^^Did I come in at an awkward time?
It
really
seems like you could use a fresh set of eyes.
xtopher isn't the best lynch today. You've been tunneling him all game ever since he argued that he didn't want to out his reads at the beginning of d1. What part of that is scum motivated instead of VI? I'm unconvinced of him being scum, and your push at this point is frustrated and emotional, rather than logical and based on evidence.
Siv, on the other hand is scum. His reads have been changing wildly with the town, he likes to hop onto the biggest bandwagon, and he justifies his behavior with outbursts and and his terrible signature that is supposed to "clear" him. His question of "who is my buddy" is horrible and reeks of an attempt to clear himself just because I'd still need to figure that out after Siv flips scum. (and other players pointed out how he is also trying to just throw us back into a state of confusion)
@Moz I noticed that most of your "reads" are based on the
emotions
of the players, rather than the actual
content
of what they are producing. Why is Siv being frustrated a towntell? Scum in his situation would
also
be frustrated and would produce frustrated posts. Also, why do you agree with my argument that xtopher is town just because xtopher is relaxed? Which one is the towntell? Relaxation or frustration?
I don't think that the emotional state of the player indicates alignment--especially in the case of Umbrage who is frustrated as all hell right now.
Nacho
could
be scum but I don't even want to deal with that line of thought until after Siv is lynched.
