Flavour post - Thing that strikes me and is probably completely irrelevant is that Fat_Tony, Slandaar and Senjai are referenced three times and seemed to be linked in the write up, somehow. Not suggesting anything but I'd consider it to be some kind of grouping the mod has used - where by one may well be potentially bad. I have in the past modded/played in games with flavour where town and mafia are linked as they are here.
The self-voting I'm kind of ambivalent to - either scum/town could well do. I'd have spend time looking at patterns to make anything of it - people who use as an excuse are of more concern in my opinion.
The Neighbours make-up somewhat meh to me - though my understanding would be that one of the three would be scum, though possible 2 of them maybe. Distancing perhaps from Benmage and CO? PV weighs in later on Ben's side and seems adamant that one of three is bad 90%.
Senjai's vote in
Post 22 bugs me as he seems to just ignore the previous 7/8 posts between CO, Benmage and DV. Which were not random crap.
DLG - slings his vote on CO. After PV. Digs out Senjai "Right with you on this. Senjai's entrance was weak." Agreed.
Asher 30 also bugs me
In post 30, asher1611 wrote:Maybe I missed it though, but how do we know one of the neighbors has to be scum? Couldn't 10% towards 3 town be a little low?
Slightly reads to me as though he knows none of them are - pushing it that direction - but than "guess" happy to go with the assumption anyway.
Also don't like 32 from BB - which again deflects the CO/Benmage argument - kind of feels like knowledge again
Chaos Omega says Asher makes random vote. Which is true. He does though ignore Senjai's random vote. Why I wonder!
Post 35 - reads off to me. He's not buddying "hard"
Also puzzled why he's called Senjai out.
Not particularly sure why Timeater then picks Benmage up on his site-meta and fact he rustles players up the wrong way.
Chaos Omega - to me through this little patch does read townish/genuine. Though I recall playing against him in the past and he's definitely no mug/newb.
TImeater continues to ignore the neighbours topic. Votes BB assuming it's due to this from
Post 23
Asher's
Post 51 seems pretty defensive to what was nothing more than a harmless prod from CO.
In post 51, asher1611 wrote:I agree there. To be honest, I didn't appreciate the significance of the information Benmage posted, I just assumed he was referring to something in the flavor text.
That's what I get for posting while distracted.
.
Timeater's vote on BB obviously wasn't that solid. Moves to Senjai for what appears lurking.
Not liking
Post 55 much from Slandaar, the vote appears to be a move to the biggest wagon and then throws dirt at Senjai, like a few others.
What is RVS?
Senjai's
Post 56 again seems off to me - defends CO in pieces, yet then votes him to accelerate the town!
In post 56, Senjai wrote:Benmage comes off scummy in the beginning after magically determining Chaos is scum in pregame without providing any real reason why.
In post 56, Senjai wrote:Chaos crossvote is expected given that Ben claimed he was scum without any real evidence so far. It is a reactionary post and I'd have done no different. I slightly think ben is scummier than Chaos
Sides with PV.
Then this bit is pretty terrible.
In post 56, Senjai wrote:For the sake of progressing town I'll VOTE: Chaos Though be sure Ben if he flips town your his biggest advocate and my vote will be on your Day 2.
Says Timeater is scum-hunting and has a slight
town tell
on him.
Then almost seems aploogetic about his vote
In post 60, Senjai wrote:Also we need to hear more from elias and fat. avoid a L-2 situation until then so they dont speedhammer.
Sensei bunged CO to L-2!!
CO votes Senjai. Spot on where I'm reading this little situation.
In post 67, ChaosOmega wrote:It's like you know I'm town, so that when I'm mislynched, day 2 you can go, "Well, now we can lynch Benmage, I knew he was scummier, look, I said it day 1!"
CO reads town to me.
DLG's vote in
Post 71 - reads like he's putting suspicion on Senjai, but then his vote against BB is a pretty lame-duck excuse for not reading the first post in the thread.
80 - This just seems too definite and wrong
In post 80, Senjai wrote:No - I think one of you is. Lynching one will identify the other. This answers DLG's question: Even though I think ben was scummier in that discussion - Im voting Chaos to progress town. Should he flip the scum is likely Ben.
CO posts a reasonable argument in
Post 82, before Time posts some link. I ain't clicking on it and then Senjai votes TIme in 84 which reads like he's almost given up the ghost on trying to push a wagon which is at L-2. What specifically made you change your mind Senjai?
Slaandaar isn't contributing and ignores the argument. Does then question Senjai.
Birthday says Senjai's looks town. Looks opposite to me -
defending here.
I like Timeater's post in 114. I don't like Timeater's post in 115.
Asher contributes very little in
Post 120. Almost an educated "don't do this we lose a townie"
Quag defends Senjei subtlely. Accuses him of bad logic more than anything.
In post 127, Quagmire wrote:But, bad logic is almost never a scumtell, and I'm getting a pretty neutral read from Senjai, and I don't think there's much information that can be gleaned from it.
Not sure if bad logic never applies to scum. Yes, they are probably more analytical about posts and less likely to make really stupid posts
Not sure what to make of Asher's big post
Post 143. Will need to review. Timeater back on that wagon.
Birthday seems meek to me. Peregrine V brings zip all to the table, vote stays. Anything else you want to add PV? What do you make Senjei for instance?
Not too sure what to make of the Elias/Time spat. Benmage has come back and really kept going on at Chaos. I will re-read everyone in isolation but for now.
