Well, to be fair, she was put in a position where she had to shoot or die. She wasn't given 1/2 a day phase to have Town direct her shot. So, to my estimation, she took a good shot [that COULD have been directed at Ben] but it hit Town. Thus, she was able to at least verify that she CAN kill during the day and that she IS willing to play ball.
Also, here's a quote for those of you who don't remember Tammy agreeing to allow Town to direct her shot:
In post 1575, Tammy wrote:I never said I wouldn't deign to test it. I am actually considering it regardless; it's just a silly question to ask me. If I'm the dayvig - yes, of course I'd do anything to help town because I win with town regardless. If I'm the SK - yes, of course I'd do it.
Either way, I have to say yes.
I don't agree with this. It's an issue today because it just came up and we need to come to a consensus on how to deal with it. If we can get resolution on it today, we can carry on without this as a distraction. Would this be more agreeable to those of you opposed to a Tammy lynch if we were to come up with a situation where Tammy *IS* the lynch? Obviously, we lynch her if she goes rogue so that's one scenario. The other would be if we had X number of Town deaths with no scum deaths or something like that? Something that would motivate her to keep shooting scum, essentially.
And I think we are in agreement on this regarding the PGO claim as well, right? Which is why I think that is a reasonable substitute lynch for today. When we have more info tomorrow and we have a plan in place, we have half a day to determine a Day Kill - see the flip - then adjust accordingly.
In post 1892, Tammy wrote:For anyone spreading the mutifaction BS and that I'm part of some team. Take a deep breath and ask yourselves why benmage is still alive? Think about it.
This is a good point. If we have multiscum, Tammy would have shot Ben anyway. Scum for a cop? Easy swap.