Mini 1400(!): Bubble Tape Mafia - It's Over!

[Jake from State Farm]

in my 2nd newbie game it was a day 3 cop claim with 5 people left. we'd lynched mafia roleblocker and doctor was NK'd, and in that setup (F11 I think) that meant there HAD to be a cop. i started day 3 asking for the cop. he duly claimed and was believed, since in that setup there could only be 1. hence in that scenario CC was the right thing to ask for, to narrow down from 5 people to only 2, with 2 lynches.

sure its wrong in this scenario, but I'm just throwing stuff out there, I can't think of every pro and con, i'm hoping other people can help out. but if its not even a valid subject for discussion, thats OK too.

that's exactly right, it's wrong in THIS scenario for multiple reasons.

1. if you were telling the truth who would CC you? Scum? No they wouldn't
2. another cop? - highly unlikely
3. a townie? sorry this isn't epic mafia

[Cybertronix]

I don't buy the cop claim for reasons already stated. Also his explanation doesn't seem genuine, and forced. The whole "laughably" thing is ridiculous too.

I believe Dave is L-2 right now if I counted correctly.

[kushm4sta]

@Jake
I'm a little bit confused about your position on Dave atm. You say you don't want to lynch a claimed PR on d1. Yet you can't stfu about how wrong his claim was.

Do you still want to go by your policy and lynch someone else?
Also what is the benefit to delaying it? Whatever checks he claims tomorrow are not going to be reliable.

[Jake from State Farm]

personally i like my policy so I will stick with it.


Dave, i was looking at your paraphrase of your role pm, your role PM says you are aligned with the town is that pretty close to how it is worded in your role pm, is it worded differently, or did you just add that in there?

[kushm4sta]

@jake If you like your policy then who do you want to lynch?

[Jake from State Farm]

Thor

[AngryPidgeon]

lol. I guess Id be down for thorn or Kthxscum. Still prefer this.

[kushm4sta]

AP, Kush and Dave looking like scum at the moment.

Gratz bro you are now number 1 lurker.

I thought you liked to be active what happened?

Are you planning on acting like this all game?

[Dave168]

Also what is the benefit to delaying it? Whatever checks he claims tomorrow are not going to be reliable.

They will be reliable when I flip cop, town side at some point probably quite early in the game.

Dave, i was looking at your paraphrase of your role pm, your role PM says you are aligned with the town is that pretty close to how it is worded in your role pm, is it worded differently, or did you just add that in there?

erm I don't want to get mod killed and am pretty sure that I can't directly quote from PM. However, the words "town" "aligned" and "cop" are right there in close enough proximity to leave me in little doubt that I am on the majority side here.

[Dunhamganger]

Vote Count #4

Dave168

: 6 (Cybertronix, Thor665, AngryPidgeon, Kthxbye, k4shmasta, zipperflesh)

Cybertronix:

1 (d3x)

kushm4sta:

1 (MaverickMaestro)

MaverickMaestro:

1 (DoubleJD)

Not Voting:

4 (Leonshade, qwints, Dave168, Jake from State Farm))

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Still searching for replacements. Hang tight.

Dave168 is L-1

.

That vote.count is wrong. My vote isn't on cyber.

Right you are.

[Jake from State Farm]

@jake If you like your policy then who do you want to lynch?

Thor

yeah you can't quote, wasn't trying to get you to do that just was trying to see if you added those for emphasis or if you changed the order around

[Jake from State Farm]

lol why did I quote me saying thor?

[kushm4sta]

That vote.count is wrong. My vote isn't on cyber.

[Dunhamganger]

qwints replaces Devourer359 effective immediately.

[qwints]

/confirm.

Dave is scum.

VOTE: Dave168

[AngryPidgeon]

Was that the lolziest troll hammer ever? Hi qwints. Lets beast this shit up like futurama mafia.

But seriously. Dave was obviously scum >.>

Kthxbye should go next.

[AngryPidgeon]

Also qwints is practically conf-town. Just saying. Regardless of the flip. (but its a scum flip)

[kushm4sta]

That wasn't a hammer. also i agree with Jakes policy i don't want to lynch him today.

[AngryPidgeon]

Dave168 is L-1.

/confirm.

Dave is scum.

VOTE: Dave168

[AngryPidgeon]

You were saying?

[Dunhamganger]

Vote Count #5

Dave168

: 7 (Cybertronix, Thor665, AngryPidgeon, Kthxbye, k4shmasta, zipperflesh, qwints)

Cybertronix:

1 (d3x)

kushm4sta:

1 (MaverickMaestro)

MaverickMaestro:

1 (DoubleJD)

Not Voting:

3 (Leonshade, Dave168, Jake from State Farm)

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch. What a coincidence.

Dave168,

Town Cop

, lynched Day 1

.

Night will extend until I find the remaining 2 replacements.

[Dunhamganger]

A friendly reminder:

1. Voting:

Votes

and unvotes must be in bold to be counted

. (Ex:

Vote: Dunhamganger

.) You do not have to unvote between votes for the next vote to be counted. You may

unvote

at any time and need not specify who you were voting for.

[Dunhamganger]

mastin2 and Rondar replace Leonshade and DoubleJD, respectively, and effective immediately.

Night deadline is 72 hours from this post, or 6:00 PM CST on 12/10/12

.

[Dunhamganger]

You wake up and hey, look, a dead body.

Rondar,

Vanilla Townie

, was killed Night 1.

With 11 alive it takes 6 to lynch.

Deadline is 12:00 PM CST on 12/30/12.

[AngryPidgeon]

VOTE: Jake from State farm

Your stance on "Ya Dave is scum, but lets not lynch him today" whilst not actively trying to rally support for a wagon you did care about is odd.

And accusing me of buddying you after one post really didn't make sense, context and all given.