NY 160: Terrible Melodrama Mafia (Game Over)

[4nxi3ty]

His question to me did seam like he was trying to find someone to band wagon with

this is the kind of paranoid theory that I expect to come more often from town than scum.

piggy is scum for reasons already mentioned and for the caving in and making a longer post because someone else expected her to; eventhough she wasn't planning on making one and hates making wall posts.

[PiggyGal15]

It wasn't going to be a wall post, but I had more things to comment on then I thought, so it became a wall post. I didn't even re-read through that post to make sure it grammatically made sense and didn't have errors.

[Senjai]

Ikr, I've been waiting for someone to do a contrast. Also you can answer my question DC xD

[Senjai]

I feel persuaded by Doom and Anxiety. Piggy is panicking and it's obvious.

HOWEVER

I want to hear from RC before we lynch.

[Senjai]

EBWOP:

UNVOTE

[Senjai]

if Piggy flips scum I expect the lot of you to join me on JS next round.

[PiggyGal15]

Piggy is panicking and it's obvious.

??? Explain?

[DeasVail]

Vote Count 1.07

JacobSavage (5)- Plan B, DoomYoshi, Toon Fighter, theamatuer, PiggyGal15
PiggyGal15 (5)- Cletus+Brandine, Untrod Tripod, adorkable, 4nxi3ty, Demon Core
Cletus+Brandine (2) JacobSavage, N
Senjai (1)- Nero Cain

Not voting: RedCoyote, Senjai

With 15 alive, it takes 8 to lynch.

V/LA

Half of adorkable- Until the 8th

Deadline

14th November, 6am AEDT

[RedCoyote]

Alright, coming into this game like an avocado on fire. Reading now.

[RedCoyote]

Mod

, will you edit the VC to include your new favorite replacement, please?

[RedCoyote]

Spoiler: Some Notes

I have no issue with prolonging RVS by a few posts or even a page, we have two weeks. Tons of time to get through everyones bullshit.

In other words, "eh, hey, guys, leave me alone... can we go back to RVS... please... please..."

---

I didn't like Piggy's chainsaw defense of Senjai. ME thinks there is something worth investigating in there

Agreed.

---

Setting aside the remarkable fencesitting nature of this post, where do you get "nervous"?

I like this post a lot too.


---

It wasnt serious im afraid?
On a related note, do you think one of them where acting scummy at the time?

This is kind of a strange response after your name has been brought up. You seem to be ignoring it.

What does anyone else think?

:/

---

You

should

care (atleast a lil') since if you know that you are town then you should try to not appear scummy and A.) NOT get yourself mislynced and B.) make other townies think you are scummy thereby letting scum slip by sice the attention is on you.

Even if you are playing "scummy" to bolster your scum meta you should be policy lynched.

This sounds extremely forced.

---

Second of all, I havent moved my vote because currently there is nothing worth moving it too.

Cop out.

---

Plan B's post 154 is really on top of things.

---

Good work having scum-reads on three of the biggest wagons.

Good work having no scumreads and no vote.

Coming into this game, I think both of the top wagons are perfectly valid. I think the JS wagon is more valid because he is far too concerned with what others think about his reads and activity. He seems to be sticking his finger in the air to see which was the votes are going before making any firm stands on anyone. I think both PG15 and N are playing under the radar. I'm not impressed with either of them so far. N in particular ir rubbing me the wrong way. He has kind of kept himself unknown for the majority of the day before popping up for a "gotcha!" vote on C+B. I didn't like it at all. It felt more like he was trying to distract the thread than he was genuinely preturbed with C+B's response.

In any case, I will gladly contribute to the JS wagon right now.

Vote: JacobSavage

[Demon Core]

My old nemesis. Scum Red Coyote

We meet again.

[RedCoyote]

Oh, no. Not this time. You can count on me, DC!

[Demon Core]

RC and his buddies kill townies at night.

[Demon Core]

Oh, the old "change my avatar to a harmless bowl of Trix" routine.

Doesn't fool me, RC.

[RedCoyote]

Lol, close!

[JacobSavage]

@Red, the reason why I ask for others opinions is two-fold.
1. I never trust my own reads, and as such I automatically assume they are wrong. So by asking other people's opinions it's not so much that I'm asking for others opinions its more that if a couple of other people are picking up on similar things then I can have more confidence in what I am saying.
2. I like having lots of information for me to anaylise. I would prefer to have about 30 decent posts from a player before I can be more confident in anything I say about them. So thus by asking people's opinions meams people will post more and what they post I can look at and mull over. I hope this explains so of what you found scummy.

[JacobSavage]

@All I will post more responses to people tommorrow, I just saw reds as I was going to bed.

[Senjai]

DC, would you be wiling vote JS?

[Demon Core]

no

[N]

EBWOP: N you should have a vote down by now. Your using the same reasoning as nero, except 150 posts later. Thats not good.

I do have a vote down. I admit it's not on one of the leading wagons, but I'm always nervous of quicklynches after previous games I've been in.

Also, we find out a lot about C+B.

Let's just say for a second you are 100% correct. Lynching JS lets us know about Nero.
However, by that same logic, lynching piggy lets us know about C+B, but also (to a lesser extent) JS.

What would we find out about C+B by lynching Piggy?

I would prefer to have about 30 decent posts from a player before I can be more confident in anything I say about them.

You won't have reads on anyone until they've made 30 posts?

[Senjai]

Why not DC, you do not agree he is scummy?

N why don't you have a vote on JS or Piggy? They have the consensus that at least one of them are scum. Are you trying to take attention away from them?

[Demon Core]

Piggy is panicking and it's obvious.

??? Explain?

Well, it's quite simple ms. piggy.

You had JS on your townreads (with 4xn as a really shitty scumread) and then realized you had a wagon on you gaining momentum, so you knew you had to join the counterwagon. Jacob's been bumbling around with his disorganized and scattered thoughts all game, but it's just now that you have an issue with them. You even stoop so low as to completely invent a scumslip to try to drive a nail in his coffin.

Another part of your stayin' alive campaign: throwing out townreads to everyone on the JS wagon and a couple people not on your wagon. The preemptive defense ("Anyone who complains that ..." paragraph) is also scummy. The Anxiety scumread gets dropped entirely (town tend to at least address gut reads, they don't tend to ignore them).

part 1 of several...

[Demon Core]

Why not DC, you do not agree he is scummy?

I don't. His wagon is obviously scum-ridden, it's absurd. They've taken advantage of his scatterbrained playstyle and poor communication skills.

His indignant attitude isn't characteristic of scum. Neither is the scummy-scum-scum composition of his wagon.

[Senjai]

Who on his wagon is scum then? Yes it's possible, but it could very well be poor scum play as well, I wouldn't count that out.