NY 162: A Week at the Theatres (Game Over)

[MrZepher]

i actually don't have to read anything leading up to now to know that my vote is in the right place

No. Bad. If you had bothered to read you'd know how garbage your vote on Bacde is.
Since then it's just been cheap justification based on largely subjective reasoning.

hmmmm

[roflcopter]

unvote, vote: zepher[/b[

more proof that scum can be caught even without reading the first ten pages

[MrZepher]

OMGUS noted.

[MrZepher]

I was sitting on my vote debating whether or not I like it on Grey more but I think Bacde's opinion has merit.
Which makes this seem like a more aesthetically pleasing spot....

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Roflcopter

inb4 he says he's trying to reaction fish.

[roflcopter]

i never reaction fish, you're just being patently transparent

unvote, vote: zepher

, but for real this time

[wind-up]

I am going to read up.

[Nobody Special]

Thank you, ever so, for informing us.

[wind-up]

Just wanted to avoid replacement.

[wind-up]

Succeeding W/O Really Trying (18/18):

• 1) Konowa
  
  2) TheTrollie
  
  3) ActionDan
  
  4) Go
  5) Nobody Special
  
  6) wind-up
  
  7) Human Destroyer
  
  8) KingdomAces
  
  9) roflcopter
  10) JacobSavage
  11) Kdowns
  12) ZONEACE
  
  13) greygnarl
  
  14) petapan
  
  15) Smashbard
  
  16) MrZepher
  17) Dramonic
  
  18) Bacde
  
  

Hah, I came into this post thinking 'wow, I think I have a lot of townreads, I should see who I'm not townreading and then vote them' but failed to realise that in fact there were just a lot of lurkers. Just over half of the unstruck names there are players with 10 posts or less.

Dramonic and Kdowns have both posted several times on site since their last post here. That's suggestive of avoiding the thread, in my opinion, but it's not necessarily telling of alignment because they're not under any pressure to post at the moment.

I feel like KingdomAces vote on Bacde is either a legitimate attempt at pulling us into proper discussion but it's a silly vote for a silly reason
Or it's a blatant attempt at misdirection to draw people away from the Go/HD thing. Which tells me that the Go/HD thing is not a townvstown argument.

You've specified an 'either X or Y' condition here, can you say which you personally believe? Is it a legitimate attempt at pulling us into proper discussion or a blatant attempt at misdirection?

zoneace still sucks, go vs human destroyer is a boring big-dick ego fight but HD looks much better off it than go

Does ZONEACE suck more or less than he did when you initially voted him? Or is there no change? Did Human Destroyer look better than Go going into the boring big-dick ego fight?


I'm a bit iffy about JacobSavage for while he points out that my claiming early is the "expected thing to do", he doesn't actually give an opinion on my alignment. It seems typical of a scum mindset to attribute doing expected things with town alignment, I find it's generally how scum try to blend in.


I'm striking out a few more players for townreads I've gained through my rereadings... leaving:

4) Go
5) Nobody Special
7) Human Destroyer
10) JacobSavage
11) Kdowns
12) ZONEACE
14) petapan
16) MrZepher
17) Dramonic

[wind-up]

I have that weird, very faint queasy feeling you get when your gut tells you you've incorrectly labelled someone as town, but I think that list of names there is a good place to start lynching.

[MrZepher]

I never specified before which I believed because it was based off of KingdomAces having voted Bacde.
At the time I was inclined to believe it was an attempt at misdirection but KA pointed out that it was an unvote, not a vote, which sort of shit on my idea.

I should have clarified that when I said whoops after KA clarified for me.

[Smashbard]

When it come to Kdowns, this is the second game I've played with him and he basically never posted. He was lynched eventually and was scum. The unfortunate thing about that is that this seems to be his playstyle, or lack-thereof. So I can't in good faith say that for sure he is totally scum this time around too.

I would love nothing more than to start cutting off the dead weight and lynch a few lurkers. But unfortunately that just invites scum to be more active and start controlling the narrative.

