I could see him as a recruiter more likely than as the recruited actually, would explain you not being recruited. And I notice he never answered my issue either. The way he claimed cop just seems so off. And not in the same way that Voided's claim was off. Voided sounds like uhhh derp while FT was trying to get the spotlight off of him and just rattled off standard cop results for a game such as a Nwbie game or a normal game, this however is not a normal game and his scum town does not make sense with the setup.
I can't see their being a goon in the set up to be fair (Itll be far too unbalanced) and Voids role is not one you'd think off straight away when you claim.
Basicaly FT is the recruiter, his claim is far too overpowered (I mean we havent exactly got standard roles have we, BG, JOAT and Alarmist seems a better bit together than replacing Cop with any of them)
How is the game imbalanced? The fact we have no idea what is going on and are probably gonna lose this game is more than enough evidence to see the game is anything but imbalanced. Cults in such a small game, with a SK to boot, make for an extremely swingy game. The investigative roles here make perfect sense, as such.
In post 1052, FourTrouble wrote:How is the game imbalanced? The fact we have no idea what is going on and are probably gonna lose this game is more than enough evidence to see the game is anything but imbalanced. Cults in such a small game, with a SK to boot, make for an extremely swingy game. The investigative roles here make perfect sense, as such.
Also, how is that an indicator of non-imba?
(Happy scumday for me, btw)
2011 scummies winner (BTS help) and participant;
coming back to Mafia...slowly. Keep an eye for me as a mod.
Also keep an eye for setup review requests.
If the game is unbalanced, it means one side has much better chances of winning than another side. At the moment, I don't see town having a disproportionately greater chance of winning than the Cult, so the game is balanced.
I'm town. Jacob is obviously cult, though I'm not sure if he's the recruiter or not. I'm thinking the cult recruiter is probably someone who seems very difficult to get a wagon going on, especially since his recruits are gonna do everything they can to keep him from getting lynched. I'd say recruiter is between Mollie/HD/Thor. I think one of them should be our lynch.
And there's another switch in your theories again with no supporting logic.
For someone calling me cult due to poor use of logic I have to say that feels rather scummy to me.
You also failed to address the point that I am arguing about you or Voided = cult other thant o say the town is balanced...and then claim one of the PRs as a theory recruit before deciding he's not for reasons that are unclear but would seem to be 'because he's one of these balanced PRs we have'.
You also failed to address why hyper town Thor is obv. recruit/recruiter because he looks town and the claimed Cop is not recruited, nope, not at all.
Basically my issue is that I don't see why there would be a Cop in this set up especially with those options.
I mean yes I can see more likely recruiters but I still can't see a Cop in this set up.
Why is receiving results in a Town/Scum format suspicious? You guys seemed to believe I was legit Yesterday, why didn't anyone question my results back then?
What the hay? I know what a meatshield is from fantasy books and history, but even after reading your Micro game it makes no sense to me in this context? Could you expand on that more HD, especially since you followed it with agreeing about what I said about the cop claim?
In post 1067, FourTrouble wrote:Why is receiving results in a Town/Scum format suspicious? You guys seemed to believe I was legit Yesterday, why didn't anyone question my results back then?
hd said town/cult not town/scum.
and I believe I did put forth my suspicions but I thought your in-game play was good at the time and it seemed too high risk/reward in a cost benefit assessment.
the thing that gives me the biggest pause is that majiffy would have wanted the cult leader out of the game too and he was pushing for an hd lynch. majiffy has pretty good scumdar. I find it hard to believe that he would willingly leave a cult leader alive he would have been hunting for them pretty hard.
