NY139: Underground Mafia (Game over!)

[trekker]

Vote: eep

I'm done. Cool. Good.

[eep]

Great. Actually stay done, this time.

[eep]

Here's my rereads:
AntB:

Uprising is screaming scum but IRC meta is null at best on forums.

Also, uprising is town, if she was scum she'd be all over this like a rash.

Didn't notice this before.
AntB, what made you change your mind?

Vifam: confirmed town by dead hiraki and by sorgster.

Uprising:
AntB's been buddying her a bunch; I'm inclined to believe that she's town regardless of his alignment. Also,

I know I'm scummy. I'm often scummy.

I'm so afraid to vote because I really don't want to lose.

Jesus. Rereading the game.

These make me think she's town. Additionally, she posted a total list of her thoughts on living players on day 3; the fact that she's at least paying attention to the game is a plus in my book.

sorgster: is confirmed town by Vifam, although Vifam has technically not commented on how sorgster's aligment was confirmed to him. If sorgster turns out to be scum because Vifam was careless about confirming that, I'm going to be pissed.

StevieT92:

I have town on Vifam, Trekker, Hiraki, and yes, Sorgster.

Right now I have as scum RedFF and AntB. As weak scum TAA, nocase, and eep. AntB has the largest wagon therefore I'm going to

Vote: AntB

IDK who to vote, so I'm gonna wagon AntB.

vote: AntB

You know.

IF FEEL REALLY GOOD WITH THIS REDFF VOTE.

but i can change to stevie.

and only stevie.

redff is town and antb is the smelliest scum right now. why are u not voting antb.

Somebody asked for a case against AntB.

<truncated>

I can get behind a SodaSpirit wagon.

unvote, vote: AntB

@AntB you are right that i misrepresented you on that one point, I read it out of context. As far as the rest of the case goes, I realized while reading it that it was not the strongest, however there is some stuff there that is suspicious.

These contain the first three votes that stevie cast on day 3. Yes, all three of them are on AntB. What?

I can get behind a SodaSpirit wagon.

unvote, vote: AntB

you can get behind a SodaSpirit wagon when it's obvious that

AntB and Soda are not on the same scumteam

?

1. I didn't notice that read. 2.

It doesn't matter, the important thing is that we lynch scum today.

Period. We need to get this game going in the right direction, we'll worry about the implications tomorrow.

Someone, please explain this to me.

Also, if he is so suspicious of AntB and soda is clearly NOT scum, why has Stevie not pressed any case against AntB since then?

battousai:
I don't notice anything exceptional in his posts, but I have a gut impression that he's town.

Stringer Bell:
I ultimately have a null read on him. trekker has been gunning for him based on two posts, from what I can tell, and he hasn't really done anything further to warrant suspicion. I thought trekker might have had special information on him, but he seems to have outright denied that, so I don't really see a case on him.

trekker:
gah I can't believe I forgot about this:

2/2 of scum, Last one's probably gonna be between TAA and Daybid as nocase said.

Is this a scumslip? He seems to imply that he knows that there are three mafia.

If this is the case, then I'm taking a guess that the three scum are trekker, antb, and steviet92. But this also means that we should NOT massclaim, and I apologize for pushing for that before really looking through things.

[StevieT92]

i'm laughing my ass off at sorgster's reads.

[sorgster]

I forgot to add trekker to that list.

Stringer bell seems to be pushed for a lynch way too much without any reason. Batt and eep are starting to give a lot of town vibes to me.I know vifam is town. AntB has always seemed scummy. Trekker is pushing too hard for a lynch of stringer bell. Uprising is a null tell. the other two are lurkers.

I've been pushing for a lynch? I don't recall pushing any sort of lynch. I think we should take it slow, maybe massclaim if it gets too close to the deadline, but the last thing we need right now is for people to be pushing quicklynches, unless we have someone who has confirmed scum.

I meant trekker was pushing you for a lynch. That was a mistake.

[implosion]

Vote Count 5.3

AntB - 1 (Vifam)
Vifam
Uprising
sorgster
StevieT92 - 1 (eep)
Battousai
CSL - 1 (sorgster)
Stringer Bell
eep - 2 (StevieT92, trekker)
trekker
Not voting - 5 (AntB, Uprising, CSL, Stringer Bell, Battousai)

With 10 alive, 6 votes are required to lynch.

Deadline is in (expired on 2011-10-19 17:00:00).

If you

ever

notice a mistake that I've made with the votecount (or elsewhere) don't hesitate to tell me.

Prodding Vifam.

[Battousai]

Also prod AntB, plz.

I want to know why Vifam (confirmed town) says AntB is scum

[implosion]

AntB declared V/LA.

[Vifam]

Posting.

[trekker]

No, I've never been in a game with more than three scum. Is it different here?

[eep]

what size games have you been playing?

plenty of people suggested that there were very likely 4 scum total so it is weird to me that you were looking for 3.

[Battousai]

If not enough people want to play...

Vote for player abandonment!

Failure for anything to be done is cause for abandonment. I've been trying to get information out of Vifam for a while now, and he just refuses to play. Something needs to be done.

[sorgster]

i'm laughing my ass off at sorgster's reads.

May I guess it is because you are scum and I put one of your buddies in the town spot? Why else would you? Please die. You or CSL for abondoning game.

[eep]

yeah, it's frustrating when we even have confirmed townies just dodging questions

steviet92 is acting just like taa

I feel like csl has a bit more of an excuse because he did come in as a replacement pretty late game, but I would still like to hear from him asap.

[trekker]

Sorgster....

[Vifam]

I've already built up a case on AntB a while back.

His recent posting isn't any better.

[Battousai]

A long, long while back... page 23. I was hoping you'd make a case on him since that read was > half a game ago.

[Vifam]

A long, long while back... page 23. I was hoping you'd make a case on him since that read was > half a game ago.

Sure, I'll get on it, AntBscum needs to die.

[Uprising]

I think that I want to lynch Stevie. I'm not sure, but... Situations like this are the reason I'm not the biggest fan of forum mafia.


Stringer feels town now, though.

[eep]

also, vifam, is there anyone else you think is notably scummy?

[eep]

@mod, I will be v/la until Tuesday.

[Battousai]

Mod: Due to the inactivity, maybe shortening the deadline will get people to actually play

[implosion]

CSL and Stringer Bell are being prodded.
Deadline is in under two weeks. So. Pick up the activity!
If activity in general doesn't pick up, I'll send out a massprod.

[Stringer Bell]

I got the prod, I'm keeping up with reading and all that this time but there's really nothing for me to say. I guess I should just post once a day, even if I got nothing new to say..

[sorgster]

CSL hasn't been posting much, just lynch him. I think scum have got by this game by lurking.

@All, who are your top 3 scumreads and why.