Mini 1427 - Slenderman Mafia - Game Over

[Ms Marangal]

I want to lynch Yates

and I was sure that Safety was scum. that's all the motivation I needed to Lynch Safety.

[Yates]

Levy is bleeding truth on his claim, guys. Yates isn't. Why can't we lynch Yates?

Because I'm not the one lying and you are his likely scum buddy?

[Yates]

Why can't we lynch Yates?

Oh yeah... and then there's the fact I will be mod confirmed Town tomorrow. *shrug* It is what it is.

[leviathan93]

Levy is bleeding truth on his claim, guys. Yates isn't. Why can't we lynch Yates?

Because I'm not the one lying and you are his likely scum buddy?

well, he can't BE my scum buddy because i'm not scum to begin with. =P

however, if you say you aren't scum and I'm not scum, then who IS scum?

[Yates]

however, if you say you aren't scum and I'm not scum, then who IS scum?

I already said Mhork and/or Margie assuming you are the Traitor [which *IS* a scum role even if you want to call it "scum-lite"]. I think it's pretty weird that you knew SD was 3rd party if that ends up being the case. Then again, I can't explain your play at all this game so... *shrug*

[leviathan93]

well, in this game the traitor is NOT a scum role. thats not how i have been attempting to play it. and therefore i would be going against my win condition if it was.

[Yates]

in this game the traitor is NOT a scum role.

Then why would your role be called a "traitor?"

[leviathan93]

in this game the traitor is NOT a scum role.

Then why would your role be called a "traitor?"

because if i am killed during the night then I would become scum. therefore my win condition would change.

[Aj The Epic]

So, let me point this out: If we LEAVE levi alive, we lose for sure.

[Mr_Ree]

... and if your win condition changed, you wouldn't tell us. It may have changed already, how are we supposed to know? Do we waste an investigation every night just to see if you've turned? Do we spend resources protecting you so you don't turn? You've become a liability, not an asset. Even if your claim is 100% truthful, which it CAN'T be, there are still missing pieces that throw it all out of whack, we can't spend the resources monitoring which side you're on. We can't be worrying about you either. You may be town now but that can change on any given day.

You gotta go BEFORE you become a problem. That's all there is to it. Thanks for doing your part, if you are still town and you die as town, you still win as town. Give your reads before you go, as detailed as you possibly can.

[leviathan93]

lol. then that is y'alls decision to make. =P not mine. i still believe because i'm town that i shouldn't be lynched. your supposed to be finding scum not lynching known town.

[serrapaladin]

Am I the only one worried about Yates' claim that he'll be mod-confirmed town tomorrow? I might be paranoid, but I feel that might mean we're in MyLo.

In light of that, I would sort of like a claim from him. Opinions?

[serrapaladin]

Actually, Yates, why did bait the N1 investigation if you can be mod-confirmed town?

Finally, if ANYONE is getting investigated tonight, it's me. So why not let that result speak for itself?

My role *will* be mod confirmed tomorrow one way or another.

Oh yeah... and then there's the fact I will be mod confirmed Town tomorrow. *shrug* It is what it is.

[Human Destroyer]

lol. then that is y'alls decision to make. =P not mine. i still believe because i'm town that i shouldn't be lynched. your supposed to be finding scum not lynching known town.

>known town

You claimed a scum role

You have to die

[serrapaladin]

No he didn't. He claimed a role that can be converted to a scum role.

Want to comment on Yates?

[PiggyGal15]

Vote Count 3.3

• [L-1]
  leviathan93
  - Aj the Epic, Yates, Mr_Ree, Human Destroyer
• Yates
  - Lord Mhork, leviathan93, Ms Marangal
• Not Voting
  - serrapaladin

With

8

alive, it takes

5

to lynch.
Deadline in (expired on 2013-03-27 11:10:59)

[Yates]

I might be paranoid, but I feel that might mean we're in MyLo.

You're being paranoid. We have only mislynched once in an 11 player game. It CAN'T be mylo.

[serrapaladin]

Except if Safety is town and yellow is the label for PR's. So tell me, why did you bait the N1 investigation?

[Yates]

Except if Safety is town and yellow is the label for PR's.

If you think Safety was Town, then Levi lied to get Town lynched thus making him scum. You are covered for either scenario. This is why Levi has GOT to be today's lynch.

[serrapaladin]

You'd better be right about this.

