In post 410, MagnaofIllusion wrote:Sala wrote:Tell me, since you have been in more games than I have, are you telling me, that it is Impossible to have all members bus their godfather. I know you are going to tell me something of the words of "highly unlikely,"
Well the word impossible doesn’t apply to Mafia. But I’ll slot the chances that Presc was power-bussed by all his teammates as so unlikely it might as well be zero.
Put another way (in the words of Llamarble) – I’d be comfortable enough losing to the scum-team that did it if I’m wrong. Because it would require play that was so potentially damaging to scum’s wincon that the Risk / Reward is way too heavily slanted to Risk.
That said – evidence this is Multiball makes all bets off on this front as scum from the opposite team would not be bussing Presc.
I can see why this hurts mafia's chances, but in the case of Arugula and Prescending, couldn't scum see Prescending was going to get lynched either way and hop on to create such a distance? But of course, this is becomming WIFOM so I'm going to drop it.
In post 410, MagnaofIllusion wrote:Sala wrote:1. I think the above addresses my thoughts on this well enough.
2. Where did I say ROFL is ‘100% confirmed Town”?
Well, way you have been going with it, you pretty much call him confirmed town for hammering the GF, which I could see both sides, where town could do it, and where scum could do it, but its more WIFOM.
In post 410, MagnaofIllusion wrote:Sala wrote:Gut isn’t a reason that holds any weight. If you can’t articulate why you think one of those two HAS to be scum in a way that relates to the game thread then your stance can’t be considered credible.
That's debateable, I've had some good gutreads, and some bad ones, but I'm sure we all do.
But in all seriousness, ROFL has been fluffy, or he has been trying to push Empking's lynch with the "strawman" BS. What is the possibility he could be third-party with VE? I just find it hard to believe he is town.
But then again, as town, I would tell Vig/SK to kill my counter-wagon in his position.
In post 410, MagnaofIllusion wrote:Sala wrote:You didn’t answer the question. I was trying to gauge how strong your ‘gut’ feeling on this is. I'm not asking if you think you will get vigged. I'm asking - if both Emp and ROFL flip Town would it be a prudent move (from a not-Sala point of view) for Town to lynch you given your stance?
I think about it, and I think VE has alot of good choices for his NK.
But anyways, is my gut read strong enough to risk my vanilla townie life when we have 2 scum kills? Yes, I would probably lynch you or anyone else who did it. I would leave with you my reads on be on my way.
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Dude, why must you post stuff like this? Why? Seriously, if you quit posting shit like this, we could be lynching your scumbuddy Arugula.
But no, in all seriousness, I hate this post, and I hate the one where you are willing to attempt to kill Empking STILL even after a JK claim, how the fuck is that not scummy. I'm done with you, die.
UNVOTE: PMmysterious
VOTE: ROFL
ROFL,PM,Arugula, and possibly TF.
GG.
