SoraAdvent wrote:I may not have jumped on the wagon first, but I personally think that he's scummy. Accusing Arinne of being Scumbuddies with Axxle, using crabbyman's reputation to pin me down, as well as being unsure of being certain things makes me believe he was scum. That's my reasons for why I voted for him.
Let's contrast this with the post where you voted kalbim.
SoraAdvent wrote:Kalbim's been a bit scummy, especially in his previous post, saying that I am scum all because I haven't posted yet. That doesn't make sense, unfortunately. I think he's just trying to divert attention from himself onto me.
Changing your tune a bit, are we? At first, it was because you personally haven't posted. But now it's "crabbyman's reputation" of not posting. And now there's other reasons that you completely failed to mention originally. It reads like you took his accusation personally and hopped on the bandwagon, and then retroactively applied scumhunting to your vote.
Is it any wonder things seem so awry? We swim in a sea of confusion and don't have to think to survive, so nobody listens!
I have changed my tune, after reading his post properly. I did make a mistake in my earlier post. At first I took it personally, and then I realized that he wasn't just aiming for me, which is why I listed on the second post my new reasons.
I feel as though we could have questioned Kalbim further and confirmed our priorities; it seems to me as though we're moving too fast. However, upon checking Kalbim's profile and seeing that he has been regularly logging on (and probably reading what is going on?), it looks like three votes were not enough to pressure him into activity. Therefore...I truly hope that Axxle flips scum.
In post 172, ChaosOmega wrote:Not a huge fan of the kalbim wagon. It's not the worst lynch, since that player slot has 3 posts all game (all from kalbim), and the post with his reads is odd. Just have a gut town read on him for now.
Scum reads are Axxle and SoraAdvent. Axxle just seems intent on looking good as opposed to actually finding scum. It was brought up how he attacked Seacore after Seacore said it made wombat99 look town to him. Seacore barely responded to what Axxle was saying against him, and he goes completely 180 to apologizing for being too pushy and having a town read on him later. As for SoraAdvent, crabbyman66 (who Sora replaced) had the weird "I have no reads on anything" post, which strikes me in the same vein as not wanting to offend anyone and coast along. And then Sora sneaks the third vote onto the kalbim wagon, with essentially an OMGUS vote.
vote: Axxle
Axxle is at L-1. Wait for him to post his reads/a claim/anything before someone hammers.
Arinna wrote:With his reply, Axxle seems very scummy to me (and will continue to be so until his explanation for this line of discussion seems more reasonable and well-founded); I think it would be a better course of action to wait a bit and get to know the new players better, observe their interactions with the rest of the players, and get a broader view of things. Are we truly ready for a claim at this point?
But wouldn't a claim give us more information to do that?
Finally!!!! Somebody who doesn't think I am scum.
I agree with ChaosOmega that we should vote Axxle, and I will come make a post explaining why in an hour or so
In post 183, kalbim wrote:Finally!!!! Somebody who doesn't think I am scum.
I agree with ChaosOmega that we should vote Axxle, and I will come make a post explaining why in an hour or so
People think you're scummy because of your words and actions; in order to improve your situation, please don't lurk, be active, and explain all your actions (and the reasons behind them) until now, not only why you think Axxle should be lynched. Although Axxle might be in L-1, many, if not all, of the players (except for Chaos) do think that you're the next scummiest player after Axxle. If you don't do something, you could be the next to be lynched, so...
Axxle wrote:I really wanted to get more information out of today, but if everyone's willing to end Day 1 so early:
Vote: kalbim
I agree with you that we still have further space to "explore", especially in Kalbim's direction, as he leaves so many things unexplained.
OK, so I know that people have said we should wait before we lynch so they can get more info, but no one is posting. I'm giving it a few hours, and then I'm switching to Axxle, because waiting around not doing anything isn't going to help.
In post 181, Arinna wrote:I feel as though we could have questioned Kalbim further and confirmed our priorities; it seems to me as though we're moving too fast. However, upon checking Kalbim's profile and seeing that he has been regularly logging on (and probably reading what is going on?), it looks like three votes were not enough to pressure him into activity. Therefore...I truly hope that Axxle flips scum.
Does anyone here think that Kalbim's a little scared right now? He's not replying to the topic a lot, and he didn't convert on his promise to post. Still seems scummish to me, and sticking my vote on him.
In post 190, Seacore wrote:I'd rather lynch kalbim, but I still think axxle is scum. I think kalbim has come in, scum slipped and is now terrified of posting.
In post 187, Hyperion wrote:OK, so I know that people have said we should wait before we lynch so they can get more info, but no one is posting. I'm giving it a few hours, and then I'm switching to Axxle, because waiting around not doing anything isn't going to help.
Not that I want to look a gift horse in the mouth, but what made you change your mind about dropping this hammer? If it wasn't just a mistake it solidifies my belief that you are town since mafia wouldn't really have a reason to do so.
The reason why I decided to wait is because some people (I think it was Arinna) said to wait and try to find out some more stuff before we end the day. I waited to see if anyone did anything and nothing happened, so I decided that getting a flip and a nightkill might help. I would rather lynch Axxle today because we have more to go on, than with Kalbim, who has maybe 5 posts total. I definately want to lynch Kalbim tomorrow, if he continues to act the way he has (barely posting, and when he does, being scummy).
Ok, so since Axxle has already claimed, and people still want Kalbim to post,
In the words of MC Hammer: duh nuh nuh nuh, nuh nuh, nuh nuh HAMMER TIME UNVOTE: Kalbim VOTE: Axxle
Thats a lynch, fingers crossed
