Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Legacy (Game Over)

[pidgey]

LOL i dont give a rats ass about BC.

Whos BC anyway

[pidgey]

I just think Mastin has a better chance of being scum

[Tammy]

AP - What made you start thinking that BC was town?

[AngryPidgeon]

Well, I can't see that Benmage is scum right now. His claim is good and if he is town faking a role, then ..no I don't think that is the case.

I do believe he has a guilty on Tammy. Which means that Tammy is a miller (nope lol) or is SK / on a scumteam that isn't AV's.

So really Tammy is scum. And she is going down today. I highly doubt she is faking the DayVig bit because that would be a very strange kneejerk reaction (unless she really did just want to out a 2nd pr before being shown the door, but I doubt it)

Benmage logic about framer is bad. How do I shot math?

@Ben: Where I thought Myk was going is that IF Tammy is town then she should KNOW you are lying, so why hasn't she shot you then? Answer: shes scum.

Tammy, why does Ben have a guilty on you? Is he really that fucking stupid that he is fakeclaiming cop?

P-edit: Don't shoot Mastin or Pidgey. Especially Mastin. Kise/RC #1 Day kills. BC/Snifit are ok.

Mykonian: are you suggesting that Benmage is scum?

P-p-edit: I thought he was town after I replaced in. More a gut read than anything, but his response to me calling him out on being less active here than elsewhere looked genuine. I did not like his reaction to me saying he could be scum with Melmond.

[AngryPidgeon]

Tammy, name claim. Why is that so hard?

[Tammy]

You would be silly to take me out today. I'm dying tonight. There's no way they're going to leave alive a dayvig that can and will take them out. I mean maybe they think I won't fire correctly, but I doubt they'll take that chance especially when I've made it clear that I'll take suggestions to shoot.

You lynch me today, Benmage dies tonight most likely. Now there must be a protective role that protected someone last night so there is that, but still.

[Benmage]

Yep, plus mafia RB is already down... Two teams/You SK... possible.

But guilty = hanging period.

[mykonian]

"@Ben: Where I thought Myk was going is that IF Tammy is town then she should KNOW you are lying, so why hasn't she shot you then? Answer: shes scum."

ben knows. He just doesn't want to die if she's a SK. (and she doesn't really want to kill him if she's the SK. Benmage flipping cop just confirms her being scum). If tammy was 100% sure she's town, she should have shot the fakeclaiming benmage.

I had both high on my townlist, AP. I was wrong about one of them, as neither is backing out of the claims in any way. I'm curious to see which one it is.

This is all great fun. If benmage is the scum, tammy should shoot him (as she is town then, probably). If tammy is scum, she's going to wriggle out of killing benmage (as that confirms her as scum). And she's doing just that now.

[Tammy]

Hey Thad - Since you're around. Any reason I shouldn't dayvig you right now?

[mykonian]

I mean, people have to appreciate this whole dance, right? I can't be the only one.

[AngryPidgeon]

Tammy, flavor. Also, why does Benmage have a guilty on you?

P-edit: I kind of see your point, but I just can't fathom why Benmage would be fake claiming right now.

P-pedit: I know, the thread went from dull -> exploding in a matter of minutes.

[Benmage]

I mean, people have to appreciate this whole dance, right? I can't be the only one.

Its a waste of time, thats adding massive unneccessary fluff to the game.

Im going to the gym. Lynch the scum.

[Tammy]

Flavor is I'm a dayvig. I have no idea why he has a guilty on me, maybe because I am technically a killer. I've played in a game before in which vigs came up as killers to investigations.

[AngryPidgeon]

Its not entirely unnecessary. Scum or not, Tammy apparently has a shot left.

That would be a gunsmith type role. I dont think Benmage would say cop to mean GS. Name claim.

[Tammy]

I have more than one shot left. I already claimed my role.

[AngryPidgeon]

Yes, Im asking for a flavor claim.

[mykonian]

fluff... perhaps, I guess. I'm enjoying this kind of fluff. I can totally see tammy-sk with the dilemma.

"shit, guilty
can't kill benmage, he'll flip town cop, too many questions to answer, I'll get lynched.
I could let them direct my kill. As long as I survive I'm fine with that solution.
As long as benmage lives, I'm not confirmed scum yet"

I mean, the whole thing would be unnecessary if she were town.

"Benmage claimed guilty on me.
there's no way he could get a guilty on me
Im shooting benmage the fakeclaiming scumbag"

[mykonian]

Its not entirely unnecessary. Scum or not, Tammy apparently has a shot left.

That would be a gunsmith type role. I dont think Benmage would say cop to mean GS. Name claim.

yup, that one was already covered. He's no gunsmith and he's pretty sure he's not insane. He's going all in there. Either he's fakeclaiming scum or he's a town and you are scum here tammy. There is no escape.

If you are a SK, there is another way to die then by a lynchmob

Make my day.

[AngryPidgeon]

^ That.

@Benmage: Is there anyway you have a false positive

[Tammy]

Hmm...interesting Thad was just viewing this forum and posted elsewhere.

[mykonian]

he went to the gym, and he's only named a framer as a possibility. I can't think of anything else either, seen what he has said till now.

And a frame is indeed unlikely in a game this large.

[Tammy]

AP - You said you didn't like his reaction to you suggesting he could be scum with Melmond. Has that changed now that Melmond came back town?

Mykonian - If you mean me shooting myself I won't do that. Not going to waste a shot on myself when I can take out scum with it.

[AngryPidgeon]

I mean a successful frame (quick math assume scum team of 6, 19 alive, 5 scum left). 14 people to frame. So theoretically there was a 1/14 chance of her being framed * probability of there being a framer in the game. So not horribly likely.

Also, I'm not sure why someone would frame Tammy if not many people (only really Benmage IIRC) thought she was scum.

Tammy, if you claimed anything other than Dayvig then I don't see it. Is your flavor really that incredibly obvscum? Inb4 Fenrir Greyback, Serial Killer.

P-edit: Not really. I've only ever seen town get mad at the accuser or say "don't care" and vote the person anyways. I've seen scum blatantly QQ about me linking them to townies, so the Mel flip doesn't really change my thoughts on that.

[mykonian]

AP - You said you didn't like his reaction to you suggesting he could be scum with Melmond. Has that changed now that Melmond came back town?

Mykonian - If you mean me shooting myself I won't do that. Not going to waste a shot on myself when I can take out scum with it.

If you are a SK it's the best way to go. If you are town we don't have to have this whole discussion, as you obviously believe benmage must be lying

[Tammy]

Why is Thad ignoring my question. Does he think I'm not serious. I'm feeling Trigger Happy Jack here.