Intent to Hammer: Levi

Marangal & Mhork: Any comments?
Levi: Please post you final reads.

[Lord Mhork]

Not at CPU right now. Sreyoi

[Mr_Ree]

Good. I was wondering when you'd come around. If you have any last minute doubts, just reread my last post and bask in it's logic.

[Lord Mhork]

Ree, you ain't got shit for logic. I liked your play better when you were scum.

Also I don't actually remember that last post, nor do I know what I was trying to spell.

[Mr_Ree]

... it's on this page...

So explain, logically, how you came to believe that we should keep Levi around and lynch off Yates.

[Lord Mhork]

How do you get 4 factions out of that? One scum team and a few 3rds.

@SP did Yates claim? I must have missed that... I remember he said he would kill Mhork but I didn't take it at face value.

I was thinking about the slendy situation as well. From the flavor, it doesn't sound like a player. One would think he would be though, it is Slender man mafia afterall. Maybe SP is more on the right track than I am. Could also just be two scum and one recruitable with a third party princess. The yellow faction color is throwing me off. Definitely not town. No clue if it's scum or a third party color.

How come nobody asked why Ms. M hammered before Safety even posted? Are we just supposed to ignore that?

I meant 4 antitown players.

Her hammer was weird, but whatev's. She's still one of my top town reads.

Levy is bleeding truth on his claim, guys. Yates isn't. Why can't we lynch Yates?

Because I'm not the one lying and you are his likely scum buddy?

Because I'm the kind to buddy my buddy hard, right? I get the feeling that you think I'm an idiot or something. Why is that? And why are all your scum reads so opportunistic?

Why can't we lynch Yates?

Oh yeah... and then there's the fact I will be mod confirmed Town tomorrow. *shrug* It is what it is.

First you were already confirmed, and now you will be confirmed? Make up your mind. Or not. It just goes to show how obvscum you are to the rest of the town.

So, let me point this out: If we LEAVE levi alive, we lose for sure.

Elaborate.

... and if your win condition changed, you wouldn't tell us. It may have changed already, how are we supposed to know? Do we waste an investigation every night just to see if you've turned? Do we spend resources protecting you so you don't turn? You've become a liability, not an asset. Even if your claim is 100% truthful, which it CAN'T be, there are still missing pieces that throw it all out of whack, we can't spend the resources monitoring which side you're on. We can't be worrying about you either. You may be town now but that can change on any given day.

You gotta go BEFORE you become a problem. That's all there is to it. Thanks for doing your part, if you are still town and you die as town, you still win as town. Give your reads before you go, as detailed as you possibly can.

This isn't logic, Ree. I can counter this question with pointing out there's no reason for him to, as scum, claim to be traitor. We don't waste an investigation every night. We ignore him while we find scum, and then if, at the end, he's still around and we're a scum short, he can get lynched then. Or vig can waste a shot dealing with him.

Why can't his claim be truthful?

Your final sentence is weak and acquiescing and bleeds of scum trying to seem protown and reasonable. You're supposed to be better than that, Ree.

Actually, Yates, why did bait the N1 investigation if you can be mod-confirmed town?

Finally, if ANYONE is getting investigated tonight, it's me. So why not let that result speak for itself?

My role *will* be mod confirmed tomorrow one way or another.

Oh yeah... and then there's the fact I will be mod confirmed Town tomorrow. *shrug* It is what it is.

This.

I might be paranoid, but I feel that might mean we're in MyLo.

You're being paranoid. We have only mislynched once in an 11 player game. It CAN'T be mylo.

How do you know we've only mislynched once? Scumslip, mayhaps?

Except if Safety is town and yellow is the label for PR's. So tell me, why did you bait the N1 investigation?

Yates, why are you ignoring this?

You'd better be right about this.

Intent to Hammer: Levi

Marangal & Mhork: Any comments?
Levi: Please post you final reads.

Serra, stop. Don't hammer levy. Help me lynch Yates. He was flat out ignoring your questions and trying to waste town resources even if he'll aparently be all confirmed town anyway. Where's the town motivation? Where's the logic? Lynching levy is a stupid move.

... it's on this page...

So explain, logically, how you came to believe that we should keep Levi around and lynch off Yates.

I was talking about this:

Not at CPU right now. Sreyoi

And remember when I said this?

Levy is bleeding truth on his claim, guys. Yates isn't. Why can't we lynch Yates?

That's why.