Street Racers: New York (Game over!)

[Edosurist]

I don't like the idea of lynching a PR D1, no matter how scummy he seems.

Llama is a bad vote, so AJ's still the best.

[njoseph]

In case you missed it, there now is a deadline. Tick TOCK

[StrangerCoug]

VOTE COUNT

Aj The Epic (4): BirdAndBeast, Albus Dumbledore, Edosurist, Baby Spice
BirdAndBeast (1): Aj The Epic
killerjester (2): curiouskarmadog, Jal
LlamaFluff (4): Bumi, PeregrineV, njoseph, Boniface, Ztife
Skyhook (1): JacobSavage
The Mini-Librarian (1): UVApe
Ztife (7): Nachomamma8, LlamaFluff, killerjester, The Mini-Librarian, Skyhook, thezmon221, Darthe
Not voting (3): ArcAngel9, jmj3000, Zdenek

With

24

alive, it takes

13

players to lynch.

Day 1 ends in (expired on 2013-01-26 13:58:22).

[thezmon221]

After Ztife's latest post, I think I'm going to settle on my vote. I do love how you changed the story, though:

I claimed my car and character, and

a first aid kit/toolbox (honestly, in my head its the same thing, and both exist btw)

and everything else is pretty self explainatory. Was it neccessary to claim my first aid kit/toolbox to begin with? Does a vig usually claims that he holds a gun? My fast cars making temporary ambulances is a paraphrase from my role pm, I just claimed it as it is. Do you think I would wanna raise suspicion and use such a doubtful car claim if I was fake claiming? Also who are you to argue that my car is slow?

Didn't you say it was a first aid toolbox? Because here you said it's a first aid kit OR a toolbox. At least, that's how I see it.

What's the difference?

First aid kit OR toolbox implies two different things, and as LF said, toolbox is more forced car-like.

[Albus Dumbledore]

OOoh lovely Albus. Any particular reason or...

This very post, for starters.

Unvote; Vote: JacobSavage

[Zdenek]

Through 40 Pages:

Baby Spice is possible scum. Her play has been very cautious and unmemorable.

If njoe is scum, I don't think that he's scum with sixx.

I wonder what happened to Nacho's sixx is scum implies Darthe is scum theory?

Bumi's self-vote and his asking to be lynched is incomprehensible.

ArcAngel ignoring Nacho's case on Sixx in 864 is bad.

Jeck's response to BirdAndBeast in 876 is really odd. His insulting follow up post when he was called out on this was unwarranted.

Sly-sly continuing to attack the Sixx wagon after Nacho gave his case, but not commenting on it is bad and then he vanished as Sixx was run up.

[JacobSavage]

OOoh lovely Albus. Any particular reason or...

This very post, for starters.

Unvote; Vote: JacobSavage

[JacobSavage]

Also we are now offically the longest D1 on site.

[njoseph]

Also we are now offically the longest D1 on site.

At least people wouldn't be pulling their hair out in bouts of impatience for nothing.

[JacobSavage]

Also we are now offically the longest D1 on site.

At least people wouldn't be pulling their hair out in bouts of impatience for nothing.

Exactly its all worth it in the end
But Seriously Night-times are boring so I'm happy.

[thezmon221]

OOoh lovely Albus. Any particular reason or...

This very post, for starters.

Unvote; Vote: JacobSavage

I'd like to hear a summation of why you think he's scum too.Nothing too fancy, just maybe a few sentences and maybe some quotes. Not a fan of this post (yours, not JS's).

[ArcAngel9]

Through 40 Pages:

Baby Spice is possible scum. Her play has been very cautious and unmemorable.

If njoe is scum, I don't think that he's scum with sixx.

I wonder what happened to Nacho's sixx is scum implies Darthe is scum theory?

Bumi's self-vote and his asking to be lynched is incomprehensible.

ArcAngel ignoring Nacho's case on Sixx in 864 is bad.

Jeck's response to BirdAndBeast in 876 is really odd. His insulting follow up post when he was called out on this was unwarranted.

Sly-sly continuing to attack the Sixx wagon after Nacho gave his case, but not commenting on it is bad and then he vanished as Sixx was run up.

so on who you going to put your vote?

