Open 319: Jungle Republic - Day 5: Calamity *GAME OVER*

[Thor665]

4 scum left are thor, fitz, sky and DJ.

What's the case for DonJosh scum? I don't see it at all.

[Shadowmod]

Thor665 (4/5) - havingfitz , whispersilk , BBmolla , DeityKabuto DeityKabuto (1/5) - Thor665 CMPunk (1/5) - DonJosh Not Voting (2/8): Sky, CMPunk With 8 Players alive it requires 5 Votes to lynch / 4 to nolynch. Deadline will be reached on Monday September 19th 2011, 6:00 p.m. Forum Time [UTC-6].

(expired on 2011-09-19 18:00:00)

till Day 3 Deadline

[DonJosh]

Why are there no votes on CM? This puzzles me.

[Thor665]

Because scum would much rather mislynch me than bus/mislynch CM? That would be my guess.

[CMPunk]

Why are there no votes on CM? This puzzles me.

you keep talking about me being scum, but have done nothing to actually back up your thinking I am scum.

[CMPunk]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: BBmolla

Still convinced it is between he and DK for last scum, and both will flip in an anti-town role

[CMPunk]

or I could hammer Thor, despite thinking he is town... nah

[Shadowmod]

Thor665 (4/5) - havingfitz , whispersilk , BBmolla , DeityKabuto DeityKabuto (1/5) - Thor665 CMPunk (1/5) - DonJosh BBmolla (1/5) - CMPunk Not Voting (1/8): Sky With 8 Players alive it requires 5 Votes to lynch / 4 to nolynch. Deadline will be reached on Monday September 19th 2011, 6:00 p.m. Forum Time [UTC-6].

(expired on 2011-09-19 18:00:00)

till Day 3 Deadline

[Thor665]

The inherent blindness of fitz's case is trying to desperately wave and make him admit it exists in that last vote count.
I predict more sturm and drang though.

[havingfitz]

Labor Day prod dodge.

[whispersilk]

Come on scum, just hammer your buddy ffs. I haven't got all day.

[BBmolla]

Come on scum, just hammer your buddy ffs. I haven't got all day.

[whispersilk]

Curious that Sky isn't voting, huh?

I'm telling you, Sky is scum too.

[havingfitz]

Is Sky v/LA or been prodded?

[Sky]

or I could hammer Thor, despite thinking he is town... nah

Thanks for reminding us of this oh so town action of yours.

Vote: CMPunk

Come on scum, just hammer your buddy ffs. I haven't got all day.

Is this a blank shot you're firing at me? Do you have something you want to tell me? This means nothing.

Is Sky v/LA or been prodded?

Yeah I've been V/LA. Good to see you reading the thread.

The only reason I see the vote for Thor is because he has two mislynches on his record? Yes or no? I hope you are all awware that he isn't the only one here that has done this. I'm looking at you CMPunk

[Thor665]

I'm really not going to get any DK support at all, am I? Nobody is even discussing him as a suspect - this concerns me.

[Thor665]

@Sky - would you back this play?

Unvote: DK
Vote: havingfitz

I feel more confident with that then I do for Punk.

[Sky]

I do have DK on my scum list. fitz not so much but he could get there.

Why don't you like CMPunk?

[Thor665]

We just had one scum lynched from the three player block - so it downshifts the likelihood of more scum being there because 2 of the other 4 scum probably wouldn't have been that tight onto their buddy. So, if CM is a Wolf I'm reasonably in support of the lynch idea in general, but I'm guessing only one Wolf was even on that wagon, and there's a smaller pool if we're hunting wolves. If we're hunting mafia I'd like to lynch either DK or DonJosh.

[Thor665]

*hunting wolves off the wagon.

[havingfitz]

Well we had a mislynch. I think that despite Thor having two on his record I am not fully convinced he scum. I would like to count fitz on this wagon since he placed blind at his number two spot, a kind of insurance if blind did flip scum. CMPunk is still scum as ever, but I need to reread.

