- Best Mafia CatcherSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Regfan First: mastin2 Second: Tierce
Nominated: Cogito Ergo Sum First: Faraday Second: Mina
Nominated: Nuwen First: Mina Second: MagnaOfIllusion
Nominated: MattP First: izakthegoomba Second: Maestro
Nominated: Fate First: MagnaofIllusion Second: kuribo
- Nominated: Regfan First: mastin2 Second: Tierce
- Most Cunning ManipulatorSpoiler: Description
- First:
Nominated: kanyeknowsbest First: Mist Beauty Second: XReckonerX
Nominated: BBMola First: horrordude0215 Second: Mist Beauty
Nominated: Haylen First: Oversoul Second: Amrun
Nominated: MuffinMan First: kiwieagle Second: Magister Ludi
Nominated: Magister Ludi First: Oversoul Second: None
Nominated: GreyICE First: iStark Second: None
Nominated: MattP First: TheTrollie Second: Mehdi2277
Nominated: Twistedspoon First: mastin2 Second: Amrun
Nominated: petapan First: BK201 Second: Ythan
Nominated: JasonT1981 First: MagnaofIllusion Second: Om of the Nom
Nominated: McStab First: rapidcanyon Second: Salamence20
Nominated: Thor First: TeChNoWC Second: McStab
Nominated: Salamence20 First: UberNinja Second: Klick
Nominated: UberNinja First: mastin2 Second: drmyshotgun
- First:
- Rising Star
Spoiler: Description- Nominated: Tierce First: hiplop Second: Xalxe
Nominated: Shadoweh First: DarthYoshi Second: Amrun
Nominated: Tammy First: Faraday Second: DeasVail
Nominated: Method First: Jackal711 Second: None
Nominated: PiggyGal15 First: RedCoyote Second: None
Nominated: Klick First: Nachomamma08 Second: mastin2
Nominated: rob13 First: AngryPidgeon Second: roflcopter
Nominated: MattP First: zoraster Second: quadz08
Nominated: Mehdi2277 First: Jarvis Second: quadz08
- Nominated: Tierce First: hiplop Second: Xalxe
- Best ReplacementSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Porochaz First: Gammagooey Second: Matias
Nominated: Tierce First: Fate Second: Cogito Ergo Sum
Nominated: Cogito Ergo Sum First: Faraday Second: Magister Ludi
Nominated: Zorblag First: Robocopter87 Second: Mehdi2277
Nominated: GreyICE First: MagnaofIllusion Second: I Am Innocent
- Nominated: Porochaz First: Gammagooey Second: Matias
- Best ICSpoiler: Description
- Funniest or Most Enjoyable PlayerSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Faraday First: hitogoroshi Second: Parama
Nominated: PeregrineV First: mastin2 Second: None
Nominated: IceGuy First: UberNinja Second: None
Nominated: Shadoweh First: Quilford Second: DarthYoshi
Nominated: hitogoroshi First: zoraster Second: None
- Nominated: Faraday First: hitogoroshi Second: Parama
- Best Performance Pro-Town TeamSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Town of Good vs. Evil First: mastin2 Second: None
Nominated: Town of TM2012 White Flag First: zoraster Second: Nicodemus
Nominated: Town of Always On First: zoraster Second: kdowns
Nominated: Town of Otherworld Mafia First: Magister Ludi Second: Vi
Nominated: Town of mini 1373 First: Crypto Second: petapan
Nominated: Town of The Detectives First: GreyICE Second: Jarvis
Nominated: Town of 1361 First: McStabb Second: mastin2
Nominated: Town of Marketplace Mafia 2 First: MattP Second: StefanB
Nominated: Town of Micro 24 First: Guy_named_riggs Second: None
Nominated: Town of Open 427 First: Bitmap Second: Om of the Nom
- Nominated: Town of Good vs. Evil First: mastin2 Second: None
- Best Performance Scum GroupSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Scum of Arrested Development Mafia First: Mist Beauty Second: XReckonerX
Nominated: Mastin's Mafia First: Oversoul Second: Amrun
Nominated: Scum of AFFC First: Eddard Stark Second: Xalxe
