NY 160: Terrible Melodrama Mafia (Game Over)

[Demon Core]

He can't act like newb scum because he's not a newb at all.

Where does your line of logic begin and end?

[Demon Core]

I beg for attention and NC laughs in my face.

I feel so....... rejected.

[Senjai]

Dont pick at my nomenclature NC. You're just raging right now. I think the pressure is getting to you. Now your saying you are agressing me because of my join date, I'm totally LOVING YOUR AD HOMINEM ATTACKS. Makes you so reputable. Using join date as an excuse in argument = scummy, keep your red herring fallacies away from me.

Mafiascum isn't the only site for mafia. I played mafia on teamliquid.net for ages, and in clubs irl. There are other people who disagree, not just you. I have my opinion you have yours, i even said I'm not looking for agreement, so why are you still whining about it. Need meta to be reliably right in rvs, keyword is reliably, or consistently. Not always. Which I stated in one of my previous posts.

It wasnt a lie, it was a gambit. Well a lie for the sake of scumhunting.

*snip*

Now, when I gave these reads I was lying. All of my reads stand except the one on Toonfighter. Toonfighter has been the most obvious and stubborn in supporting my lynch while not scumhunting anybody else. As quoted he doesnt respond to any of the other posts, nor imo does he try to reliably scumhunt anyone either than me.

So this is what I attempted to do.

I would make a post saying that he's a town read. I'd expect him to back off of his position as scum. Because he knows that two people consider me town, by associating himself with me or backing off he could get some cheap towncred with those two people. While in later times he could argue he was scumhunting the wagon, was satisfied, and went with my reasoning. I changed my vote to Nero Cain (dont get me wrong NC, I still think your scumtastic) and expected him to hop on. Had he have done this I would make it my lifes desire to have him lynched.

But he only went partway, and that was backing off his position (again with no explination). He didnt do this when I attempted to reason with him (among others like theamatuer and Anxiety) but only when I stated that I had a slight town read. This is SCUMMY. Though not as scummy as if he hopped on with me, I wont vote him yet. but...

FOS: ToonFighter

How is that scummy? I thought you knew what you're talking about mr 2009.

[Senjai]

You're wrong, that's actually a scumtell.

But I'd have to be scum for it to be a scumtell. And I'm not so...

If JS flips scum, lynch this with fire.

[Senjai]

@Piggy

What is your read on DemonCore?

@Everyone on the JS wagon.

Why is JS scummy for calling somebody "nervos town" but 4xn skates by for doing something similar?

Read #115. Also lets here what you think about everyone else, when you cool off that is.

[Senjai]

@MOD: Where is Number Six?

He hasnt posted yet. And adorkable hasnt posted in forever.

[JacobSavage]

Thate the point I'm making. We're both saying the same thing. My logic is exactly the same as yours!

I am saying that he can't be a newb scum attacking anything that moves as hes not a newb so he must have a good reason for it.

[Senjai]

JS you give me a headache.

[Demon Core]

So, he's not acting like newb scum, and therefore he's town?

If that's not it, then I'm stumped.

[JacobSavage]

no as in he's not acting like newb scum therefore he must have a valid reason behind it.

[Demon Core]

So, it's alignment null...

Where are you getting "town"?

[Senjai]

It's okay, I'll go get some rope from the store. Brb

[JacobSavage]

It was a gut based on his posts in general. I cant really explain it anymore than that really.

[adorkable]

as of page 3:

- piggy's RVS FoS of Nero is bad and so is her posts on page 2

- amateur's defense of senjai is also bad

- planb's #50 gives me baaad vibes

- senjai is town. bad, but town.

Fixed. Above was originally posted on a different account.
-DV

fucking this up already...

@Mod, take care of that post plz?

[adorkable]

savage giving me bad vibes too off of page 4

I'll sift through the long-ish posts later

unvote
vote: piggy

for now

[Cletus+Brandine]

Playing on a phone is quite annoying. I'm just gonna go through and quote stuff that sticks out to me, with my thoughts.

[Cletus+Brandine]

And statistically wise, yes

it's very much possible

that you'll find scum during RVS.

Is it plausible?

No.

Not really

we have two weeks. Tons of time to get through everyones bullshit.

you do know that this is logic that usually comes from scum right?

Then why haven't you voted me? Perhaps it does in your scenario, maybe you missed my point, the first half hour of the game REALLY doesn't matter.

I agree. Though 30 mins=//=2 weeks. Though town should take however mych time is needed to scumhunt and shouldn't ever waste it 'cause "there's still time"

My vote isn't on you 'cause your a 12' join date but if you really want it there I'd be more than happy to oblige.

vote:Senjai

Advises Senjai he sounds like scum but doesn't vote Senjai.

Testing the waters perhaps?

Then gets baited into voting l-2 on page two.

Lulz.

[Cletus+Brandine]

Plan B is a bro.

[Cletus+Brandine]

Toon fighter and demon core seem pretty okay to me also

[Cletus+Brandine]

um, derp, yes you did answer it. What do you think of the last chainsaw accusation (by Toon Fighter)?

N, what's with the no vote? What do

you

think of the Senjai wagon?

I'm sorry >.< I have nothing left to say

Nothing at all? Senjai gave some reads, does this make him scum?

Yes nothing at all o.O I don't know, someone do something scummy so that I have something to talk about. Right now everyone is null/scum except Senjai who's town because my gut tells me so.

This post needs to die and so does piggy.

She's discouraging people from scumhunting by saying rvs doesn't matter and trying to say nothing interesting is happening. At the same time she's got a gut town read on Senjai. So she's got a gut town on the only major wagon and no scum reads.

Seriously... nothing scummy has happened?

[Cletus+Brandine]

Are we really going to argue about RVS?

VOTE: PiggyGal

This is a serious vote

DIAF

I want bacon

Just going through everyones posts, and found this.
Only post (Not that I am one to talk, also adorkable has one RVS post still....) not a serious vote but accompanied with a non-serious comment....

It was a serious vote. Everything in this game is serious to me and i believe everything is important, even rvs. I still like to have fun and make fun comments, but I believe everything "counts" in a game of mafia. You pick on the little things at first and get reactions and get people talking. That's how you get into meatier stuff and get more sure who is scum.

[N]

Senjai, what do you think of your wagon? What about what you were up to L-2?

As long as theirs a wagon its cool. Great for scumhunting. If someone quicklynches that quickly then I dont want to be a part of this town. Also it was technically L-3, as I was one of those votes.

That's not what I was asking. I meant to ask what you think of the people on your wagon.

If JS flips scum i'd say he slipped up and was trying to defend NC (which isn't really possible given his reasons for my vote) and or wagon with NC.

Do you think scum-JS is more likely to be defending a buddy, or buddying a town?

no as in he's not acting like newb scum therefore he must have a valid reason behind it.

Why do you think the only way of being scum is to be new-scum?

[Cletus+Brandine]

i would say mre piggy is probably nervous town than scrum but so far there really has not been enough to say either way with any sort of uncertainty

Oh hey look who defended piggy for no reason at all

[Cletus+Brandine]

Mai top scum reads:
Piggy
Jacob
Nero

[JacobSavage]

I'm just on my way to bed but I thought I should say 1. Cleuts is giving off scum vibes to me already and not in OMGUS. His argument on Mrs piggy is weak and mainly resting on the fact defending people you think are town is bad.

I'll reply to the rest of you in the morning but Inflatable Pie, we have played before haven't we? 112?