Newbie 1252: The Other Game Town Wins!

[Majiffy]

I'm sorry, Thor, did you essentially just equate someone as town because they had sound logic?


This is not the Thor you are looking for.

[Thor665]

It's more the thought process behind the logic - yes.

If you want to try to get him lynched, that's your business. But last I checked, the point was to lynch scum, not attack my town reads...oh, wait, unless you're scum, so...yeah.

[Thor665]

And even if you think I'm playing poorly and buddying him because *I'm* scum...he's still town.

[Majiffy]

I'm not trying to get him lynched, I just think you're being a bit quick on the obvtown reads. This is not the Thor I know and love.

Which means you're probably town, because haven't you been scum in every game I've played with you?

[Thor665]

Maybe - but I am quick on the town reads regardless so...methinks you just read me badly.
Again - hat's the point of having an issue with me calling someone obv. town "a bit quickly".
At the end of the day, how does this matter to you if you don't think he's scum?

[Majiffy]

More an inquiry than a problem. I just don't see what you see, I suppose.

[RXK]

Why aren't you voting right now - do you consider yourself as being overly conservative?

I consider myself to be like 3 pages into the game. If you're gonna call me out for not voting right now then apparently six other players are being overly conservative too.

Actually right now we should probably all take a minute real quick and illustrate the difference between not voting (which 2/3 of the game's members are doing) and being afraid to vote.

The latter thing is what I was trying to get at in that post. I respect that you're not doing the latter.

But last I checked, the point was to lynch scum, not attack my town reads...oh, wait, unless you're scum, so...yeah.

@Robo - yeah, but I need some more sheep to finish you off. You do need to die for this gambit because it's a pretty 'meh' gambit to begin with, you're already past the point of it being useful, and

it will amuse me to kill you regardless of your alignment.

Otherwise I have no idea what you're getting at aside from intentionally doing this to fuck with dudes I guess?

[Thor665]

Why aren't you voting right now - do you consider yourself as being overly conservative?

I consider myself to be like 3 pages into the game. If you're gonna call me out for not voting right now then apparently six other players are being overly conservative too.

The odd point being, you actually kinda dug into...whoever the heck that was you dug into, for not voting.
All while not voting.
Usually people are either gung-ho about it or laid back. As I recall [player you called out] even specifically said they were still feeling out stuff and wanting to think things over and that they'd have other chances to vote.
You then went 'baw! but U no vote, loser!' all while...not voting.
I just don't understand that dichotomy. And since you're calling me out on a dichotomy surely you agree that dichotomies are odd and you desire to understand them.

In answer to your call out - I was trolling one of them for lulz and calling the other out for acting scummy.
You can take your bets as to which was which.

[Thor665]

@Robo - your read on RXK?

[Majiffy]

[RXK]

[quote="In [url=http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 6#p4130736]
The odd point being, you actually kinda dug into...whoever the heck that was you dug into, for not voting.
All while not voting.
Usually people are either gung-ho about it or laid back. As I recall [player you called out] even specifically said they were still feeling out stuff and wanting to think things over and that they'd have other chances to vote.
You then went 'baw! but U no vote, loser!' all while...not voting.
I just don't understand that dichotomy. And since you're calling me out on a dichotomy surely you agree that dichotomies are odd and you desire to understand them.
[/quote]

I didn't think I really dug into Fujinko as much as I was trying to make a point about just not being afraid to vote in games in general and I probably should have further mentioned specifically that in the post. Majiffy pretty much said what I said too and probably explained it in post 33 better than I did.


Can we attribute that more to a "failure to communicate" sort of deal?

Either way I guess how the townn uses our votes is an important topic in this game and mafia as a whole. Are you more of a guy who would rather use them liberally or no? I guess this may be a stupid question because you do have a vote already, but I guess I'm asking what your policy is about it.

[RXK]

is there a way to fix quote tags if they broke? i tried just quote thor's reply to mine but i think i cut out his post data along with my post.

[Majiffy]

That'll do 'er.

VOTE: RXK

Thanks Thor.

p-edit: No, no way to fix them. You could

bold

a request to the mod and see if they'll fix it for you, however.

[RXK]

...something i said?

[Majiffy]

Yep. I'll elaborate later.

[194]

Please do, before someone decides to speedlynch Robo.

[Majiffy]

Robo wagon won't be reached any time soon. And if it is, it'll be quite suspect. I need to see more from you and Iknal, as well as ANYTHING from zabriel. Or at least a replacement of his slot.

[Majiffy]

Also, any comments on the other happenings of the game since your last post, 194?

[194]

Not that much. I'm still impressed at Robo's ability to not give a f*ck about the votes of others over him. However, his gambit is basically useless now as it was already pointed out as that: a gambit (and a gambit needs to keep occult in order to work). I still think he's not scum, however.

So, Thor is qualified as experienced? Sorry, I still need some time to grow accustomed to this site's nomenclatures. Also, his reasoning about Hoss being townie seems consistant.

