SMBM II: Defense of Yoshi's Island (Final! MVPs announced!)

[Isa]

i am going to claim my MVP trophy now

*COUGH*

Yeah you're totally not deserving of that. Neither am I, but you're absolutely not. You found Sunscum and approved of a few scum lynches, but that's not MVP worthy at all, especially in combination with the mislynches you were about to get going, and the ones you GOT going.

Vifam in combination with Warriormode is the one deserving of the MVP award if anything. Warriormode wouldn't have made it to the endgame unless Vifam didn't pull this gambit. The rest of the scumteam played like crap - diddin, Sunset and David X were all easily caught. Vifam was a townread of mine so I was troubled with that, but other than that I think I did great this game.

[hiplop]

i am going to claim my MVP trophy now

*COUGH*

Yeah you're totally not deserving of that. Neither am I, but you're absolutely not. You found Sunscum and approved of a few scum lynches, but that's not MVP worthy at all, especially in combination with the mislynches you were about to get going, and the ones you GOT going.

Vifam in combination with Warriormode is the one deserving of the MVP award if anything. Warriormode wouldn't have made it to the endgame unless Vifam didn't pull this gambit. The rest of the scumteam played like crap - diddin, Sunset and David X were all easily caught. Vifam was a townread of mine so I was troubled with that, but other than that I think I did great this game.

^^ town wise i did the most! The only one I didn't get was warrior, and I feel like an idiot for that - ONE OF THE BABIES WAS SCUM he just didn't claim because for some reason my mind had him claimed as a yoshi :\

At least i knew it wasnt imp, and today i was going to vote warrior if he lived - but I rip'd

[implosion]

At least i knew it wasnt imp, and today i was going to vote warrior if he lived - but I rip'd

its either you or KC. Also resorting to insults is cowards play.

:-\

[hiplop]

that was directed at bbmollla ._.

[Bunnylover]

Bah.

[WrathChild]

God damnit town! I was killed Night 1 and followed this game the whole time. I thought we had it in the bag! Are we gonna get a scum QT?

[chkflip]

Fuck this site i hate this game. i will not play anymore i am shit full of it fuck everything and goodbye.

Good riddance.

[Bowser]

Scum QT will be given out if three of the players want it. If the Sunset hydra is mixed, they'll be counted as "No."

Anyways, Night Actions forthcoming.

[chkflip]

Kind of disappointed in town. GG scum.

[Isa]

Eeeey, I did what I could.

Overall though, the players that knew what they were doing were killed off early by scum. The VI's that wouldn't defend themselves were left alive (Bunnylover springs to mind).

I wish Jakalope had targeted me. That way, I would be able to get my information out through a new medium that wouldn't reveal me.

[Kise]

Wow, the usurper did it. Holy shit.

[Bowser]

(

Red

denotes actions that should have failed or should have succeeded, since I know I'm bound to come across one. Just watch...)

--Isa--

Night 1: Yellow button
Night 2: White Button
Night 3: Orange Button
Night 4: Brown Button
Night 5: Blue Button
Night 6: Yellow Button

Nightkilled Night 6

--TheJakalope--

Night 1: Sunset (Result: Non-baby)
Night 2: DemonHybrid (Roleblocked)

Night 3: Bunnylover (Result: Baby; QT created)

Night 4: No Action (Roleblocked)

Killed Night 4

--Anti-Islanders--

Night 1: DX to kill WrathChild; Sunset roleblocks hiplop; diddin rolecops Hoppster
Day 2: diddin vigs stormer

diddin lynched

Night 2: Sunset to kill Hoppster and roleblock TheJakalope
Night 3: DX to kill DemonHybrid;

Sunset roleblocks TheJakalope

Vifam lynched Day 4

Night 4: warrior to kill TheJakalope

Sunset lynched Day 5

Night 5: warrior to kill chkflip

warrior activated Night 5

David Xanatos lynched Day 6

Night 6: Isa nightkilled
Night 7: manho nightkilled

warrior deactivated Night 7

Night 8: WLC killed
Night 9: hiplop killed

Win Condition achieved Day Final!!!

