MeMeMeet Mafia (Game Over!)

[ibaesha]

My vote is still on Quag where I like it. I don't think people are random voting. They're just putting their votes back where they were before the crash.

[Atticus]

I'm sorry, that wasn't my point.

What I was trying to say was: Why aren't we doing anything new? For goodness sake, the crash barely affected THIS game. You can be thankful for that, and you can be ponderous about that.

Sure, a way to win this game is by having the most points, but why can't we be trying to make the town win as well? And again, sure, voting for who you think is scum is in a way, trying to help, but can we make a lynch without an agreement?

No!

Dirge had a good point, I didn't even see it then! We're not concentrating on the

game

, we're concentrating on the

games

! If more than one person's going to win this, we're going to have to do more about his game.

[ibaesha]

So who do you think is scum, Atticus? Complaining about the state of the game is all fine and good, but if you want to do more, do more.

Do you agree or disagree with the suspicions regarding Quagmire?
Do you agree or disagree with the suspicions regarding Pooky?
Do you have any suspicions of your own that aren't either of these people?

[Atticus]

Oh, good point.

I really haven't done much.

Vote: Dirge

And I beleive that Quagmire is suspicious, but I feel not the need to vote for him

I think it's weird Pooky so easily spotted Fishbulb, but maybe he's a cop, maybe he's scumI don't know, I just don't think he's the latter right now.

[Dirge]

Well I have a thought about this game and I think that there is good reason to be suspicious of Pooky.

[Atticus]

Convince us?

[olio]

Atticus, why are you voting Dirge? All that rambling about people not pondering enough and you don't even give reason for your vote.

[mith]

Game 8: 52 Card Pickup - Results

Anonymities: 2 (Qc, Kc)
Atticus: 8 (2d, 3d, 4d, 5d, 6d, 8d, 9d, Td)
Dirge: 0
Fritzler: 10 (6s, 7s, 8s, 9h, Th, Jd, Qd, 6c, 7c, 8c)
ibaesha: 7 (4h, 5h, 6h, 7h, 8h, Qh, Kh)
Mr_Gnome_It_All: 2 (As, Ts)
MrBuddyLee: 1 (Ah)
olio: 8 (5s, Js, Qs, Jh, Ad, Ac, 9c, Jc)
PookyTheMagicalBear: 14 (2s, 3s, 4s, 9s, Ks, 2h, 3h, 7d, Kd, 2c, 3c, 4c, 5c, Tc)
Quagmire: 0

MeMeMeet Points:

PookyTheMagicalBear: 13
Fritzler: 12
Atticus, olio: 10
ibaesha: 9
Anonymities, Mr_Gnome_It_All: 7
MrBuddyLee: 6
Dirge, Quagmire: 0

Total:

Atticus: 58
Fishbulb: 51
MrBuddyLee: 49
PookyTheMagicalBear: 49
Fritzler: 46
Mr_Gnome_It_All: 40
Quagmire: 30
Dirge: 29
kristocker: 29
Anonymities: 23
Mastermind of Sin: 18
Thesp: 16
mlaker: 10
Yoko Kurama: 10
MeMe: 8
Yosarian2: 8
Fletcher: 2
olio: 3
ibaesha: -3

[mith]

Vote Count:

Current Boss - Anonymities

Quagmire: CLS (Fritzler, ibaesha, olio)
PookyTheMagicalBear: DS (Dirge, Quagmire)
Dirge: C (Atticus)

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

My top suspicion for today and who I think should be lynched after some careful consideration is Atticus.


Why? I've just gone over all of his posts from day 1 forward, 94 posts and all of them seem to be very flimsy, he not only made a major position change without explaining why, but also voted for Fish when the primary evidence against fish that I had presented was something that he himself was guilty of.

His contribution to the game in terms of actively seeking out scum has been negligible and he seems eager to bandwagon.

On day 2 when I nearly got lynchified by a wagon containing MeMe/FB, both scum, Atticus was all too happy to hope on and encourage people to pile votes on in order to get me lynched.

In his vote against me in this post

Reply with quote
Hmmm, I just don't think it makes sense to lynch Thesp, with his claim, I think he just makes horribly exploitable mistakes.

Buuut..... I see good enough reason to vote Pooky.

Vote: Pooky
_________________

he doesn't actually mention what good reason he was voting me on, he's yet to come up with a single good reason in fact his following posts make absolutely zero sense.

Then in the flip of an eye when I made my move on Fishbulb and wagonned him for reasons that Atticus is guilty of as well, Atticus was all too happy to flip sides and suddenly help me lynch Fishbulb, now he's been buddying up to me ever since, if there's one thing I know it's that i have a real big soft spot for people who buddy up to me *huggles ibby* and I think Atticus was trying to take advantage of that.

Oh and this added thing is just gravy on top btw,

Reply with quote
Er, Spork, mlaker, this is what the green cards went, (as far as I can remember from a certain game) yeah, okay.

There were like four power roles in this one gamewe played, okay? Roleblocker, cop, doc, and vig. One of these was taken out and replaced with a green card, which would be a lessened version of that. But this person would know nothing!

Here are what I think happens.

The vig can only kill towns ( I know this because that was the one in the game at MeMeMeet)

The doc can only protect scum.

The cop.... insane maybe? I can't think of what this handicap would be.

The roleblocker can only block pro-town roles.

If this person chose to do something they could not, they would get no result, nada, say if a vig tried to kill a scum, he would just get a shake of the head. But I assume then maybe he'd get a "no" in a pm or perhaps nothing on the site, I don't know.

That's what he said about the green card, doesn't sound like something a green card townie would say, that's assuming green cards are actually townies which is something I'd expect Fishbulb to have known because it'd be ludicriously stupid to make a remark like that if he was completely wrong cuz he'd easily be caught out if a single vanilla townie said, "wait im not a green card! die!"

