NY 151: Playground Mafia (Game Over-Mafia Win!)

[The Mini-Librarian]

I'm very interested in what reads seacore will come up with. These will be very helpful later on.

Fake God is really scummy. (That reads post was completely useless.)

OGML solidifies my town read on that slot. He seems to be very town motivated.

--

@SC

: If forced to do so right now would you rather vote for pine or junpei?

[Lady Lambdadelta]

DV, what experience do you have playing with Seacore?

inb4 meta defense of seacore

Yeah no.

I have a better reason.

[DeasVail]

None, as far as I'm aware.

What do you think of the slot?

[HezLucky]

DV, what experience do you have playing with Seacore?

inb4 meta defense of seacore

Yeah no.

I have a better reason.

Really? I thought it was an opportunistic jump.

[DeasVail]

Really? I thought it was an opportunistic jump.

By me?

[Seacore]

I'm very interested in what reads seacore will come up with. These will be very helpful later on.

Fake God is really scummy. (That reads post was completely useless.)

OGML solidifies my town read on that slot. He seems to be very town motivated.

--

@SC

: If forced to do so right now would you rather vote for pine or junpei?

My reads will not be really useful later on. I'm a VT replacing into a game and about to be lynched, what insight will that give?

[The Mini-Librarian]

@seacore: Well, I don't think you're a VT, I think you're scum. So town can use these reads to peg other scum later.

Even if you are town, shouldn't you be helping us find scum? Fresh eyes can really help the game. Give us a new perspective on things.

[DeasVail]

The problem I have is that there have been times where I have manipulated the town by acting like town when very close to being lynched, so whenever I think someone may be acting like town, I always think, well I could really see myself doing that to have that kind of effect.

[HezLucky]

Really? I thought it was an opportunistic jump.

By me?

No. By Seacore.

I will revisit this later, though. I'm currently trying to hone my scumhunting skills by reading through an already completed game. Maybe it's not a scumtell :shrug:

[StrangerCoug]

@SC

: If forced to do so right now would you rather vote for pine or junpei?

I already answered that question before you even asked it:

If somebody were to put a gun to my head and say "pick one of these two now or die", I'd be more inclined to vote Pine than Junpei due to my town read on the latter

My reads will not be really useful later on. I'm a VT replacing into a game and about to be lynched, what insight will that give?

This stands out, but I'm having trouble making a firm decision whether this is townie or scummy. I want to say townie, but I really do want Seacore to give a valiant effort into scumhunting and not just throw in the towel.

[Seacore]

I will make an effort the moment the weekend is over, but the post about my reads being really useful felt like a fluff post. Like someone was trying to look like a patient scum hunter.

Of course my junpei vote was opportunistic. It's got the best chance of keeping me alive, and I'm the only town read I have so far.

All my reading and posting today will be, and has been, by phone.

[OhGodMyLife]

Yep, still against lynching seacore and for lynching junpei. Lots of scumminess pushing for a seacore lynch.

[PeregrineV]

Vote Count 2-10

(as of Post 1811)

Seacore (10)

- Maxous, scooby, Benmage, The Mini-Librarian, drmyshotgun, Psyche, kdowns, Junpei, redFF, DeasVail

Junpei (8)

- mastin2, HezLucky, Lady Lambdadelta, OhGodMyLife, Kublai Kahn, Nero Cain, Code_X, Seacore

The Mini-Librarian (1)

- StrangerCoug

redFF (1)

- drmyshottyizsik

Not Voting (1)

- FakeGod

With 21 alive, it takes 11 to lynch

Deadline:

Thursday, May 17, 2012 3pm CDT

Replacing:

No one

Prods:

drmyshottyizsik
scooby

V/LAs:

Mastin May 14
Nero CainMay 14

[drmyshotgun]

Seacore is better than Pine alright. But not enough to change my vote yet.

[Maxous]

Really? I thought it was an opportunistic jump.

By me?

No. By Seacore.

Actually, regardless of alignment it is the only sensible move to make. (unless another rapid bandwagon appears)

@ Deas, Code X: Did either of you expect to get kdowns lynched today when you voted him? Or bandwagoned?

[DeasVail]

I thought it possible.

[Code_X]

@ Maxous. Possible yes. Unlikely though. I just don't think either of these wagons are great truth be told. Macros had a lot of people suspicious of him - kdowns hasn't really done anything. Compare his content since replacing in to Ohmygod for instance.

[DeasVail]

@ Maxous. Possible yes. Unlikely though. I just don't think either of these wagons are great truth be told. Macros had a lot of people suspicious of him - kdowns hasn't really done anything. Compare his content since replacing in to Ohmygod for instance.

Why do you think kdowns would be more likely to post content as town?

[Code_X]

Because, if I was in his shoes I would.

[DeasVail]

Would you post content in his shoes as scum?

[Code_X]

I'd post a little more than he has - but to actively not do anything suggests he either doesn't give a shit "quite possible as I feel a bit like that about the game" or he is scum and has no real interest in reading the thread back and contributing.

Junpei should claim.

[DeasVail]

Well the way I see it, both town and scum in kdowns' position have reason to post content, so I don't really see it as related.

I'm kind of eh on junpei claiming. It's kind of pointless if we're just going to lynch seacore no matter what he claims.

[Code_X]

Seacore has already claimed. Based on the two wagons the names on his wagon are scummier than the names on Junpei's

[DeasVail]

*no matter what Junpei claims.

And I think that considering "scumminess" of wagons is a bad influence on scumhunting, but each to their own.

[DeasVail]

I've looked through a fair bit of Junpei's ISO and am confirming my weak town read of him. Really, I don't see anything scummy. Can I have the main reasons for him being scum summarised? All I remember is suspecting shotgun, and I think that's a bad reason.