Discworld Mafia: Anarchy in Ankh Morpork (Night 7) Choices!

[Dragon Slayer]

Ok, sorry for the delay. Patrician vote count!

Eillid: 7 (Cadmium, Koru, Jadesmar, Gaspode, Jeep, Doomcow, Beaudoin)
Ptolemaic: 1 (Ptolemaic)
GARM: 1 (ambic)
Gaspode: 1 (NIghtstalker)
Mikegoo: 1 (Mikegoo)
zzzbeauty: 1 (zzzbeauty)
Saberkitty: 1 (Saberkitty)

[mith]

I'm just going to respond to this one part, and I think it will answer most of the rest of your post (if not all of it).

Why can't another idea than yours be considered as a good idea?

Did I *ever* say it couldn't? I think you misunderstand the idea of Crap Logic. You see, I don't agree with anyone doing anything other than what I am doing, or I would be doing it. I'm not voting for GARM, nor am I FOSing anyone that is, or saying they have Crap Logic.

However, when someone posts something that *is not logical*, and does this repeatedly, and I explain why, and no one tells me the flaw in *my* reasoning, and the other person's reasoning is, IMO, something that would work against the town, then I will call it Crap Logic (and reserve the right to take the label away if someone shows me why I am wrong), and, with nothing better to go on, I will vote for that person.

[Nyarlathotep]

First off, I am *not* cracking down.

Secondly, since it wasnt noticed the last time around:

UNVOTE: JOHNWWELLS, VOTE: AMBIC

For no appearant reason whatsoever. Similarly,

VOTE: EILID

Now, please, mommy, make this day end.

Nyarlathotep

[SaberKitty]

i can accept the role of townie, even if pratchett dosen't have them, but i'd expect any other role to have a specific character/relation to discworld. suicidal townie definately dosen't fit. (i guess you could be King Teppicymon XXVII- he jumped off his balcony thinking he could fly, but that's a huge stretch) Liar Liar Pants On Fire!

vote:amb

ok, what's with the ellid for patrician thing? (s)he hasn't even posted. ok, i agree that she was chosen randomly, but should we really have a patrician who isn't here? (s)he was one of the last to confirm and now isn't even posting. do you really want a patrician who dosen't care enough to post? what if (s)he get's replaced due to inactivity?

pick someone for patrician who is actually here, for goodness' sake.

vote SK, do not delay

-SK

[zzzbeauty]

All righty. This IS starting to take a while, so I'm going to change my votes.

Unvote: IS, Vote: Ambic

, because if you KNOW you're going to die anyway it's better to die sooner than later and get it over with,

and

Unvote: Myself, Vote: Eillid

, because even though I really really really really really really really wanna be Patrician, I figure someone who never posts isn't going to be abusing their power.

Then again, I'm pretty busy in RL all of a sudden, so I may not be posting myself....nah, I'll still vote for eillid for now.

But vote zzzbeauty Day 3! (or whenever)!

[discer]

Jeep's random vote generator is trusty so i will

vote: Eillid

as well.
I will vote: Ambic as well cause after reading 7 pages to catch up the one thing that sticks out the most is

vote: Ambic

. Plus, I don't see how a dejected townie is getting even with the town by getting lynched and if all I had to do to win was get lynched the game would be over by now.

[Dragon Phoenix]

vote Eillid

[Internet Stranger]

Patrician?

[Vegtable2001]

If we have to have one it's just as well they're not here

Vote Eillid

[Polotet]

No time for an full vote count now, but there are 15 for ambic, only two more to lynch.

IS: read the first post.

[Internet Stranger]

Damn you! that thing was two paragraphs long!

Either way, I should have been voted the Practicioner dude. My campaign will commence soon.

[MeMe]

Vote: IS for Practicioner dude

Vote: Eillid

for Patrician

[Jalyn]

I'll also

vote:eillid

per the random scheme. I'm going to wait for ambic to see if there is more to the role claim (like a name), if not, that is definitely where my vote will be going.