[Zdenek]

I'm going to read first.

Why are you asking me this, when you're not voting?

[LlamaFluff]

OOoh lovely Albus. Any particular reason or...

This very post, for starters.

Unvote; Vote: JacobSavage

I'd like to hear a summation of why you think he's scum too.Nothing too fancy, just maybe a few sentences and maybe some quotes. Not a fan of this post (yours, not JS's).

Actually AD is completely right. JS is really scummy and that post is something alone I wouldnt have much of an issue voting him for. If Ztife wasnt confirmed scum already I actually might be voting him for it.

[thezmon221]

OOoh lovely Albus. Any particular reason or...

This very post, for starters.

Unvote; Vote: JacobSavage

I'd like to hear a summation of why you think he's scum too.Nothing too fancy, just maybe a few sentences and maybe some quotes. Not a fan of this post (yours, not JS's).

Actually AD is completely right. JS is really scummy and that post is something alone I wouldnt have much of an issue voting him for. If Ztife wasnt confirmed scum already I actually might be voting him for it.

It wasn't a question of whether I thought he was scummy or not, but rather if AD had the right intentions for voting JS. I too think he's scummy, but I'd like to hear AD's case, if you understand what I'm getting at here...

[njoseph]

Of course, Ztife's lynch can be supported in greater numbers with more alacrity if Ztife's not protecting the right individual(s) becomes an assumption.

[LlamaFluff]

Of course, Ztife's lynch can be supported in greater numbers with more alacrity if Ztife's not protecting the right individual(s) becomes an assumption.

So you can acurately tell if he was blocked, was the one who stopped a kill, etc?

Im pretty sure you cant. There is zero way ztife is going to make it without being lynched a few days, and when he is almost confirmed scum, letting scum who could have a dangerous PR live just sounds like a bad thing.

Still waiting to hear why a med-toolbox saves against cops, or how he protect players

[njoseph]

UNVOTE

VOTE: Ztife

I don't think this doc's services would be too valuable.

[Zdenek]

Through page 60

SlySly attacks the Ztife wagon, calling it shaky at best, but agrees with Nacho's rationale for his vote, and expresses a willingness to hammer. His analysis of how the wagon grew is ridiculous because he is only considering the posts containing people's votes and is ignoring the other posts where people commented on the people they are voting.

That said, I'm starting to have very strong doubts about SlySly being scum, partly due to 1174 and partly due to the fact that his thoughts on AA seem genuine: has a scum read on her with legit points, argues that she could be derp-scum but asks her to replace out if town, which could be very counterproductive if he was scum, since she was already being defended by B&B. I've also played with him once before and read him as scum in that game, where he was town, and his play feels very much the same here.

Thez possibly defending Sixx by saying that he'd never seen a mafia jail keeper is a fine point.

Jal is looking townish.

PV looks townish.

CKD looks scummy, but I think I usually read him as scum, so I'll have to put some thought into that one.

Edosurist could easily be scum. Generally gut, but 1470 seals it.

[njoseph]

Even if Ztife is a town doc, which is the risk, that risk is not too much of a risk.

[njoseph]

I should say not too DANGEROUS of a risk.

[thezmon221]

Even if Ztife is a town doc, which is the risk, that risk is not too much of a risk.

You see, the point is, if either scum team really has any sense, then Ztife is useless either way. If he's scum doc, there's a chance the other scum will kill him and he wouldn't protect targets from his scum, so that way is scum.

However, if he's town, he's as good as dead from either scum team, or from us suspecting him of being mafia for living a few days later. Or simply, someone will keep blocking him; that is assuming that the NYPD faction even has another RB role (which is unlikely) and assuming that the second faction has an RB role (which is not out of the question, especially since Sixx was a JK).

So, in short, Ztife dying at this point, I've come to think, is little-to-no risk.

[Aj The Epic]

Edosurist could easily be scum. Generally gut, but 1470 seals it.

What post? 1470 is by Njoseph.

[PeregrineV]

Behind on the thread but will get pc access tonight.

[Zdenek]

Edosurist could easily be scum. Generally gut, but 1470 seals it.

What post? 1470 is by Njoseph.

sorry 1471