And yeah, we need actions from zabriel and Iknal. I considered myself inactive but those two together have posted less than me.

[Thor665]

Are you more of a guy who would rather use them liberally or no? I guess this may be a stupid question because you do have a vote already, but I guess I'm asking what your policy is about it.

I'd rather use them than not use them - we're honestly all just sitting around right now waiting for a few more votes to enter play.

Not that much. I'm still impressed at Robo's ability to not give a S*rf about the votes of others over him.

Pssh - we haven't even remotely got tat fire burning yet. You should vote him and see if he stays cool as a cucumber.

Also, [Thor's] reasoning about Hoss being townie seems consistant.

Consistent with what?

And yeah, we need actions from zabriel and Iknal. I considered myself inactive but those two together have posted less than me.

Do you find that scummy of them?
Do you find anything scummy yet?

Please do, before someone decides to speedlynch Robo.

That would bother you? He's even voting himself, so he agrees with the case on him as well.

[Majiffy]

Thor is qualified as an IC as well, yes. In fact, he was qualified as an IC before I even came to this site.

[Thor665]

Though whether I'm a qualified IC is another matter.

More people should be voting - that's my 'not the IC in this game' advice.

I'm allowed to lie about my advice in this game.

[194]

Not that much. I'm still impressed at Robo's ability to not give a S*rf about the votes of others over him.

Pssh - we haven't even remotely got tat fire burning yet. You should vote him and see if he stays cool as a cucumber.

Could work. I will give it some thoughts

Also, [Thor's] reasoning about Hoss being townie seems consistant.

Consistent with what?

Probably badly worded from me. I was trying to say that reasoning didn't look flawed to me.

And yeah, we need actions from zabriel and Iknal. I considered myself inactive but those two together have posted less than me.

Do you find that scummy of them?
Do you find anything scummy yet?

zabriel hasn't posted anything and that can't be qualified in any way. Iknal could be lurking, however, as he has effectively posted but not really contributed. That could be considered scum activity. I will wait for his next post, assuming it happens anytime soon.

Please do, before someone decides to speedlynch Robo.

That would bother you? He's even voting himself, so he agrees with the case on him as well.

As I was saying before, I still think Robo is townie. However, yeah, he doesn't seem to care about his own life. I won't vote him yet, but once again, I could end up giving that a try.

[Iknal]

Posting to say ill post in 24 hours. Hopefully 12 (ie: after work tomorrow, hopefully before.)

[Robocopter87]

Please do, before someone decides to speedlynch Robo.

No. We want that to happen.

RXK? Not much to go off of, but Post #60 is definitely interesting. However I can definitely create scenarios in my head that he does the same thing as either alignment.

Not that much. I'm still impressed at Robo's ability to not give a f*ck about the votes of others over him. However, his gambit is basically useless now as it was already pointed out as that: a gambit (and a gambit needs to keep occult in order to work). I still think he's not scum, however.

So, Thor is qualified as experienced? Sorry, I still need some time to grow accustomed to this site's nomenclatures. Also, his reasoning about Hoss being townie seems consistant.

And yeah, we need actions from zabriel and Iknal. I considered myself inactive but those two together have posted less than me.

If I'm town then why would votes bother me? If I'm scum only votes would bother me. However what if I'm scum posing as town by doing things scum wouldn't do? This is WIFOM. (IC can elaborate on that)

Thor is not your IC, yes he is qualified and very good at it. I'm qualified and don't do it because I am not very good at it. This is Majiffy's game to do it though. He will. If you need help, ask Majiffy, if Majiffy leaves for quite sometime then me or Thor or Iknal will be around.

Not that much. I'm still impressed at Robo's ability to not give a S*rf about the votes of others over him.

Pssh - we haven't even remotely got tat fire burning yet. You should vote him and see if he stays cool as a cucumber.

Could work. I will give it some thoughts

Also, [Thor's] reasoning about Hoss being townie seems consistant.

Consistent with what?

Probably badly worded from me. I was trying to say that reasoning didn't look flawed to me.

And yeah, we need actions from zabriel and Iknal. I considered myself inactive but those two together have posted less than me.

Do you find that scummy of them?
Do you find anything scummy yet?

zabriel hasn't posted anything and that can't be qualified in any way. Iknal could be lurking, however, as he has effectively posted but not really contributed. That could be considered scum activity. I will wait for his next post, assuming it happens anytime soon.

Please do, before someone decides to speedlynch Robo.

That would bother you? He's even voting himself, so he agrees with the case on him as well.

As I was saying before, I still think Robo is townie. However, yeah, he doesn't seem to care about his own life. I won't vote him yet, but once again, I could end up giving that a try.

Please never do that again. Don't write inside quotes. Just quote and respond, please. Its more of a ease of reading your posts. I didn't even realize what you had done until I looked closer at it.