NY139: Underground Mafia (Game over!)

[SodaSpirit17]

haha that didn't end in the best way. since we both got killed.

Anyways who ya thinkin should hang?

[eep]

You just realized? IDK your votes are kinda bad sometimes. Although the fact you agree with me about Uprising makes me think lesser of you

You seem be conflating disagreeing with you to being scum.

That's a dangerous mistake to make, son. Although it does throw my read of you off a bit.

[sorgster]

Daybird's still silent after my vote on him. Almost 5 days without a post now.

Unvote
Vote AntB

He is at l-2. 2 more then we can lynch him.

[SodaSpirit17]

This post seems kinda desperate.

I was reading through the topic and then I randomly see a post from Daybid and forgot he was even in the game.

[redFF]

how many scum are there sorgster?

you never answered, just ignored. How many scum do you think there are? I think it was scummy to just not even respond to this post.

[sorgster]

how many scum are there sorgster?

you never answered, just ignored. How many scum do you think there are? I think it was scummy to just not even respond to this post.

That was a serious question? It's scummy not to respond to that? Don't make me laugh. Especially as I gave the answer the post right before it.

[sorgster]

Ebwop: Also the original question was how many scum are there? The second question asks for an opinion.

[implosion]

Vote Count 3.6

AntB - 5 (Vifam, StevieT92, TheAwesomeAll, SodaSpirit17, sorgster) (L-3)

Vifam
redFF - 1 (AntB)
Uprising
sorgster - 1 (redFF)
StevieT92
SodaSpirit17 - 2 (eep, Hiraki)
Daybid
nocase
TheAwesomeAll
Stringer Bell - 2 (nocase, trekker)
Hiraki
eep
trekker
Not voting - 3 (Daybid, Stringer Bell, Uprising)

With 14 alive, 8 votes are required to lynch.

Deadline is in (expired on 2011-09-25 17:00:00).

If you

ever

notice a mistake that I've made with the votecount (or elsewhere) don't hesitate to tell me.

Now searching for a replacement for Daybid. Also, prodding nocase.

[eep]

can someone please tell me what the case against antb is?

[sorgster]

He hasn't been posting much other than fluff

[sorgster]

EBwop:I mean his two first post and his huge post more than anything else have had nothing in them.

[eep]

isn't this the same reason that a lot of people voted xanatos?

I mean is there really no one else you find more suspicious? because "he's posting fluff" is more of a null tell than a scum tell.

[Hiraki]

Do I need to make a part II?

Why can't I connect with these kids?

[StevieT92]

Somebody asked for a case against AntB.

Player -> Score

0=ZOMG LYNCH! 10=Scum Hunter Elite

Vifam -> 4
redFF -> 4
sorgster -> 4
TheRainMan -> 6
TheAwesomeAll -> 4
paraffin -> 4
eep -> 6
trekker -> 4

If you're not listed, you're neutral. This is taking the d1 lynch flip into consideration.

This is his first attempt at analysis, see how he doesn't take a stand on anybody and instead is wishy washy as hell.

Last one before I sleep.

My reads jumped all over the place, and for all the interaction I had D1 I may as well be a N1 replacement. I'll admit my reads are very middle of the road and hardly even worth mentioning. But as they are, that's what they are. When I'm back from Edinburgh, you may find a case, you may not.

If you want a FoS from me so badly, it would be vifam and redff currently. redff always stinks of scum to me however and I will need to reread vifam.

Vifam and RedFF both seem very town to me, and also how would your reads not be worth mentioning? scummy

@vifam
I re-read you, nothing changed. And you've ISO'd me? srsly? lol
You'll learn I am quite a vague person. I have my own method/madness thing going on.

---

The point of the list is to get you looking at players closer than you normally would and to formulate your own thoughts on them, If you really must know, 2 are town. Shift everyone by the same and they are together.

---

@redff1
You were almost on that list too btw... thought you'd like to know that.

This post reeks of scum.. using vagueness to defend youself? ridiculous. Also he defends is wishy washy list by making it even more ambiguous.

If you want us to give you reasoning for YOUR scumreads you have another thing coming.

Nice threat. And its to make you look closer at the players I've mentioned...

