Mafia 49: SpeedyKQ's Big New York Game - Game over!

[Fritzler]

RAJ isn't scum guys.

Vote: Max

[help im a bug]

I don't believe him Let me say this if you were doctor and we let you live til tomorrow you wouldn't die at night.

This statement is weird to me. I'm still not sure what to make of it. Especially as said by someone who claimed vanilla townie.

[MrBuddyLee]

Well, this early in the game I think a doc could just as easily claim vanilla town and get away with it. I think such a claim would be better for the town.

my exiting role states I am vanilla townie and I win when all mafia are eliminated. I GOT THE MOST IMPORTANT ROLE

Just pointing out the coincidence, don't know if it's significant or not...

Uh, sorry, no.

Trying to out the doctor is in fact very very scummy. Especially when you've already claimed doctor, as it makes me think that, hey, you're probably not the real one.

vote: MM

.

unvote raj, vote: help im a bug

for insinuating this was any kind of rational, reasoned out attempt to out a doctor. I agree it was a stupid post, but stupid =/= scummy. A few posts before this, you said it was a best to leave claimed doctors alone. If this post by M-M was your reason for changing your mind, it's a flimsy one.

I'm moving my raj vote in the off chance Fritzler has some solid info behind his comment.

[vikingfan]

vote Max

Best play on the board at the moment, though I wish MM had played smarter and not pulled his stupid gambit...that didn't help much.

[Kelly Chen]

MM suggesting Max might be a doctor,

because

Max claimed townie, when MM had already claimed doctor himself, is pretty weird. HIAB mentioned this as well. It wasn't just about an apparent attempt to out the doctor.

I still doubt Max is scum.

[XGreyjoyX]

Gonna have to go back to my orginal suspect

Vote:Max

[armlx]

Choo choo!

Band wagon! (that I started D1...)

Vote MAx

[MrBuddyLee]

MM suggesting Max might be a doctor,

because

Max claimed townie, when MM had already claimed doctor himself, is pretty weird. HIAB mentioned this as well. It wasn't just about an apparent attempt to out the doctor.

Weird. Totally agree there. Good enough reason to change your mind about lynching the doctor? Smelled funny to me.

[help im a bug]

Weird. Totally agree there. Good enough reason to change your mind about lynching the doctor? Smelled funny to me.

Good enough reason to lynch the doctor? Perhaps not.

Good enough reason to vote someone suspicious who made a doctor claim under duress? I think so.

[Save The Dragons]

I can work with a

vote: raj

also, for saying little other than votes for a few people.

Does this have anything to do with Raj's hammah?

[Coron]

I don't believe him Let me say this if you were doctor and we let you live til tomorrow you wouldn't die at night.

This statement is weird to me. I'm still not sure what to make of it. Especially as said by someone who claimed vanilla townie.

...
What he's saying is this.
Think from the mafia's point of view, if you say, if doc is alive tomorrow we'll lynch him, mafia aren't going to kill him to save them a kill and waste a lynch obv.

[Nightfall]

MM suggesting Max might be a doctor,

because

Max claimed townie, when MM had already claimed doctor himself, is pretty weird. HIAB mentioned this as well. It wasn't just about an apparent attempt to out the doctor.

Weird. Totally agree there. Good enough reason to change your mind about lynching the doctor? Smelled funny to me.

I think what happend to MM was the result of MM using one of his own quotes out of context.

* MM had said in an earlier post that "docs could claim vanila townie this early on and be able to hide and likely get away with it."

* Max THEN claimed townie

* I think MM then quickly read his prior post and thought he said mafia instead of doc. (That's how I missread it the first time I looked it over)

* MM THEN posted his and Max's quotes to imply that Max was doing what MM had (thought he) said in his other post, claiming townie this early to hide his true role. Maybe MM made this comment as a little eye brow raise in Max's direction implying that he could be scum since he was only claiming vanila townie.

[Kelly Chen]

I can work with a

vote: raj

also, for saying little other than votes for a few people.

Does this have anything to do with Raj's hammah?

Only in that it came out of nowhere.

[Glork]

I think Nightfall hit the nail on the head there. I was very confused as to MM's "big slip-up" when he quoted the posts, mostly because I hadn't read them properly either. Nevertheless, I don't think MM was going to avoid the D1 lynch at that point, so I didn't really bother speaking up.

[Bacde]

So you are saying MM confused himself?

[BabyJesus]

it did not matter....

people that claim doc need to f'n die, regardless....

[Tamuz]

Choo choo!

Band wagon! (that I started D1...)

Vote MAx

vote: Armlx

IGMEOY: MrBuddyLee

[MrBuddyLee]

I think you have your eye on me in every game, T, and I turn up town

[Glork]

No. That MM wasn't thinking and misread his earlier post.

[rajrhcpfreak]

Ya'll expect analysis from Raj? Good luck.

i love you.



yah im sorry i hammahed the doc. but it wasnt like i was the only vote. there was 11 other votes agreeing with me.

[quote"MrBuddyLee"]I think you have your eye on me in every game, T, and I turn up town[/quote]

hes bound to be right one of these times.

being i had 12 other people doing it before me i didnt see the need.

lets

vote:mrbuddylee

not omgus. just you come off the scummiest on attacking and prettending to be protown.

[Tamuz]

Uhh Lee, that was one other game.

Plus, you not only have given me a scummy feeling about you, but you have the history of MoS's posting...

[MrBuddyLee]

Hey, analysis of one out of 23 people, that's a good start.

being i had 12 other people doing it before me i didnt see the need.

I think it's scummy to pass the blame. I imagine people like to see reasoning before you vote so they know why YOU did it, not why everyone else did.

But hey, if Fritzler says you're cool...

[Twito]

I think what happend to MM was the result of MM using one of his own quotes out of context.

* MM had said in an earlier post that "docs could claim vanila townie this early on and be able to hide and likely get away with it."

* Max THEN claimed townie

* I think MM then quickly read his prior post and thought he said mafia instead of doc. (That's how I missread it the first time I looked it over)

* MM THEN posted his and Max's quotes to imply that Max was doing what MM had (thought he) said in his other post, claiming townie this early to hide his true role. Maybe MM made this comment as a little eye brow raise in Max's direction implying that he could be scum since he was only claiming vanila townie.

That sounds like a good possibility. I'm going with MM's idea and voting Max.

[Glork]

Unvote

for now. This Maxlynch feels a little too easy right now....

[Ameliaslay]

*Checking in... ^^^ I'll agree on that one.