In post 2403, AngryPidgeon wrote:Fun fact: Tammy was scum.
Incorrect. Tammy was NOT scum. Tammy was 3rd party. There *IS* a difference. Scum wouldn't target themselves [barring multiball] whereas 3rd party HAS to target scum to win. Therefore, 3rd party has as much information as Town and is almost equally committed to finding scum - effectively making them more like Town than Scum. So your argument that Zab is scum because Tammy was "scum" is not only baseless but flat out wrong.
I'll just assume your super mature posted image on this topic is equally well thought out:
In post 2406, Acosmist wrote:OK, then I won't respond to your semantic argument.
So you have no rational response for explaining why you said "I am PGO" "Don't call me PGO" "Thanks for verifying I am PGO?" That's cool. You understand why this isn't a semantic argument, right? And you understand that being squirrely about your claim like this makes you less likely to be Town, right?
In post 2407, MagnaofIllusion wrote:You could always just, you know, conventionally scum-hunt. Like for example – do you think every single person on the Day 1 mislynch was Town?
Was there some portion of this post from early in the day that was unclear or confusing?
In post 2341, Yates wrote:I don't think being right or wrong about Tammy flipping SK is an alignment tell nor do I think scum were all on or off of a certain wagon. If anything, with the division being the way it was, I would expect roughly half the team to be on and half to be off in order to avoid guilt by wagon analysis.
In post 2411, Acosmist wrote:I'm also not seeing how Yates can avoid the DBZ logic of badplayYates = scumYates.
What exactly has been "bad play?" I understand you not being down for being the lynch target yesterday - self preservation and all. Outside of that, you haven't got a leg to stand on. My only "bad play" was not being able to rally enough support for an Acosmist lynch late in the day. And, to be frank, that is just as easily symptomatic of the activity level of certain people in this game coupled with replacements.
Maybe I'm just cranky today but all three of you are pissing me off and posting like you have never played this game before.
PE: Okay, I do agree that 1v1 is stupid and this thread needs to die.