I found BF to be somewhat suspect and if it had come down to the deadline and facing a no-lynch, I would have switched to BF to avoid the no-lynch. But the fact is I was not on his wagon which forced more scum to act in order to acheive it.

The inherent blindness of fitz's case is trying to desperately wave and make him admit it exists in that last vote count.

What blindness? You have been the main advocate of two mislynches and your actions D1 WRT Ray still reek. Please type slowly for me and explain what the post above refers to and feel free to include a reason other than OMGUS for your vote on me

The only reason I see the vote for Thor is because he has two mislynches on his record? Yes or no? I hope you are all awware that he isn't the only one here that has done this. I'm looking at you CMPunk

I realize that. I can't vote for all of them though and Thor has been the worst perpetrator of the mislynches. FTR the others on both mislynches have been CMPunk and BBMolla. CMPunk is my #2 suspect and would be my next option failing a Thor lynch. BBMolla hasn't done much to raise my suspicions but at the same time I would not annoint her town.

Thor seems to be flailing a bit. Voting a defenseless v/LA DK for no valid reason (pardon...I mean for PoE) and then bailing on that stellar case for the OMGUS vote on me and then the contradiction in bold below posted within a fairly short timeframe by Thorscum....

4 scum left are thor, fitz, sky and DJ.

What's the case for DonJosh scum? I don't see it at all.

We just had one scum lynched from the three player block - so it downshifts the likelihood of more scum being there because 2 of the other 4 scum probably wouldn't have been that tight onto their buddy. So, if CM is a Wolf I'm reasonably in support of the lynch idea in general, but I'm guessing only one Wolf was even on that wagon, and there's a smaller pool if we're hunting wolves.

If we're hunting mafia I'd like to lynch either DK or DonJosh.

[whispersilk]

LOL that's hilarious. Good catch fitz.

[whispersilk]

CM, your vote on BB is absolutely useless. Can you please put it where it's going to make a difference?

...hint...

Spoiler:

ON THOR

[Thor665]

What blindness? You have been the main advocate of two mislynches and your actions D1 WRT Ray still reek. Please type slowly for me and explain what the post above refers to and feel free to include a reason other than OMGUS for your vote on me

Blindness 1 - your case is based on "lol - leading mislynces = scum which is so far removed from sanity that it's starting to honk me off. You think I cant show you a game where I was town and led two mislynches in a row? Really? REALLY!?! You think I couldn't find a town game of yours where you were on two mislynches in a row?

2. The other blindness is that your case is based off of "lol, scum iz Thor because otherwise people would be more eager to lynch Thor" and here we are with your craptacular case and a wagon of sheep.

Also - DK is lurking but still had time to pop in and support wagon?
Eyes fitz - eyes. You're scum for intentional blindness...and OMGUS.

the contradiction in bold below posted within a fairly short timeframe by Thorscum....

Oh my gawd fitz, how bad do you think I am?
There is no contradiction there - I have very clearly shown PoE for the Josh/DK logic of why one of them is mafia - whether or not I personally have a town read on Josh has very little to do with where I think we should be lynching if we want to lynch mafia except insomuch as I've clearly stated I'd rather lunch DK first. There is no contradiction there at all and I proudly claim both statements as mine.

LOL that's hilarious. Good catch fitz.

You need to start stepping up your game - seriously. Explain how there is a contradiction there, I'd like to see you do so. Explain my logic and the contradiction inherent in it. Please, do so now.

[whispersilk]

You ask me what the case is on DJ,

"because you don't see it at all"

, yet you tell someone else that you want to hunt scum by

"lynching either DK or DJ"

.

Why are you telling me you see no case on DJ, when in your next breath you say that you would be happy to lynch him. You do realise that the town CANNOT afford to have another mislynch. Why on earth would you be happy to lynch someone you don't see a case on at all?