In post 1669, Dolorous Edd wrote:Hmm.. you probably shouldn't have said that. For example, I interpreted the jailing as the mod will announce thenumbers, not the actually people who voted where. If scum saw it like that too, they could've sent in their votes for someone to try block a PR or something.
In post 1695, Pandora wrote:So I have a neat question here, why the hell would you ask this and why would you tell everyone about it if it's true? This is not the kind of information town should be looking for. Anyone asking for clarification about if their jail choice is going to be outted should be kicked in the balls.
(I see Edd said the same thing. Too little too late I guess)
Simply put because I clarify every little thing with Faraday. Faradays later comment in Post 1659 hinted very strongly that revealing of names and such would be the case so it's not outting anything that scum don't already likely know and if they didn't the odds of it being revealed via one of them asking themselves, someone else bringing it up or Faraday making it more clear in the thread are super high so I don't see the harm in revealing it earlier rather than later so we can organize a proper jailing technique or plan for today (Which would be everyone just sending in their vote on a town-read they want alive rather than a pool of 3).
In post 1689, Dolorous Edd wrote:DCL/Jal/Regfan scumteam. Bvoigt/Staeg/MoS scumteam. Starbuck might be some weird third party. [Snip]
WHAT'S LEFT(the lynches after the above pile):Petyr Baelish7) kortul, 18) Benmage
For one if you think I'd buss in a multi-ball on D1 you're kidding yourself or don't know me at all and for two you've dropped your 'super-mega-strong-town-read' on me because DCL was defensive to me pushing on him (Which is likely because I was the only person focusing on him at the time and if I continued it'd likely lead to his lynch.) For three I want you to explain to me why Kortul/Benmage are in your nullish tier, think both are relatively obvtown.
In post 1690, Zdenek wrote:I'm leaning town on Benmage, but there were a few things that bothered me with his early play - some buddying and I don't like that he called for snowstorm's mason buddy to claim. [Snip] My read on Benmage has shifted to leaning scum. He's defended DCL, bvoigt (who will likely flip scum), he demanded that snowstorm's buddy claim and now he'd prefer to lynch the claimed power-role. All of this taken in combination makes him pretty likely scum.
I don't think buddying is a scum-tell for him, think he just does it naturally, I remember him doing it to Llamarbale in White Flag where Benmage was town. He didn't really defend DCL in fact I'd argue that the way he reacted to him is significantly more likely to make him town, his reaction was the way that DCL claimed is town but that DCL still needed to die, I remember a conversation and interaction between the two where Benmage was telling DCL that he had to die for the good of the town with DCL arguing, that doesn't come from partners, not a chance. Also his defending of Bvoigt is something I did at the time too as was his fight towards different lynches, both of the wagons came across as town D1 (Sapor/Bvoigt) and it was a constant fight to try to find a better compromise lynch.
In post 1690, Zdenek wrote:I have never seen Regfan as scum. Can he not fake his town meta?
No, I can't. I mean my scum play is relatively effective, if someone didn't know my meta at all and I was scum against them I'd be very likely to win, think I've only been lynched 2ish times in 10 scum games but my town and scum play have a lot of differences in them. I absolutely detest being scum and it comes across in my play a lot, get very dis-motivated, lurk quite a bit and all up don't contribute much time to 'thinking' about the game.