I keep thinking about this and nothing quite adds up.
I am assuming that the folowing people exist because they were main cast in season 3:
Buffy- protector and/or vigilante
Willow- investigator or vigilante
Oz- mason
Oz's bassist- mason (me)
Mr. Trick- in the death scenes, so must exist- works for the mayor, main baddie in season 3
That's 5 out of 8 living.
I am beginning to second guess myself, but I would guess these would have to be in the game, too:
Xander
Cordelia
I'm starting to second guess strictly because they do not have a abilities that map to mafia well. Heck, I wondered why Devon wasn't part of our band, but I understand that a four person mason lodge would be too large in this game.
So that's 7 + 1 townie or bad guy or minor character.
Angel Fish: Here are some reasons, I was going to resist the urge to go back, but...
re: sketchwick
I do wrry that we should be looking elsewhere & this is just a smokescreen.
Trying to divert attention from your spy?
There was one other place that piqued my interest, but I don't see it right now.
Then:
I'd like to do an OMGUS, but I actually thing Jeep maybe right about half his accusations, so, instead:
Made me think you knew you were mafia and suspected Pudd'nhead was innocent, making me 'half right.' I thought you were just being cute.
And the fact that I was likely targetted by both a protector and the vamps last night... maybe I was on the right track?
In re-reading the thread, Sofis raised a my eyebrow, too. Sofis does seem a bit more suspicious on re-reading the thread.
And finally, no one else has given me a better theory. I'm not 100% convinced you are a vamp. Yesterday, I was something like 60% sure of you and 80% sure of Pudd'nhead. Hence, I went with PW.
So I'm just going with my gut. If I'm wrong, I apologize. If you have better evidence, put it forth and I'll weigh it against my gut feel and everyone else is more likely to go with evidence over my guess...
-JEEP