Worst Role Mafia - GAME OVER!

[Amrun]

He did NOT full claim on day 1. I hate the way he's added to his claim, and I could easily see it being a scum role. He's scummy, and that's what matters.

[IceGuy]

And let's not forget his role means he's anti-town even if he is town.

[danakillsu]

With 3 1/2 days left, it's looking like the following people will have to make up or change their minds:

Captain Haddock, BBmolla, theamatuer, Foxace36, brizingre1, Robotnick2, ShadowGirl, PokerFace

So if you're on that list, and especially you, ShadowGirl (since you have two choices to make), make sure to read the cases against the players being wagoned.

[danakillsu]

Actually, Captain Haddock and Robotnick2/mafian00b already voted Phillammon, so they don't belong on the list.

[RedPanda]

I totally get why his role is antitown.

But its like antitown town or antitown third.

I don't really see it as a scum role.

[brizingre1]

With 3 1/2 days left, it's looking like the following people will have to make up or change their minds:

Captain Haddock, BBmolla, theamatuer, Foxace36, brizingre1, Robotnick2, ShadowGirl, PokerFace

So if you're on that list, and especially you, ShadowGirl (since you have two choices to make), make sure to read the cases against the players being wagoned.

I'd vote for Oversoul to avoid a no-lynch - less sure about Phil.

[theamatuer]

Os>phil for me too.

[Tierce]

Then vote him.

[theamatuer]

I'm active enough to place a vote before the deadline: I just want fox's wall of text first.

[saulres]

Sigh. Even though I think Oversoul is likely scum, I'd rather vote for Phil, because an investigative role could check Oversoul but not Phil (based on claims). And Phil has to go at some point before LyLo, and can't be vigged, so we have to lynch him. Giving our investigative roles (if we have any that actually work) a chance to check Oversoul while getting rid of someone we're going to have to get rid of anyway just makes sense to me.

And before it's suggested that ShadowGirl have Phil modkilled: I would agree, but only if it meant she lost her ability. Day-vig-ing is one thing, but taking away a player's opportunity to win or lose on their own merits just sucks. Especially someone who's put some effort into the game (which you have to admit Phil has, with 72 posts, even if many of them were pure fluff).

[BBmolla]

With 3 1/2 days left, it's looking like the following people will have to make up or change their minds:

Captain Haddock, BBmolla, theamatuer, Foxace36, brizingre1, Robotnick2, ShadowGirl, PokerFace

So if you're on that list, and especially you, ShadowGirl (since you have two choices to make), make sure to read the cases against the players being wagoned.

My votes locked.

Don't lynch Phil.

[IceGuy]

Do you have any reasoning for that?

[mafia-n00b]

Don't lynch Phil.

Got a reason why we shouldn't?

[BBmolla]

He's town

[saulres]

*faceplant*

No, he's a third-party survivor, according to his claim. He's only saying he's town so he won't be lynched.

Or do you have some inside information?

[BBmolla]

No

He's town

[Phillammon]

Okay. Molla, whatever you're doing, stop it. Unless you're going to produce evidence for me being town, you're being less than helpful.

[BBmolla]

Okay I'll let town mislynch my town reads and sit here quietly, my bad.

[mafia-n00b]

@Phil, I don't know, maybe he'll convince people to lynch him instead of you, that'd be helpful, right? ;p

[Phillammon]

Yes, but if he flips scum, suddenly I'm public enemy number 1.

[BBmolla]

@Phil, I don't know, maybe he'll convince people to lynch him instead of you, that'd be helpful, right? ;p

^Better lynch.

[BBmolla]

So Phil the town thing to do here would be "Oh you guys are so silly! Go ahead and lynch Phil, I'm going to sit back and let it happens, who cares what I think!"

[Phillammon]

No. Backing it up would be more useful, or at least just saying "He feels town". But I shouldn't argue against you in any case, looks like people who believe me are in the minority...

[mafia-n00b]

^This.

@BBmolla, just saying "he's town" over and over isn't helpful and makes you look like a putz.

[BBmolla]

mafia-n00b why is he scum