Pless, the town read on Tierce is partially meta based but also a lot based on her play; I've seen her play this same way and have this same attitude in a few games where she was town. But specifically Post 49 of instantly noticing the same thing Edd did as the 'slip' is a big town-tell and her comments directed to Feysal sense. Also the sheer number of times she moves her votes/chooses even switching them around here and there is a big town-tell as it shows that she's thinking things though to a level higher than she would as scum. Her "Starbuck isn't for lynching" comments are a massive town-tell as that's how she handles her town-reads even if she believes they're harmful or playing badly. Plus her explanation for her initial choose vote on Tammy being that she trusts her to use the gun correctly if town and wants her out of the game due to clash in their play is something that is spot-on with how they've interacted in prior games.
Hasdasg, I'll try and explain why this matches Edds town-play but Tammy can probably jump in and explain it better too. Arthur is a significantly stronger town player than anything else and he loves to jump into games, put himself in the midst of things and take stances, he's done all three of those things this game. The way that Post 14 is phrased comes of as very natural because he's stating an opinion on the mechanic, then proceeding to ask others thoughts on it. Then look at the phrasing of Post 48 and Post 52 especially look at the timing of it, only just a few minutes after Feysal makes his post Edd posts stating that he thinks Feysal count have potentially slipped, then goes and does some research into the OP for a few minutes locking his vote in on Feysal when he finds no mention of multi-faction in the OP. It's a really really natural thought process. Also look at his frustration in Post 88 him getting annoyed about pushing on a scum-read makes a lot of sense as town whereas not sure how that sort of frustration by a little bit of suspicion makes sense as scum there. The jump back to Starbuck in Post 260 shows that his reads aren't static and that he's actually re-reading and re-considering everything which is a big town-tell. That should be enough.
In post 409, Staeg wrote:Re: Regfan's 345 - again, for the millionth time I ask: how is posting 10 posts of 50 words worse than 2 of 250?
People generally look at the number of pages first, if they see the game has exploded with 10+ pages they're more inclined to want to replace out or procrastinate instead of getting to the game (Pappums is a perfect example of this) whereas walls and longer posts do much less of that and in worst case the people with less time or who are lazier can just glimpse/skim read them (Which they shouldn't do!) so it's much less harmful.