Nominated: Scum of Mafia 144 First: mastin2 Second: DeasVail
Nominated: Scum of Otters vs. Tigers vs. Sharks First: Umbrage Second: Amrun
Nominated: Scum of HMS Regalia First: RichardGHP Second: None
Nominated: Scum of Judge, Jury, Executioner First: mastin2 Second: None
- Nominated: Scum of Arrested Development Mafia First: Mist Beauty Second: XReckonerX
- Best Performance Third PartySpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Chesskid3 for Lyncher in Red Dead Redemption First: Matias Second: Amrun
Nominated: Petapan First: MattP Second: None
Nominated: Guy_Named_Riggs First: Debonair Danny DiPietro Second: AururorusVox
Nominated: Vi for Murer in the Louvre First: Tierce Second: DDD
- Nominated: Chesskid3 for Lyncher in Red Dead Redemption First: Matias Second: Amrun
- Most Memorable EventSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: havingfitz First: quadz08 Second: GreyICE
Nominated: kanyeknowsbest First: Shamrock Second: MattP
Nominated: Axxle First: quadz08 Second: UberNinja
Nominated: Salmance for Disney Villains First: UberNinja Second: quadz08
Nominated: Baseline for replace in post First: Dunhamganger Second: StefanB
Nominated: PiggyGal15 for fakeclaim First: RedCoyote Second: None
Nominated: Soul2277 for fakeclaim First: Faraday Second: OmoftheNom
- Nominated: havingfitz First: quadz08 Second: GreyICE
- Most Enjoyable Game- Awarded to Both Moderator and Players of a GameSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Magua and Players for Paranoia Mafia First: UberNinja Second: None
Nominated: Seacore and Players for Good vs. Evil First: mastin2 Second: Amrun
Nominated: RichardGHP First: Malakittens Second: None
Nominated: zoraster and Players for Always On First: xReckonerx Second: esuriospiritus
Nominated: Guy_Named_Riggs and Players for Disney Villains First: UberNinja Second: Salamence20
Nominated: Moneybags and Players for Jester... First: Parama Second: TraceyLyn11
- Nominated: Magua and Players for Paranoia Mafia First: UberNinja Second: None
- Best SetupSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Secret Society Mafia First: Empking Second: BBMola
Nominated: Abarat Mafia First: Faraday Second: Seraphim
Nominated: Acomist for MST 3k First: MagnaofIllnsion Second: None
Nominated: Vi First: Nexus Second: Tierce
- Nominated: Secret Society Mafia First: Empking Second: BBMola
- Best Role(new or adaptation)Spoiler: Description
- Nominated: petroleumjelly for Knowledgeable Townie First: Llamafluff Second: Amrun
Nominated: AIDS Infector First: DeltaWave Second: xReckoner
Nominated: BBMolla for Venge-Cop First: Kcdaspot Second: Faraday
- Nominated: petroleumjelly for Knowledgeable Townie First: Llamafluff Second: Amrun
- Best Flavor TextSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Ghostling for Warlocks and Warewolves First: Tierce Second: IceGuy
Nominated: CDB for West Wing Mafia First: Empking Second: Nobody Special
Nominated: hitogoroshi for Abarat Mafia First: Mina Second: Equinox
Nominated: Xalxe for RotT: The Encryption First: saulres Second: Amrun
Nominated: Acosmist for Mystery Science Theater 3000 First: MagnaofIllusion Second: GreyICE
Nominated: rainbowdash for My Little Pony First: Tierce Second: Vi
Nominated: Glork for Weather Mafia 2 First: quadz08 Second: Xalxe
Nominated: Magua for Paranoia Mafia First: Tierce Second: Oversoul
Nominated: dazzy for open 397 First: kcdaspot Second: quadz08
Nominated: XReckonerX/Untrod Tripod for Gay Mafia First: kuribo Second: Staeg
Nominated: Vi First: Nexus Second: Tierce
Nominated: hitogoroshi for Abarat First: Nexus Second: hinduragi
