Mini 1252 - My Not So Humble Abode - Game Over

[monk]

it has been brought to my attention that I did state Delta's role incorrectly, the following is the relevant part of his role pm

You are a Town BodyGuard.
During the night you may choose someone to protect. If they are targeted you have a 50% of learning the killer and a 50% chance of dying instead.

[Thomith]

sorry for not posting, life got on the top of me, thanks monk for stepping in.

as stated Dealtawave,

Town Bodyguard

Lynched Day 2.
Any quicktopics not open are now open.

[monk]

You awake and find two of your number missing...

Rainbowdash,

Town - One-Shot Vigilante

, killed Night 2

Johman,

Mafia - Goon

, killed Night 2

Deadline

with 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch

Not Voting (8) - 2birds1stone, Beck, bvoigt, Draken, Sir Bastion, weirdbeard, Scumhunter, Palmar

[monk]

thread is now unlocked, get to it guys...

Nightfall is in two weeks

Just as a note, I haven't heard from Thomith all night phase, I promise to keep closer eye on this game from now on since he has disappeared, effectively treat me as your moderator, I will endeavour to have vote counts every 3 pages or so.

[Draken]

So Delta really was town bodyguard...
Rainbowdash was killed by mafia, but not before taking out Johman it seems.

Sir bastion... How do you respond to the bodyguard debacle?

[Scumhunter]

RIP Pony

[Sir Bastion]

So Delta really was town bodyguard...
Rainbowdash was killed by mafia, but not before taking out Johman it seems.

Sir bastion... How do you respond to the bodyguard debacle?

by pming both mods for clarification which I already did. Monk said he'd ask the review board about it and Thomith hasnt been online since I sent it so no response from him yet.


Next on the list Johman scum means 2bird needs to defend himself, he claimed neighbour with johman. I dont know if its revealed when someone dies if they were neighbour or not aswell. Clearly it didnt for johman and I am not after yesterday going to go through another round of rules define the lynch. I will check to see if it is stated in rules or not but will not use it this time to push the lynch until I hear back from Thomith. I am still quite annoyed about yesterday because every bloody page on the wiki backed our perception.

Finally. RIP RB. I shall continue on as Applejack in memory of you.



You irritated me, drove me up the wall at times, but clearly your heart was in the right place.

DRAKEN!

That pony died and she defended you all of day 1.

PROVE TO HER YOU WERE WORTH DEFENDING ACTUALLY DO SOMETHING TODAY!

[Sir Bastion]

going from the front page of this game: http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.ph ... 0#p3444140

which is also a mini normal

neighbors are revealed when they are killed as shown here: http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.ph ... 4#p3500764

but I'd like a mod toe confirm this time

MOD: Does a player's status as neighbor get revealed when they are killed or lynched?

If there are any Neighbour flips they will be noted as such
--monk

[Sir Bastion]

and voila.

2birds is not a neighbor.

he lied and is clearly scum

vote: 2birds1stone

MOD: did you get a response on the issue with the bodyguard from the last day from the review group?

I am not going to discuss it in the main thread or by PM until end game

[Sir Bastion]

ok no problem.


lets push on then.

2birds1stone you openly lied claiming to be something you are not you continued a charade with johman all through day 2 which has now been shown to be false. Do you have any conceivable reason why someone working with the town would lie to save scum?

[Scumhunter]

Oh shit. This does mean 2b1s is scum here right? Before we make any more hasty decisions based on mechanics, I do want to see what 2b1s has to say though.

2b1s, how do you explain johman flipping goon here?

[Sir Bastion]

this time thankfully we have the mod confirm the mechanics so we know 100% that

johman was not a neighbor

[Scumhunter]

vote 2birds1stone

lol we lynch 2scum1gambit.

Hey Sir B, look at my iso #11 and tell me you still suspect me

[Beck]

vote: 2b1s

No neighbors = scum caught.

[Sir Bastion]

a small bit.

Actually both you and Draken are looking slightly suspect to me purely for ignoring the elephant in the room when we started today.

More so Draken as he got somewhat accusatory with the term *debacle.*

But right now I wont make any calls on further scum until 2birds defends himself and I get to look at their ISO.

[Sir Bastion]

ok guys this time a bit less eager he's already at

L-2

So no one else vote until we get an answer from him!

[Scumhunter]

unvote

for the sake of cautiousness and because we have plenty of time to double check ourselves here.

[Scumhunter]

i honestly forgot about the whole neighbor fiasco/didn't really consider what the flip meant til I read your post. My sole thought process about this game was slight bitterness over the bodyguard lynch and anger at myself for going along with it without really poring through the ruleset/asking the mod. I think this game would be more fun if ANY claim were allowed.

[weirdbeard]

If Johman definitely was NOT a neighbour, I can't think of any conceivable town-sided reason for 2birds to claim neighbour with him.

[Scumhunter]

Neither can I, lets just wait to see what he has to say though.

[Sir Bastion]

I think this game would be more fun if ANY claim were allowed.

isnt that what the open games are for though?

normal allows it within reason. Which was where the issue was raised.

[Beck]

Open games don't allow fake claims like this.

If 2b is scum, which is almost a certainty since they corroborated each other's stories with fake night discussions, this will be the 2nd game I've been in with weird where scum fakeclaimed together and got caught.

[Sir Bastion]

he's your lucky plushtoy?

[Beck]

lol I guess

[Sir Bastion]

i am actually trying to work out a scenario where 2bird could be town but honestly the only one that works is so incredible far fetched and pointless that its laughable. I'll wait til I see his response then you can have storytime with basty...