Also, the phrasing of the death, with bolding rearranged to show just how much it can affect the way you read it:
He was shot with a crossbow
Looks to me like this is comparable to "he was shot
I stand by it. I think DarkBlade is the gun wielder.
No offense taken... which is why I referred to them as "random insults" rather than "despicable slander".d8P wrote:AAAGH!
Dourgrim: Sorry. Didn't mean to cause offence. Newbie nerves, or attempt at humour, that's all. I would have been the first to post except you beat me to it, so I had to re-write mine, hence the name calling.
A second mafia attempt
and said he was the brains ofProtecting Your Godfather From Nosy People
"3 killers is a lot, and leads me to look VERY suspisciously upon someone assuming there are 3 killers."per CubanSmoker
This is incorrect. The third shotDarkblade wrote:That third shot couldn't be from a vig. The vig won't kill the first day as chances are he'll hit a townie.
i think it was speculative meant to encourage dialog. (note the question mark)Darkblade: 3 killers?
cuban smoker: Yay! Go Mafia! ... I mean... heh.
cuban smoker wrote:The fact that the conclusionwasmade suggests to me that the gunshot probably came from DarkBlade. I only listed a vigilante as a possibility. As well, some vigilantes are forced to kill. It should be noted that DarkBlade has effectively denied being a vigilante, which eliminates the only nagging doubt in my mind: "maybe DarkBlade is firing guns as a vigilante..."
Maybe there are 3 killers, maybe there aren't. There are many scenarios under which there are only 2 killing groups. Why did DarkBlade assume there were 3? In my opinion, it is quite likely this assumption was made because DarkBlade knows who fired the questionable shot.
cuban smoker wrote:So... maybe DarkBlade is innocent townie, with no vigilante role or anything: Why not try to support this idea by agreeing with the general consensus: A vigilante role wielding the 3rd weapon?! DarkBlade has discounted the possiblity that he is a vigilante.
cuban smoker wrote: So, DarkBlade is innocent, has assumed there are 3 killers, which must be 1 mafia group and TWO Serial Killers, one who cuts people up, and one who uses a gun or a club, PLUS the 3 mafia.