[Konowa]

unvote;
Vote: MrZepher

Zepher and Trollie are both scum for their awkward as fuck posts on page one. The most important part of the game is the first few pages because scum have a hard time trying to get into the flow of the game. Awkwardness is a scumtell in RVS. Then continuing through the game –none- of Zepher’s posts have done anything to determine alignment. For example, 171 is a softball question that scum love.

In other news, I got absolutely nothing the first time I read the Go/HD back and forth. I should try that again. Also, someone should shoot Jacob (post 139 is another one of those awkward "HAHA let me chime in" jokes).

[KingdomAces]

Jacob really needs to start contributing. It seems like every time he posts, he never actually gives us anything. The main post that is causing me to think that he's scum instead of just unhelpful is 139. When I made a post like that, it was as they were arguing, and I had already tried once more casually to stop them. Someone also mentioned that posting that gave them a townread on me. When Jacob posted that hours after the argument had ended for the day, literally the only purpose it could possibly serve would be to get some excess townreads from anyone who thought it was town when I did it.
VOTE: JacobSavage

Greygnarl, what did you expect would happen if you intentionally made a bad post? I don't know what you're trying to do, but stop it.

Among other things, Zepher seems to have trouble being able to read. He has misread or missed too many things for someone who has actively criticized other people for not reading. As for what I think of him alignment-wise, I really can't tell. He has posted far more irrelevant things than relevant, but that's not necessarily indicative of scum. I'll keep thinking about this, but right now I'm getting nowhere.

I was going to try to post about more people, but I realize that I have almost nothing to say about anyone, and trying to figure something out is giving me a headache.

[MrZepher]

If ActionDan's reads haven't changed he apparently has a town read on JS which seems weird to me considering the lack of posts.

[Nobody Special]

Smash, I can't recall. Have we ever played together?

Would like an answer, please.

[Smashbard]

I don't think so. I've seen you around, but I can't remember us ever playing together.

[ActionDan]

I don't mind that there's a Zepher wagon, but why are there not more votes on NS?

[Bacde]

I'm still waiting on grey to come in and confirm my suspicions that he was reaction testing

[Nobody Special]

If I do get lynched, look very very hard at ActionDan. He is most assuredly scum.

[Bacde]

If I do get lynched, look very very hard at ActionDan. He is most assuredly scum.

Wasn't I your #1 scumpick?

Why is actiondan more scum than I now?

That is to say, what has ActionDan done that is scummy?

(this isn't a defense I'm considering voting ActionDan just fyi)

[Nobody Special]

Please show me where I said he was more scummy than you. (Hint: I didn't.)

It's more what he hasn't done; he has 8 posts, only one of which discusses me at any length. He's avoiding the thread, and pushing my wagon for no logical, discernible reason.

[Bacde]

you didn't convince me fyi

[TheTrollie]

i rly should have written better notes while i was catching up i forgot why my reads r what they r

[Dr Producer]

Random Fact: Unlike most wine fanatics, ALW collects his farts in wine bottles. He keeps his most aged ones in the back room of his wine cellar, opening up one every several years if he ever needs some inspiration for a brand new hit.

TheTrollie -

1

[L-9]

wind-up
ZONEACE -

1

[L-9]

petapan
Go -

2

[L-8]

kdowns, Human Destroyer
MrZepher -

5

[L-5]

dramonic, TheTrollie, Bacde, roflcopter, Konowa
Bacde -

4

[L-6]

KingdomAces, Nobody Special, ZONEACE, greygnarl
Nobody Special -

1

[L-9]

ActionDan
greygnarl -

1

[L-9]

Smashbard
Smashbard -

1

[L-9]

Go
Roflcopter -

1

[L-9]

MrZepher
JacobSavage -

1

[L-9]

KingdomAces

NOT VOTING:

WITH [18] ALIVE IT TAKES [10] TO LYNCH
DEADLINE:

(expired on 2013-02-14 21:30:00)