Roiight finished my exam won't have another one for two weeks so I can contribute properly now.
First and foremost: people who have labelled me as scummy for not contributed are either blind or scum.
In post 105, el simo wrote:And on that note: I have an exam today and tomorrow so don't expect too much out of me for the mo.
I clearly stated in my third post that I had limited activity. Targeting me for not being able to post content when I warned you in advance that I wasn't going to be able to is nonsensical.
I don't know who is worse, Soben for starting it or the Oddy for hopping on the wagon, labelling me as some what scummy repeating everything already said about me just so they can look like they have done some actual work.
What bugs me about this is both Soben and Oddy are hybrids, so four very good players have made this oversight that is just nonsense. What's more frustrating is that other than this, I have a pretty strong town read on both of them. At this point in time I don't know what to make of it, so I'll leave it and come back when it might be more useful.
Redtail on the other hand is clearly sheeping, how ever he has the fortune that both Soben and Oddy have stronger reads than me, so his vote is actually the first. Funny though how he targets me for having no substance in my posting, when he hardly has any himself. Yonzy is guilty of this too. Lots of scummies go to both these players.
On Timeater/Uphill: Timeaters aggression doesn't seem genuine to me. He attacks Uphill, claims he is caught scum then noobscum, then immediately moves his vote. Uphill was clearly trying to push out of RVS, this is evident in that his vote, the third in the game, was the second on Soben. <- no one bandwagons in RVS unless they are fishing for reactions, and boy did Timeater react. I find it amusing that he is still pushing Uphill four pages in on one sentence constructed to start discussion. His "powerlurking" comment is a huge stretch and his so called deflection is just a play on words, clearly taking the micky out of his question, "what's up with your vote?" More so, there was nothing for him to deflect, so how can he be deflecting?
After placing my vote on him I was actually expecting him to back off and claim he was fishing for reactions. The fact that he has pursued with this case even though he isn't voting him smells more of cover up than a genuine read.
Uphill strikes me as very town, his last post before replacement was very good. His jump on KB was good and his jump on bion was good. <- Clearly a townsman hunting.
Btw
Timeater, who blew up my house, the grenade or the guy who threw it?
On Katty B: 100% agree with Oddy. But what is more telling for me is her
last post. She backs out of her vote, claiming that is was terribad. Despite unvoting and admitting her vote was bad, she goes on to defend her vote. Further more, the reasons she gave do not align with her IIoA post. She claims her vote was because he didn't seem like he was trying to randomly voting or trying to generate discussion, yet her IIoA (which she claimed as evidence for why he is scum) was about how it is scummy to advocate a random lynching. Inconsistent.
On that note, Retro you've improved a lot! Also: I hate hybrids, it's like trying to read two players! Oddy and Soben are the only hybrids, correct?
On Treznor: I'm very familiar with his meta and so far he is sticking to it. He won't be getting my vote any time soon.
So to summarise:
vote: Katty Bard.
She is my top read, follow by Timeater. I'm suspicious of Redtail and Yonzy, but have not got enough from them to make any big statements yet.
Lastly:
Hybrids, can you please not post as two people?
It is unfair. Discuss your reads in a quick topic and post them as one. The way you two are posting, we are currently playing with 15 people. All four of you may as well be posting in separate accounts. It's frustrating when I read Retro but then get a conflicting read on his partner etc etc.
In #98 I said she was null-to-scum, in 162 I moved towards scum. I don't see how those are actually all that contradictory. I openly state in 98 that the only reason that I was holding back from full-on scumread on Katty for IIoA is that I know I'm prone to it as well, even when I'm town (which is the only alignment I've actually had on this site).
