Mini 1401 - Game over!

[Gorgon]

I'm fine with the MC and fine with w/e proposed order, just tell me when it's my turn.

So your turn now, then.

[Slandaar]

Massclaim seems fine though SK should have set the order and should claim last.

But anyways I am happy claiming after Dex so will wait on him.

[roflcopter]

final jeopardy music playing in my head

[roflcopter]

doo doo doo doo doo doo doo, doo doo doo doo DOO doodoodoodoo

[d3x]

was out all day... i'm vt

[Slandaar]

vt

[Kthxbye]

TheConman17

-

Mafia 1xBulletProof Goon

Huntress

-

Town Mason

havingfitz

- Vanilla Townie

qwints

- Mafia Goon

Malakittens

-

Town Mason

rofl:-------------- VT
SiN:-------------- VT
d3x:------------- VT
Slandaar:------- VT
Gorgon:--------- ??
NS:--------------- ??
SK:--------------- ??
Kthx:------------- ??

Tis what we have so far if I'm not mistaken. I'll speculate on PR's after we all claim.

[Kthxbye]

SK can claim last if she'd like. I have to say I'm disappointed that nobody claimed Vig....Could I be wrong about there being a Vig??

[SaintKerrigan]

Gorgon already claimed vanilla.

P. Edit: I don't particularly care when I claim, honestly.

[Kthxbye]

go now then since you're online

[roflcopter]

SK can claim last if she'd like. I have to say I'm disappointed that nobody claimed Vig....Could I be wrong about there being a Vig??

i totally tried to explain right when this day started why an sk made more sense than a vig

[SaintKerrigan]

VT

NS, go.

[Kthxbye]

I know, but with the N1 kill and no N2 kill....

[Kthxbye]

TheConman17

-

Mafia 1xBulletProof Goon

Huntress

-

Town Mason

havingfitz

- Vanilla Townie

qwints

- Mafia Goon

Malakittens

-

Town Mason

rofl:-------------- VT
SiN:-------------- VT
d3x:------------- VT
Slandaar:------- VT
Gorgon:--------- VT
NS:--------------- ??
SK:--------------- VT
Kthx:------------- ??

Tis what we have so far if I'm not mistaken. I'll speculate on PR's after we all claim.

Updated

[SaintKerrigan]

Unless kthnx would rather claim now, but I kind of want NS to claim second to last since he's softclaimed power role.

[Kthxbye]

^that

[roflcopter]

I know, but with the N1 kill and no N2 kill....

let me repeat my explanation for why that makes this an sk not a vig...

1xbulletproof goon does not exist to counter a 1-shot vig
sk would want to shoot conftown mala just as much as scumzies (meaning she probably ate two bullets)

[Kthxbye]

Bah, just read through NS's ISO and I totally believe him to be a cop. No way he's scum with his postings on Conman. I'll update the list with what he's prolly gonna claim and what I believe him to be so that we can all move on and discuss.

[Kthxbye]

TheConman17

-

Mafia 1xBulletProof Goon

Huntress

-

Town Mason

havingfitz

- Vanilla Townie

qwints

- Mafia Goon

Malakittens

-

Town Mason

rofl:-------------- VT
SiN:-------------- VT
d3x:------------- VT
Slandaar:------- VT
Gorgon:--------- VT
NS:---------------

Cop

SK:--------------- VT
Kthx:-------------

Odd Night Vig

Tis what we have so far if I'm not mistaken. I'll speculate on PR's after we all claim.

Updated

Final

[Gorgon]

I know, but with the N1 kill and no N2 kill....

Is that all you had to go on? I thought that given how sure you seemed to be that there was no SK and the way you completely overrode all the SK speculation you had something more solid. Your statement that there was no SK read to me like "Don't bother with these speculations, I

know

there is no SK."

[SaintKerrigan]

Well, it should be pretty obvious why, now.

Who'd you kill N1, kthnx, and why?

[Gorgon]

OK it took me way to long to write that previous post so now it's pretty irrelevant since Kthx has claimed vig. It seems we're in a pretty solid position then. I don't think that Kthx would dare claim a vig who can still kill as scum since it puts him directly in the line of fire of mafia if he is an SK and a possible SK if he is mafia. Plus all the him looking very town anyway.

[SaintKerrigan]

This is totally wild setup speculation on my part, but 1xBP goon seems overpowered to counter an odd-night vig. What if there's also an even-night serial killer?

[Kthxbye]

So, as it stands, we 1 Cop, 1 limited Vig, and 2 Masons (4 PR). Scum have 1 limited scum role, 1 regular goon, and 1 unknown scum (1 PR known)

My limited PR and Con's limited PR kinda cancel each other out leaving 3 town PR's with no more scum PR's? Nope.

I believe the last scum (assuming 3) MUST have a PR. The likely possibilities are God Father or Role Blocker imo. We'll know which soon as NS tells us if he got a result last night. No result = RB, result = GF. I honestly hope he got no result last night because I'd like to cross SK off the list of suspects.

Now, I've been away awhile, so I don't know if it's out of the question for scum to have a 4-man team or not. Town does seem heavy on the PR's tbh. Thoughts?

So, for lynchable suspects my list goes like this:

Scummy

Sin
Gorgon
d3x
Slandaar
rofl
SK

Townie

Will have to re-read and things could change if NS did get a result last night.


p.edit: I killed Huntress N1. She seemed so scummy. The only bad call I've made this game IMO

[SaintKerrigan]

Actually it's prolly more likely that there's a weak scumteam. Ignore me, I'm being crazy.

P. Edit: Not that crazy, kthnx. I thought she looked pretty scummy, too. (Ironic, my two strongest scumreads were on the masons. )