In post 428, Toon Fighter wrote: In post 426, PMysterious wrote:Sure, lynch me. I'm a safe lynch, right? No! Its one that will tick me off. If you wanna lynch me, look into anyone that is on my wagon. Besides, I can be a meat-shield for you guys. I'll take the Mafia blow. There is no one else that can at this point. Don't lynch me and I PROMISE to help find scum.
AtE and fluff. Let's just lynch here and be done with it.
You are correct about it being AtE and fluff. Does that make him more likely to be scum?
In post 429, PMysterious wrote: In post 427, Salamence20 wrote:Plus, how are YOU going to find scum when you have no reads on anyone other than MoI and Empking.
Simple. We play the game out and look for more scum tells. Eventually, we WILL kill off all scum.
You can start doing that now. You don't have to wait.
In post 442, McStab wrote:@MoI: I'm fine with a policy lynch with two dead scum and PM as a possible third scum, on Day Two. There's simply no chance of scum killing PM overnight at this rate, and we'll have to lynch him at some point before LyLo, I can see some real advantages to it this early in the game. As for Toon and Toog, both have had very opportunistic tendencies, neither were on the Prescending wagon D1, and they both have had minimal reads beyond sheeping one wagon or another (although Toog has admittedly answered more questions and been more transparent than Toon).
Regardless of whether it's policy or a scum lynch (I am more inclined to think he'll flip scum) PM is a good lynch today. Worst possible situation is he flips VT and we narrow down the pool of possible scum and a huge distraction, best possible situation is he flips scum.
I agree about most of this, and your logic seems to be that if we are wrong, it is better to be wrong about PM who is a VI than Toon. I do not agree with that, because Toon isn't even trying while PM is at least putting in effort.
In post 457, Salamence20 wrote: In post 456, MagnaofIllusion wrote:Sala wrote:Also, if PM Flips scum, Arugula is probably the last scum.
1. What happens if he flips Town?
2. Why are you so certain that we have 4 total Mafia?
1. I would probably still think Arugula is scum, probably better than TF.
2. I don't like this question, MoI. It's the same psychological bullshit Junpei pulled on me as scum. How should I know how many scum are in a Large Normal? I would say 2 goons, a RB (if empking is lying), and a GF, or possibly 2 goons, a doctor (if VE is SK), and the GF. Do I look like a guy that knows much about Role Setup?
So, Arugula is scum either way? Then why do you even mention any connection to PM? Also, MoI's question is legitimate. I have seen scum caught with this kind of thing.
This is the type of play we can expect from you then?
If this is seriously wanting Empking dead in the night after his claim, then... I have no idea what you are thinking.
In post 479, mcqueen wrote:Also, if the vig decides not to be on Empking, then we will be able to find him at that point. I have a big theory on who the vig is, and if he is not on Empking tonight, I'll find him tomorrow.
Ummm... VE has claimed Vig? Do you remember what has happened in this game?
In post 489, roflcopter wrote:salamence stop saying things continue to make you look like empking's scumpartner. stop trying to direct the vig and stop trying to direct the vig away from anyone in particular. partner tell x1000
Ummm... wait. So mcqueen directs the vig and nothing, but sala "directs the vig" and this? Why?
Meaning?
Also, I realize I have asked people questions, and I thing some people didn't respond, so later I will check previous posts of mine for those questions.
