In post 209, xvart wrote:Your votes on evilpacman are not doing any good for a town agenda.
KageLord's most recent post screams scum to me because he is answering a question directed at someone else before the other person gets the opportunity; and I think he is only doing this because he wants to get out in front of the rblinker connection and had to get it out early about the "obv buddying" and WIFOM "that would be really stupid if we both were scum".
First of all, I didn't have to get out in front of the connection as the people that posted weren't looking for my head. Second, it is a perfectly town move to not want to be dragged down by the scum that was buddying you. Third, WIFOMy maybe, but true. And again, look over my scum meta to see that I bus scumbuddies that get themselves in trouble.
Based on the fact that rblinker got busted for fence sitting around the early scum reads on KageLord I'm guessing he wasn't really playing the long game here; which is further proved by the fact that he disappeared so he really wasn't going for a team strategy other than lurk and hide, strategically replace out.
The final nail in the scum coffin is the fact that he really just talked about how everyone could be scum, made no definitive decision about who he was likely to vote for, and then said he was down with a lurker lynch.
VOTE: KageLord
1. "Talked about how everyone could be scum": Did you read the post? I actually said the opposite. I said that I picked my list based on POE because most people look town (and indeed most are).
2. "Made no definitive decision who he was likely to vote for": Again, did you read it? I actually give a list of the 3 people I am likely to vote for and give you the order that I would vote for them in. The only reason that post didn't contain a vote is because the day just started, lynches can happen quick with so few people, and I want to hear from VE before voting.
3. "Down with a lurker lynch": First of all, there is a precondition to that, which you kindly left out of your post (aka misrep). Also, are you saying that you do not want to lynch lurker VE?
In post 211, evilpacman18 wrote:Robbnva, you obviously don't understand my reasoning, and since you're trying to tell me that drchrist is confirmed town (LOL) I'm not gonna bother with you right now, I'm confirmed town whether you realize it or not, as is my list.
Can you give us reasons why on this?
Except maybe KL, I'll trust xvart on this one, especially since he's (KL)
trying so hard to buddy me
.
... Pretty sure you didn't read my post at all. If you had, you would realize that you are the person I put as second most likely to be scum (after xvart).
drchrist is still my vote though, I mean look at the reasoning in in 207, it assumes I'm scum because I lynched her when she could have been a PR except she turned out to be scum, so those two things are mutually exclusive. This isn't a hindsight is 20/20 fallacy, let me explain farther. Drchrist's reasoning is that I'm scum because that hammer was scummy. What if she was a PR? But that doesn't make any sense because if I'm scum then I knew she was scum, and you're not accusing me of bussing, you're accusing me of a bad lynch.
Did I take a risk? Hell yeah I took a risk. I also lynched scum so stop trying to fake indignation, please.
... I am very tempted to smack this down too, but I'll let Drchrist give it a shot.
PEDIT: Well, that wasn't exactly the answer I was hoping for from a town Dc, but it's close enough. Point is that good town wouldn't take that risk for no reason. Assuming good play, more likely explanation would be a scum bus since you knew she wouldn't flip town PR, which would cause us to become more suspicious of you. Only reason I'm not sold on that train of thought is I'm not assuming good play.
