.
Step 3. Maru now has a wife who wants to kill him.

Hold on. Wife who wants to kill husband? Sounds normal to me

[Maruchan]

PERFECT PLAN IS IT NOT?!?!?!?!?

[Captain Corporal]

Define "perfect".

[haoala]

Maruchan, role info or not, is obv-town and, unlike you, he has actually been looking for scum. But I'll humor you for a second. Your previous post implied that you've called Maruchan's actions scummy before and I believe you 254%. Can you just remind me where you did so?

This is nonsense.
1. Maruchan admitted that he wasn't looking for scum.
2. ISO Umbrage. He's been calling Maruchan scummy all along.

Very suspicious, DRK.

[DeathRowKitty]

1. Where?
2. Where?

[haoala]

1. Post 102
2. Post 25, 77

Ok maybe 2 isn't so convincing but I got that impression from him earlier in the game.

[haoala]

CC, now that you're here, what do you think of how the game has progressed so far?

[Maruchan]

1. Where?
2. Where?

doh, for about 2 seconds I thought you were making a clever joke at my clever joke of a RQS.

[Captain Corporal]

@Haoala - The only notable thing that's happened is DRK's town thing on Maru, which hasn't really done too much for me, other than give me a townread on Maru.
I'll be very happy when the game starts so we can start doing stuff

[DeathRowKitty]

@haoala

(It would have been nice if those numbers had been linked so I didn't have to go running around the game thread >_>)

Post 102 isn't an admission that Maruchan was never trying to find scum and, if you read his earlier posts, he was.

I don't accept post 25 as Umbrage calling Maruchan scummy for 2 reasons:
1) It looks like a random vote to me.
2) As late as post 56, Umbrage doesn't believe that people should be forming opinions on who's scum.

Post 77...maybe at a stretch. It doesn't have what I was really looking for though: something that unequivocally says "Hi, I'm Umbrage and I think Maruchan is scum." That post initially read to me as Umbrage just suggesting a plan that made no logical sense, as opposed to anything based on alignments.

@Maruchan
1. Where?
2. When?
3. Sure!

[Captain Corporal]

So DRK answers Maru's questions but not mine. WHAT IS THIS?!
I know.

[haoala]

DRK

1. So, where was Maruchan scumhunting?
2. Well it surprised me that you jumped at him for not calling Maruchan scum earlier, when it appears to me that he had.

[haoala]

@Haoala - The only notable thing that's happened is DRK's town thing on Maru, which hasn't really done too much for me, other than give me a townread on Maru.
I'll be very happy when the game starts so we can start doing stuff

So you believe DRK's claim?

[Bogre]

Forgot about this too til I got the reminder. /confirm.

Mego is scum. Making up specific numbers is scummy. Really pushing the DRK thing as a ploy seems forcefully distracting.

VOTE: Mego

[haoala]

Mego is scum. Making up specific numbers is scummy. Really pushing the DRK thing as a ploy seems forcefully distracting.

Have you any experience playing with DRK?

[DeathRowKitty]

Making up specific numbers is scummy.

QFT and as an excuse to sheep

Unvote: 2birds1cup

Vote: Meg

an

o

[Bogre]

Mego is scum. Making up specific numbers is scummy. Really pushing the DRK thing as a ploy seems forcefully distracting.

Have you any experience playing with DRK?

Don't believe so.

[Captain Corporal]

So you believe DRK's claim?

Anyway you look at it, Maruchan is probably town. For example:
1. If DRK was scum and Maru was town, DRK would put the claim out the to earn towncred with Maru, and the rest of the town.
2. If DRK was town and Maru was scum... Well, since our roles aren't bastard, we can assume this could never happen.
3. If they were both scum, this would be a bad play by them, as buddying that obviously would get them both killed in the end.
4. They could both be town.

1 and 4 are the most likely out of these answers, and in both scenarios Maru is town

[haoala]

So the best play from here would be to lynch DRK today?

[DeathRowKitty]

The best play from here would be to lynch scum today.

[Maruchan]

@Maruchan
1. Where?
2. When?
3. Sure!

USA
Tomorrow
WOOT WOOT

@Captain Corporal, you're not as important as me.

[haoala]

According to CC, you have a 50% chance of being scum. Statistically, lynching you would be wiser than lynching anyone else. That's the situation at this point.

[DeathRowKitty]

According to CC, I am scum in 2 out of 4 likely circumstances. However, the likelihood of each of those 4 situations being true is dependent on my likelihood of being scum.