NY 161: Overly-Posh Mafia (POSH WIN - NIGHT X)

[TheReverend]

No question IAI is MVP. Town is bad for falling for that crap twice, but that shouldn't take the shine off his performance.

[MattP]

I think the biggest issue for town was the demoralization

Which I was the causer of

I should have just replaced

[UberNinja]

and ya IaI, I did know I was the easiest. I tried my best to argue that.

Seriously though I had you dead to rights.

no actually, he had YOU dead to rights

like I said:

By the way, how did we manage to lynch AD over IaI ffs?

because AD was playing like shit and IAI had his ducks in a row

get with teh program

[I Am Innocent]

Like I said, my goal was to go with the cop, and I think I did a good job of making it believable. Heck even AP didn't vote me D5, and say what you will about most of the town at that pt, he is a solid town player.

You were damn lucky you just so happened to prepare for a cop claim, which would counterract a gunsmith

yeah there was luck involved with that for sure, but he took advantage of the preparation he had already laid

and then he got both you and AD lynched with a ridiculous amount of swagger

therefore he is the scum MVP in my eyes

hiding in plain sight.... you clever mother ****er, IAI

Best part was that I was trying not to leave clues back to me team, so I think I only ever voted two people (Jacob & Mollie) until my two scum investigations D4 & D5...lol

[MattP]

Oh, Mhork, when you're an IC and you're kept alive over non-confirmed players that means scum is keeping you alive because your reads are wrong

[UberNinja]

I think the biggest issue for town was the demoralization

Which I was the causer of

I should have just replaced

yeah, probably

or just stop fakeclaiming as a habit

[UberNinja]

Like I said, my goal was to go with the cop, and I think I did a good job of making it believable. Heck even AP didn't vote me D5, and say what you will about most of the town at that pt, he is a solid town player.

You were damn lucky you just so happened to prepare for a cop claim, which would counterract a gunsmith

yeah there was luck involved with that for sure, but he took advantage of the preparation he had already laid

and then he got both you and AD lynched with a ridiculous amount of swagger

therefore he is the scum MVP in my eyes

hiding in plain sight.... you clever mother ****er, IAI

Best part was that I was trying not to leave clues back to me team, so I think I only ever voted two people (Jacob & Mollie) until my two scum investigations D4 & D5...lol

i noticed that, and i couldn't believe other people didn't.. hahaha

[Vifam]

Lets talk about how I basically pushed every mislynch in this game

[UberNinja]

Oh, Mhork, when you're an IC and you're kept alive over non-confirmed players that means scum is keeping you alive because your reads are wrong

i admit, i laughed pretty hard at this post:

Oh yeah. Gimme a sec for mass claim list.

Majiffy
Aj the Epic
TheReverend
penguin_alien
Vifam
Borkjkork
UberNinja

There.

[I Am Innocent]

and ya IaI, I did know I was the easiest. I tried my best to argue that.

Seriously though I had you dead to rights.

Not gonna lie, I was sweating it a little that day...

[UberNinja]

No question IAI is MVP. Town is bad for falling for that crap twice, but that shouldn't take the shine off his performance.

to be fair, we played a pretty solid day game as well

like vifam said, i think AA was probably the only weak link

[UberNinja]

well, once bork picked up his posting that is

he was struggling about halfway through, and needed a kick in the ass

i'll give it to him though, scum games this long are pretty taxing

[ActionDan]

Like I said, my goal was to go with the cop, and I think I did a good job of making it believable. Heck even AP didn't vote me D5, and say what you will about most of the town at that pt, he is a solid town player.

You were damn lucky you just so happened to prepare for a cop claim, which would counterract a gunsmith

yeah there was luck involved with that for sure, but he took advantage of the preparation he had already laid

and then he got both you and AD lynched with a ridiculous amount of swagger

therefore he is the scum MVP in my eyes

hiding in plain sight.... you clever mother fucker, IAI

Good play to claim a guilty on Matt.

Equally best play to claim a guiltly on me.