Also he replied to Thesp that he didn't have an activated ability.

No activated ability and not vanilla town? I think BS.

vote Atticus

I don't think Dirge/Quag are scum because scum don't go after hard to lynch targets, scum tend to go after easy fish, or try to buddy up to people, scum generally aren't so unhelpful as to pretty much refuse to post any logic.

[MrBuddyLee]

vote: Quag

[Dirge]

Convince us?

I posted and then quoted my suspicions already. My suspicions are sound and better than Pooky's retread of "Fish's" suspicion applied to you. If we let him he'll be able to get everyone lynched for the same reason.

[olio]

Waiting for Atticus to answer my question and Pooky's accusations.

[mith]

Game 5: Betrayal at House on a Hill - Attacks

(Repost)

Atticus attacks Anonymities with a Hadouken Fireball. (Anonymities gains one Might point.)

olio attacks PookyTheMagicalBear with Tin Whistle. (PookyTheMagicalBear gains one Speed point.)

Mr_Gnome_It_All attacks Dirge with Atticus (picking him up by the ankles and swinging him around). (Dirge loses one Knowledge point.)

Fritzler attacks olio with a pipe. (olio loses one Knowledge point.)

MrBuddyLee attacks Atticus with a flying monkey. (Atticus loses one Speed point.)

PookyTheMagicalBear attacks MrBuddyLee with a spoon. (MrBuddyLee loses one Might point.)

ibaesha attacks Mr_Gnome_It_All with Magic Marker! (No effect.)

The Traitor strikes! (Anonymities gains one Knowledge point.)

[mith]

Vote Count:

Current Boss - Anonymities

Quagmire: CGLS (Fritzler, ibaesha, MrBuddyLee, olio)
PookyTheMagicalBear: DS (Dirge, Quagmire)
Atticus: W (PookyTheMagicalBear)
Dirge: C (Atticus)

Current Character Influence:

Anonymities (G)
Atticus (C)
Dirge (D)
Fritzler (S)
ibaesha (C)
Mr_Gnome_It_All (D)
MrBuddyLee (G)
olio (L)
PookyTheMagicalBear (W)
Quagmire (S)

Mod Note:

Just a reminder... you do all have cards you can play at any time.

[Atticus]

Okay.... While I'm not going to bother answering everything in Pooky's post, let me first make a claim.

I'm a point-whore

. The person I had to get more points than to get an investigation, was Thesp. That was never possible, because I had always topped him in points. This led me to assume that Thesp was pro-town. And with a claim like activted-ability-cop, I figured well, why lynch him?

MeMe was not scum, she was some other form of killer, a zombie. Had I been scum, there is no way I would have known that MeMe was also a fiend. And furthermore, if I had, I would have been pushing to kill her.

That's what he said about the green card, doesn't sound like something a green card townie would say, that's assuming green cards are actually townies which is something I'd expect Fishbulb to have known because it'd be ludicriously stupid to make a remark like that if he was completely wrong cuz he'd easily be caught out if a single vanilla townie said, "wait im not a green card! die!"

Not to try and cop out of answering this, or anything, but what does all this mean? In basic terms.

You also state that I vote Fishbulb based on your reasoning. Reasoning that, for the most part, applies to me. In actuality, a lot of it does. But if I can think properly, why would there be any reason to vote my scumbuddy? As you said yourself, why would I simply want to throw someone under the bus? What is the point? You yourself said that this would damage me, or you, if you would be scum. Unless of course you are scrapping this theory.

You're accusing me of taking advantage and trying to buddy-up to you? You can't possibly say that you're not taking advantage of being the buddy. Right now you're EVERYONE'S buddy. (except for Dirge apparently.) You have sole position over who gets lynched, because everyone can trust good old Pooky, heck, he got us a scum single-handedly,and who's got any better ideas, and well, like he said himself, there's no reason to kill his own partners. And if that's not taking advantage of something by your terms, you better change your book.

I want to point out something to EVERYONE. Going into Night 2, Kris tocker and Fish were the point leaders. Kristocker died that night.

Two days later, Fish is the point leader. He is killed single-handedly by Pooky.

Today, I am the point-leader, and I am about to get killed. I don't give a crap if I'm lynched today for being the point leader. But I do care if Pooky's gonna lynch me. For reasons like this.

[Quagmire]

NICE ONE, Atticus! Now we can finally kill Pooky!

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Wow Quag, I seriously hope there's some post restriction causing you to act stupidly because otherwise I think i've lost all respect for you.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Actually atticus, in my notes I have you down as a zombie because of how eager you were to lynch Fishbulb and your interaction with MeMe prior to that and your eagerness to lynch in the preceding days.

[Atticus]

NICE ONE, Atticus! Now we can finally kill Pooky!

I am not in anyway implying that Pooky is absototalutely scum. I just want to keep those reminders open.

[Quagmire]

NICE ONE, Atticus! Now we can finally kill Pooky!

I am not in anyway implying that Pooky is absototalutely scum. I just want to keep those reminders open.

Oh. Well, I am.

[olio]

Atticus, what was your reason for voting Dirge again?

[Fritzler]

attack quag with an ice cream scoop cuz he doesn't want to share like that snowman in calvin + hobbes

[Atticus]

I'm not entirely sure myself. It could have been to assure myself that I was on the ball, or there could be some reasoning that I've forgotten now.

Sory for answering that so late.

Unvote

[Anonymities]

Actually atticus, in my notes I have you down as a zombie because of how eager you were to lynch Fishbulb and your interaction with MeMe prior to that and your eagerness to lynch in the preceding days.

So who is down for scum in your notes?

I'm holding my cards close because I bet that my theories are wack. And by wack. I mean wack.