Nominated: AurorusVox for Steam Library First: Kcdaspot Second: Katsuki
Nominated: PapaZito for Mini1372 First: mastin2 Second: AngryPidgeon
Nominated: Zar for Mystery at Lake Village First: Dunhamganger Second: StefanB
Nominated: Zar for Rocky Horror First: saulres Second: Maestro
Nominated: Shamrock for The Room First: Parama Second: None
- Nominated: Ghostling for Warlocks and Warewolves First: Tierce Second: IceGuy
- Best Mechanic/MutationSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: kunkstar for Cyclic x2 First: RedCoyote Second: MagnaofIllusion
Nominated: Darth Yoshi for Red Wall Mafia First: Zdenek Second: None
Nominated: Seacore First: mastin2 Second: None
Nominated: Zoraster for Always On First: xReckonerX Second: esuriospiritus
- Nominated: kunkstar for Cyclic x2 First: RedCoyote Second: MagnaofIllusion
- Excellent Moderation
This is now a Body of Work awardSpoiler: Description- Nominated: rainbowdash First: Tierce Second: Vi
Nominated: Seacore First: mastin2 Second: chesskid3
Nominated: Equinox First: Llamarble Second: Oversoul
Nominated: mykonian First: redff Second: None
Nominated: zoraster First: Faraday Second: Amrun
Nominated: AurorusVox First: Robocopter87 Second: Kcdaspot
Nominated: Tierce First: Equinox Second: Zoraster
- Nominated: rainbowdash First: Tierce Second: Vi
- Best Contribution to Mafia Discussion/The wikiSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Yosarian2 First: Magister Ludi Second: Mr. Flay
Nominated: The Fonz First: mastin2 Second: Vi
Nominated: Psyche First: Debonair Danny DiPietro Second: IceGuy
- Nominated: Yosarian2 First: Magister Ludi Second: Mr. Flay
- Behind the ScenesSpoiler: Description
- Outstanding MishMash GameSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Ether for Pictionary First: N Second: UberNinja
Nominated: borkjerfkin for Bang Revival First: quadz08 Second: None
Nominated: izak for Planetmafiascum First: Xalxe Second: Mehdi2277
Nominated: Mewtwo for Survivor: Seafoam Islands First: Xalxe Second: Nicholas1024
Nominated: mastermind for Spitfly First: Xalxe Second: None
Nominated: Blackberry for The Agenda First: Xalxe Second: None
Nominated: Blackberry for Survivorbots First: Xalxe Second: None
Nominated: Magua for Arkham Horror First: RedPanda Second: Mehdi2277
Nominated: Phillamon for Trouble in Terrorist Town First: RedPanda Second: Xalxe
Nominated: Zoraster for Robobattle First: XReckonerX Second: inspirataloos
- Nominated: Ether for Pictionary First: N Second: UberNinja
- The Community Contributor AwardSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Thestatusquo First: SleepyKrew Second: Amrun
Nominated: Singersigner First: Zoraster Second: Faraday
Nominated: Fenchurch First: Nexus Second: Amrun
Nominated: Faraday First: Nexus Second: Faraday
Nominated: callforjudgement First: SleepyKrew Second: MattP
Nominated: xReckonerX First: Starbuck Second: izakthegoomba
- Nominated: Thestatusquo First: SleepyKrew Second: Amrun
- In order to be considered by the scummy judging committee, a nomination must be seconded.
- Self-nominations are allowed. However, they are generally frowned upon, particularly where the sole winner will be the nominator. It is expected that Most Enjoyable Game will be a self-nomination
- Nominations with LINKS and descriptions of why you wish to nominate a player or group of players are greatly appreciated.
- Please boldwho you are nominating and for what award.
- Please note these are the official award categories of the 2012 Scummies. Suggestions will still be taken, but are unlikely to be implemented until the 2013 Scummies.