--manho--

Night 1 activation

Night 2: watch DemonHybrid (No visits)
Night 3: No action

Deactivated Night 3

--

Activated Night 6

Night 7: watch warriormode (no visits)

Deactivated Night 7 due to death

--hiplop--

Activated Night 2

Night 3: Protect Isa
Night 4: Protect Kcdaspot

Deactivated Night 4

--

Killed Night 9

--chkflip--

Activated Night 3

Night 4: No action
Night 5: Roleblock implosion[/b]

Deactivated Night 5

Killed Night 5

--WLC--

Activated Night 4

Night 5: Track chkflip to implosion
Night 6: Track Kcdaspot, but went nowhere

Deactivated Night 6

--

Killed Night 8

Mistake during Night 3 would not have changed the result of the game

[Bowser]

Town MVP:

Town started to start sinking a bit a few days after he died. If he'd have lived, then the game would probably have ended differently. I'm giving it to

DemonHybrid/Matias

Scum MVP:

There are two awards here, because without one's gambit, the other would not have lived to the end. Those two would be

Vifam and warriormode

[Isa]

Town MVP:

Town started to start sinking a bit a few days after he died. If he'd have lived, then the game would probably have ended differently. I'm giving it to

DemonHybrid/Matias

Not going to argue with this; DH was really useful.

The projectmatt lynch though...

[BBmolla]

Feh. Sorry folks, I should have put more effort into this game, my apologies for not doing so.

[Matias]

Town MVP:

Town started to start sinking a bit a few days after he died. If he'd have lived, then the game would probably have ended differently. I'm giving it to

DemonHybrid/Matias

Scum MVP:

There are two awards here, because without one's gambit, the other would not have lived to the end. Those two would be

Vifam

Oh wow, I totally agree about that scum MVP!

[Bowser]

I've had enough of your griping. You lost, you're mad. It's just a fucking game. Deal with it.

[Isa]

I'm not really mad about the ending - Vifam and warriormode set this up nicely for warriormode, and I'd never suspect it as long as I'd be alive.

Overall, the game was an enjoyable cruise from day 2 and onward, with everyone scum making themselves more or less obvious (the projectmatt lynch though...) one way or another. I must complain though about the lack of votecounts for an entire MONTH. The setup was fun for me, but I don't know if the Yoshis/babies agree. Overall, I think I'd play in SMBMIII, as long as votecounts were done more frequently.
Honestly, mod, what happened there?

[Matias]

I've had enough of your griping. You lost, you're mad. It's just a fucking game. Deal with it.

are you talking to me?

you realize that I'm talking about how everyone's jizzing over warrior's play (it does NOT deserve a fucking scummy) and not the outcome of the game, right?

I can get mean right the fuck back, so please tell me that you're picking a fight over the right thing

[Matias]

or do you want to move this discussion over to the scummy thread where you can join the other idiots in orgasming over warrior mode doing jack shit while vifam sets him up even though he should have been lynched the second after town noticed that he was "left alive"?

Vifam's setup was the best play of this game and it wasn't even DONE at the right time. the mafia deserved the win. they got it. they do NOT deserve scummies.

[projectmatt]

I thought that Warrior was scum but that was before I saw his watcher gambit, then my read changed. You have to admit it's rather clever and he played well given the circumstances. Vifam also did something that looked like the silliest thing in the world and it helped the scum team get the win altogether. I'm still disappointed that I was lynched. (I understand, I probably was over-reacting with my anger but I'm wondering what caused me to be lynched in the first place. I strive not to be a VI type player so if someone could tell me how I was scummy or what I can improve on, that would be nice.)

Town played alright, scum played well. It's a loss, but still GG.

[Isa]

I will never, never, never understand your lynch.

[warriormode]

Thanks for the game and the nomination Bowser!

And thanks everyone for the game, this game had me nervous from beginning to end, which never happens to me,
not only was this my first game that I lived til lylo, it was also my first game as scum.

Definitely couldn't have done it without my teammates for sure. This wasn't like a "one man army" victory.
Vifam executed a great gambit, I don't where he went after that though, but that was definitely a huge part.
David and Sunset also put me in a good place in this game and supported me a lot so i'm thankful for that too.
Easily the best game I've been a part of for me. Not sure if any game could top this for me but I've been wrong before...

So damn Hiplop! You pulled a little gambit yourself right? soft-claiming a guilty on Sunset? You were actually a doc right?

[Sinestro]

hehe yeah

[Ranmaru]

or do you want to move this discussion over to the scummy thread where you can join the other idiots in orgasming over warrior mode doing jack shit while vifam sets him up even though he should have been lynched the second after town noticed that he was "left alive"?

Vifam's setup was the best play of this game and it wasn't even DONE at the right time. the mafia deserved the win. they got it. they do NOT deserve scummies.

Why doesn't Vifam or Warrior deserve a scummy?