In post 748, UberNinja wrote:Since you're confident on Mogri, would you mind explaining to me why *you* think he's scum?
Dude, I have plenty of times, I gave you a detailed analysis last time you asked me. Look up my post activity, I think I've done about three or four rants on
"101 reasons why Mogri is scum."
I wouldn't say 'confident', but more confident than anyone else, and I'm getting NO town tells from him.
Was wondering if you also had any scummy reads on petapan. So far he has displayed towntells (which BB failed to do), but he seems more experienced than BB and so may be hiding it well. I'm still getting some scummy vibes, but I really wouldn't be happy lynching him today, unless he did something outrageous.
Considering NS did reply and isn't going to be replaced as I initially thought, I would possibly lynch him today, though not confidently.
BD was another small consideration, but I want to wait for a replacement.
Inte was yet another, but he has shown improvement recently. I would probably consider him for D3 depending on how things pan out, but not keen on lynching him today.
Pine I have to look up on.
So basically, Mogri, my two main scummy reads for a D2 lynch (and like crypto, I don't want this to drag on any longer than necessary) are you and NS.
you know I think I overestimated Mogri's bussing ability. I thought red was town and mogri was scum for making red his first vote and just kinda coasting with it after. but I also though if red was actually scum then mogri was blatantly busing him. and now he buses my other scummiest read on BB's slot, I think I see a trend xD
In post 755, BK201 wrote:you know I think I overestimated Mogri's bussing ability. I thought red was town and mogri was scum for making red his first vote and just kinda coasting with it after. but I also though if red was actually scum then mogri was blatantly busing him. and now he buses my other scummiest read on BB's slot, I think I see a trend xD
Me too. And its a possible sign that he is trying to draw attention to other players on the top of people's scumlists, to avoid the lynch. I empathise with his 'everything I do is scummy to you guys' statement, in that at this stage, there is not a lot he could say that would make me think he is town, very quickly. If he survived D2 and D3 and seemed to become more town over that period of time, sure. Not much he could say right now though. He's been backed into a corner.
I would be happy to give him one more day and see what happens, and lynch NS, but I would still rather lynch Mogri. It's up to how the bandwagons go, really. BK, what is your take on NS? Sorry, hard to keep up with everyone's reads on everyone without skimming through the threads a million times.
In post 688, UberNinja wrote:did i mention that i FUCKING LOVE how NOBODY is giving me the Mogri case?
cause, yeah
Just a vibe. He speaks technically and his posts seem to have no uniform purpose, like he is picking random things to say to hide his scumness. His general reaction to scumhunting in that he interjects at odd times with odd comments that achieve nothing. He never bothered to give me scumreads (from memory, correct me if I am wrong), he just tries to throw random suspiscions on others but doesn't seem contemplative of his suspiscions, emotionally engaged with them or even assured of what he is trying to say. He is trying to fly under the radar with a very odd style that just screams scum.
I won't doubt that other players are doing similar things, but that doesn't make Mogri any less scummy, just that we potentially have a large neighbourhood of scum.
Been looking back through NS, I can't read him properly. He offers little. I would say neutral, leaning towards scum. Inte is my next analysis project
So you're saying other players are doing similar things, but you keep coming back to Mogri regardless?
I think NS is the hardest to read, and I don't like that so he's my third scummiest. though he is a good bit under BB/petapan and mogri. what he has posted has been "sparring jabs" as someone said earlier. He promised to change in his latest post though, so lets hope he changes.
. Still think this guy is scummy as a baseline but still rereading.
I can see both sides of the issue on Mogri. One is that his vote is scummy because petapan replaced BB like a day ago. However, if he legit skimmed, I don't see how this is a scum-exclusive action.
Formerly DemonHybrid. I play mafia extremely occasionally. I run the Song Contest. You can find me there. My GTKAS My old account
seriously try to justify a single point for bbmolla (who isn't in this game anymore) being scum that does not also apply to you because hahahahaha you can't
In post 739, Mogri wrote:Also, what are the odds that there is actually only one scum team and Ythan is trolling us?
I'd say extremely low based on just about everything I know about Mafia, this site, and Ythan.
lolol Ythan -would- do that, and he would laugh all the way to endgame over it, too. Which is not to say he DID do that, but that you don't know his ways as well as you might think you do. When I saw the blue team thing I literally immediately wondered how many factions, if any, there were.
So I guess our votes reset to zero at daylight? That hasn't happened in my other games. I like it, actually. Makes things clearer. I'm still down to vote Mogri today. NS can wait, I agree with teCh, we can see how he does but if his posting doesn't change then I want him dead.
Matias, I know you said you're catching up and that's the only reason I'm going to groan but not pick at your Blondie post. (S)he wants out of the game. And I still personally believe it's more newb than scum but we shall see when the replacement digs in.
I'm v/la this weekend.
Going camping. My vote for Mogri still stands, so.
vote Mogri
Engineers accepted the word “planetary” in its epicyclic sense, but I was always conscious that it also meant “wandering,” “erratic.”
Compassion, Common Sense, and Context should always go together.
In post 739, Mogri wrote:Also, what are the odds that there is actually only one scum team and Ythan is trolling us?
I'd say extremely low based on just about everything I know about Mafia, this site, and Ythan.
lolol Ythan -would- do that, and he would laugh all the way to endgame over it, too. Which is not to say he DID do that, but that you don't know his ways as well as you might think you do. When I saw the blue team thing I literally immediately wondered how many factions, if any, there were.
So I guess our votes reset to zero at daylight? That hasn't happened in my other games. I like it, actually. Makes things clearer. I'm still down to vote Mogri today. NS can wait, I agree with teCh, we can see how he does but if his posting doesn't change then I want him dead.
Matias, I know you said you're catching up and that's the only reason I'm going to groan but not pick at your Blondie post. (S)he wants out of the game. And I still personally believe it's more newb than scum but we shall see when the replacement digs in.
I'm v/la this weekend.
Going camping. My vote for Mogri still stands, so.
vote Mogri
To be fair, I'm still trying to catch up, but perhaps you're right.
I want to see what his replacement has to say.
Formerly DemonHybrid. I play mafia extremely occasionally. I run the Song Contest. You can find me there. My GTKAS My old account