But my lynch was accomplished with the help of some of the town being in the 5% bracket

Actually UN I had him dead to rights. Sorry!

[Nero Cain]

Well I also nailed Vifam and Ubernija. Seriously, Town lose when they don't listen to me.

well, also, half the battle as town is to NOT get lynched

when your partner is mastin, that can be ... problematic

I know but town should also NOT mislynch so that speaks volumes about this town.

point conceded

but dude

i didn't feel at all threatened by your slot this game, so that also speaks volumes

no one ever is 'cause no one ever listens to me but if I hadn't been mislynched then I would have keep the heat on you, maybe you'd even need to kill me. and if I was a vig you'd be dead. Thank the town for mislynching me.

[MattP]

or just stop fakeclaiming as a habit

Sometimes it works dandy

But sure everyone can now yell at me for that

If IAI didn't crumb cop it wouldve worked

[Vifam]

Im pretty sure I was on just about every lynch in this game

[ActionDan]

and ya IaI, I did know I was the easiest. I tried my best to argue that.

Seriously though I had you dead to rights.

no actually, he had YOU dead to rights

like I said:

By the way, how did we manage to lynch AD over IaI ffs?

because AD was playing like shit and IAI had his ducks in a row

get with teh program

like my shit play = lurking all of D2 + D3.

[AngryPidgeon]

Ugh it is fucking impossible to lynch Vifam.

[MattP]

Also fakeclaiming is equally likely in my town and scum meta. And by this point it's so common for me it has no meaning. If people want to use that against me, I disagree, I won't be changing that aspect of my game, and people can hate me for it

[mozamis]

No question IAI is MVP. Town is bad for falling for that crap twice, but that shouldn't take the shine off his performance.

He was good, no question. But he really should have got lynched over AD. The rest of the scum team get credit for that as well. But the give away for me (after Mattp flipped town -I was unsure before that, so yeah well played IAI ) was that he didn't really play like a cop. Most (outed) cops I've seen lead from the front, shout about it, beat their chests etc IAI was very quiet for a cop I thought.
Still, props to him obviously.
My list of MVP scum would be: Vifam, IAI, Uber, Bork, AA.

[UberNinja]

Like I said, my goal was to go with the cop, and I think I did a good job of making it believable. Heck even AP didn't vote me D5, and say what you will about most of the town at that pt, he is a solid town player.

You were damn lucky you just so happened to prepare for a cop claim, which would counterract a gunsmith

yeah there was luck involved with that for sure, but he took advantage of the preparation he had already laid

and then he got both you and AD lynched with a ridiculous amount of swagger

therefore he is the scum MVP in my eyes

hiding in plain sight.... you clever mother fucker, IAI

Good play to claim a guilty on Matt.

Equally best play to claim a guiltly on me.

But my lynch was accomplished with the help of some of the town being in the 5% bracket

Actually UN I had him dead to rights. Sorry!

of course you had him dead to rights

usually the townie with a fake guilty on him has a LITTLE bit of confirmation bias, at LEAST

[Vifam]

Ugh it is fucking impossible to lynch Vifam.

What do you mean

[UberNinja]

Well I also nailed Vifam and Ubernija. Seriously, Town lose when they don't listen to me.

well, also, half the battle as town is to NOT get lynched

when your partner is mastin, that can be ... problematic

I know but town should also NOT mislynch so that speaks volumes about this town.

point conceded

but dude

i didn't feel at all threatened by your slot this game, so that also speaks volumes

no one ever is 'cause no one ever listens to me but if I hadn't been mislynched then I would have keep the heat on you, maybe you'd even need to kill me. and if I was a vig you'd be dead. Thank the town for mislynching me.

there's a lot of 'ifs' in that paragraph

we should talk offline, maybe i can teach you a think or two about avoiding being lynched.
it's a pretty valuable skill as both town and scum

[AngryPidgeon]

My list of MVP scum would be: Vifam, IAI, Uber, Bork, AA.

Dude Vifam was hillariously scum all game long and no one would give a shit enough to actually pressure him >.>

[Nero Cain]

I think Matt P should be scum MVP.