---

QFT. Someone who has something to hide, and makes it blatantly obvious that they are hiding something, is scum.

Town hide things all the time. Also scum wouldn't blatantly hide something. The only thing I'm hiding is if they are town/scum. The people on that list are my strongest reads, one way or the other.

Scum will pick me off if I'm right, or try and and frame me if I'm wrong. All I'm doing is making them think.

---

No surprise at the redFF vote

---

Anyone voting me for that list needs to step back and use their brains and really think about it.

---

Self-voter ¬_¬

---

You really think if me and david were scum together we'd be happy at being the only two wagons? If it was the case, that would be epic bussing.

---

Self affirming townie scum... I hate those guys.

---

"I'm VT - Hey mod, can my ability hit anyone or my wagon?" - derp

---

Everyone is being very vague this game.. its interesting.

David needs to be lynched, he's basically hit self-destruct and town don't do that.

Seeing as everyone is bitching about my list, I'll turn it into the scums shopping list.
TRM and Hiraki are town, the rest are probsscum. Sorgster is VI/Newbtown.
redFF is also on the list now.

You label everyone in the game except for 3 people as "probscum". Scummy. The argument about you and David not being scum together is WIFOM as hell, also looking back lynching david instead of you was a great move for the mafia. The "scum will pick me off if i'm right" is incredibly scummy.

Also, uprising is town, if she was scum she'd be all over this like a rash.

Yeah but it'll help for after I flip to see who associates who with me....

Hiraki, you better hit scum dude... UNVOTE: Vifam VOTE: redFF

Sheeping Hiraki is not pro-town.

That's my case, I picked the crappiest of his posts. He seems pretty scum to me.

Steve

[Hiraki]

Yeah.

He's town for like half of those points.

[eep]

yeah, I'm not getting a scum read.

minor point, but when he said that "the rest are probscum" I think he was talking about the rest of the people on that list he made, not the rest of the players. how would accusing most of the living players make any sense?

steviet92 is a bit higher on my scumlist now, though

[redFF]

Yeah there are a bunch of people in this game (antb and uprising come to mind), who just say they have scum reads/town reads on people with no reasoning. It's annoying but I'm not sure if it's scummy just yet.

[Hiraki]

Does Steve get points for trying though?

Hmm.

ergh. This is an interesting question, self.

[TheAwesomeAll]

eep/hiraki (mb both) and antb. mark my words

[trekker]

I don't want to lynch AntB.

SodaSpirit came it and posted reads that seem a bit faked to me and then just jumped on the AntB wagon, something I don't like at all.

[trekker]

came in*

[AntB]

You missed the entire day 1, and you rub me the wrong way, because you're trying to mislead us into people you know are town...

This is your entire reasoning? 36 pages, and this is all you get... I retract my read on TheRainMan - you just blew it clean apart.

You thought I was scum the entire time in Newbie, and we both rolled town. Does this change your opinion?

I love how you used one of your first games on site AND A NEWBIE GAME as meta to try and sway someone...
VOTE: SodaSpirit17

---

@StevieT92
Point 1: Yes, it's very middle of the road, yes it's non-commital - I work better live than watching re-runs.
Point 2: Put it back in context.

If

you want a FoS from me so badly, it would be vifam and redff currently. redff always stinks of scum to me however and I will need to reread vifam.

Point 3:

This is constructed to deliberately misrepresent me.

The list you mention is completely different to the list I am referring too at that time.
Point 4: You tell me who the players I've mentioned as probscum are please, because there are actually a few people I've made very minimal mention of or interaction with currently.
Point 5: Hiraki is town, he doesn't mess around and gets straight to the point. Put me in dip and shear my wool, I'm sheeping his redFF vote.

[Hiraki]

hiraki

[Hiraki]

I don't want to lynch AntB.

SodaSpirit came it and posted reads that seem a bit faked to me and then just jumped on the AntB wagon, something I don't like at all.

EWBOP:

And this is why I like you more than trekker.

Though I love you both equally, really.

[eep]

I don't want to lynch AntB.

SodaSpirit came it and posted reads that seem a bit faked to me and then just jumped on the AntB wagon, something I don't like at all.

is stringer bell a better lynch than sodaspirit?