[Werebear]

Hm. I don't know what to say, I guess I'll help ambic win. 8 pages is long enough for day 1. *shrug*

Vote: Ambic

Oh, yeah, and I'll tickle IS' fancy and vote for him for proctologist.

[Cadmium]

Okay Mith, where do I start?

I posted once before the weekend and after that I had to read everything that happened after that post. There were some things that got my attention, but most of the posts were either about the patrician or about Ambic/GARM. The whole Ambic/GARM theory didn't cut the cake for me. It was just a joke form Ambic's side and I think it's bull to take that seriously. Then there was the patrician discussion. I gave my ideas about it in my first post and was curious what everybody else was thinking about it.

Vegetable and SK post their ideas and after that you call it Crap Logic and FOS them. It's true that you gave your ideas too. Plus you tried to explain why you think their theories are not a good idea. Nothing wrong so far.
Then Vegetable doesn't agree with you and simply tries to explain himself again (without FOSing or voting you). So he's basically trying to show you why you're wrong so you can take the label away (that's exactly what you wanted according to your last post). But you still don't agree and upgrade your FOS to a vote. When I read that, you got my attention some more. That vote was not completely fair IMO. But it wasn't enough for me to vote for you.
But it was enough for Ambic to vote for you. Let's see what happens next. You vote for Ambic. And why? Because of hypocrisy. But as I explained in my last post, there was no such thing going on IMO. So that was another vote from your side that didn't make sense to me.
I put all these things together and added those two points from your argument with Jeep and found the whole to be suspicious enough for a vote. And that's why I *did* vote for you. Nothing more, nothing less.

But I'll

unvote Mith

for now. I still disagree with the FOS's and votes but I just know we're not getting anywhere here. I'll change my

vote

to

Ambic

. The role sounds really non-discworld, and I don't think a moderator would seriously consider using this role in a normal mafia game. If Ambic is telling the truth, then I would be so surprised. It's like trowing away your entire game on the first day.

[Polotet]

Ambic has been lynched, you'll get a death scene around 4PM EST. You can post, but only to discuss or vote for a Patrician. When the death scene comes, the Patrician will be chosen, and enter power tomorrow.

[JohnWWells]

Vote Ellid for Patrician

Why not?

[Polotet]

OK, ambic has been lynched and eillid will be your Patrician, starting tomorrow. Here's ambic's death scene, and DS may write a election scene if he wants to.

The town wakes up in the morning, not sure what to do about the whole Patrician thing. Quickly, ambic makes a suggestion: "Vote for GARM, he's honest!" The town responds: "Buh?" and then "What, are you guys scum or something?" and then, when GARM denounces any connection, "Ambic is scum!" As the votes pile up, ambic begins a frantic defense. Finally, he claims a role: "I'm a suicidal townie, kill me and the game ends!" Again, the town responds: "Buh?" and then "You must be lying scum!" They finally string ambic up, and nothing interesting happens. They then head to his houise, where they find nothing special. Ambic was a mere townie, lying to defend himself.

Ambic, townie, has been lynched. Eillid has been elected Patrician. It is Night Two. Send choices to the appropriate mod, please.

[Koru]

It's the lies that hurt the most

[SaberKitty]

I know it's night and that i shouldn't post important info, but: ambic is a guy

-SK

[GARM]

Don't worry SaberKitty that is not important

[Cadmium]

No, but it would be nice if these mix-ups wouldn't occur anymore though.

I still say we need some sort of gender thingies in our profiles.

[Porro]

No, but it would be nice if these mix-ups wouldn't occur anymore though.

I still say we need some sort of gender thingies in our profiles.

...or in our avatars

Bah @ non-gender-specific-body-part-avatars

[Porro]

Yipes!

I've just realised (as I clicked the submit key) that my last post could be interpreted as encouraging people to use pervy-gender-specific-body-parts
I didn't mean that, honest (though I won't object too strongly if doodettes adopt that policy ~ within the realms of decency of course), I was merely referring to 'the hand' used by Cadmium.

[Cadmium]

LOL @ Porro .

But obviously, that is a man's hand .