Going to start off with the easy ones first, if there's anything you guys want to comment on or help out here feel free.
Baby Spice's Interactions With Other Slots Part One (Johhog):
Baby Spice's vote on Johhog in
#108 and continued criticism of his "ignoring" the salient parts of Mehdi's posts (
#184) point against him being on her team. I also think the back and forth Johhog has with Baby Spice starting at
#219 where he criticizes Baby's defense of Mehdi, Baby calling Johhog's vote "terribad" and the worst on the Mehdi wagon in
#275, and the later cross voting early D2 (
#548/
#549 - especially the latter's attached reasoning) point very very heavily against them being partners. Overall, extremely confident in Johhog being town here, if not based on individual play alone, then certainly based off his interactions with Baby Spice.
Baby Spice's Interactions With Other Slots Part Two (Arthur):
#176 where Arthur initially scumreads Baby Spice is a minor thing that I think he could plausibly fake as scum, but the rest of his interactions with Baby surely rule him out. For example, Baby spends a good portion of her time continuously criticizing Arthur's "lack of reasoning" for pushing the Mehdi wagon (starting at
#275 - "Ser Arthur. No reason given, no reason aparent..."). Back and forth with Baby Spice about the defense of Mehdi, especially with
#354's language and Arthur continuing to push for Baby's lynch later on in
#526, is another thing that points against them being a team. While Baby Spice never really commits a vote here,
#601, her mini-case surrounding Arthur's votes would just be really fucking weird as distancing. Another player that's pretty much cleared via interactions with Baby (and frankly, via his own individual play).
Baby Spice's Interactions With Other Slots Part Three (Tammy):
Doing this one anyway in case I'm wrong about rofl's crumbing and as a precaution against Gunsmith-immune Godfather or Mafia Doctor. Very little interaction early on but Baby Spice's criticism of Tammy's Mehdi vote/Johhog townread in
#275 points against them being partners given the exaggerated, drama-building language she uses (e.g., "I find it strange that..." / "Then she takes the cake for complaining about Medhi daring to scum hunt.") as well as Tammy criticizing her "rather flaccid rundown" of the Mehdi wagon in
#394/the criticism that Baby is willfully misrepresenting Johhog's vote and reasoning. There's a lot of genuine frustration between the two of them, starting with Baby's
#534 that I think doesn't really work as distancing. Less confident in this one than I am with the other two since they both just kinda drop the issues they have with each other, but I think what I've pointed out here (and based off what I know of Tammy's meta she doesn't get frustrated like this with her partners as scum), the possible roflcopter crumb, and her own individual play being really town all work to rule her out as scum.
I'll put up the rest later.
P-Edit: Tammy, I need to re-assess too, I feel like I've been sucking this game and this scum flip just lit a fire under my ass. But honestly, I think the certainty with which roflcopter expresses that you're town in that post makes it far more likely he checked you than guiltied MoI...if he had done the latter, I don't think he'd have ever switched off MoI and probably would have claimed considering how much of a strong player MoI is.
More P-Edit: Yeah, nice job Arthur...well, I did have her as a non-townread. Kinda wish I hadn't second guessed.
