In post 955, Rainbowdash wrote:
But you passed on a vote of a scumread who would be V/LA until deadline to vote the player who "didnt stick out to you" just two posts in iso before. I can understand if we are talking weeks to deadline and its two players you read as scum, but avoidance of the wagon how you did reads very poorly. Especially when you consider how serra acted towards KBW and how he was scummy either way.
Also what MM said is a good point, you jumpe from TUA to MO because TUA was "fighting for survival" which is exactly what MO was doing. Only player getting votes not doing that was KBW, who while V/LA was a noteable scumread of yours. What made the TUA vote bad but MO vote good since your reasoning doesnt quite hold up.
You could always just vote Antilles though. He is also scum and I would be willing to kill him if thats what we want to do first.
Yes, I purposefully made the decision to not vote someone who couldn't get to the computer to play the game and said he may have to replace out. And I would make that same decision again, barring a cop read or equivalent where I knew the guy was 100% scum. Like I said, day 1 is too early to have any solid reads in my opinion that would justify voting someone who can't even play over someone who can and who can, therefore, contribute. That you would have made a different decision doesn't make me scum.
When I got back from Easter, the MO wagon was pretty much gone and we only had a few days left before deadline. The viable wagons at that time were KBW and TUA. I voted TUA. Later, MO became viable again and I went for it because I got that gut feel that I shouldn't just let the TUA wagon happen (also as I've already explained) and he was still there fighting. Yes, MO posted when he looked like he would be the lynch, but that has little relevance to my gut feel on TUA (and the F-U drawings by MO did not scream out town.)
In post 957, RachMarie wrote:
To further elaborate... I have played with Town Serra before, and before you state oh he obviously was busy and that is why he did not play like usual and then replaced out card, all someone has to do is go check out Serra's posts... See if he replaced out of ALL of his games. That is about all I can say though because of redacted....
I do think that Serra replaced out because he did not have the time to devote to playing a good scum game. Normally I read replacing out as a null tell, and I admit mostly a gut read based on Serra's posts. The AtE though by Jen kinda reinforces my read.
I am not impressed with Antilles either they never did address my question about both hydra heads...
I can't say anything about why Serra replaced out because I don't know. I'm not sure what "AtE" you're talking about. You only give vague reasons for your read and seems like you're just trying to jump on the popular wagon du jour.
- What specifically about Serra's play did you find not like his town play?
- Also, even assuming I'm your top scum read, who else do you think is scum? Are you calling Antilles a scum read, or are you riding the fence on that one?
In post 958, Ms Marangal wrote:OMG KBW was scum, yay.
and that's a total misrep of my case on you Jen, and I didn't even vote you
How did I misrep you?
In post 964, Metal Overlord wrote:
Others proving my point for me holds more credence to me proving it myself. Besides, many others were against me for a policy lynch, especially Bulbazak, well so I don't policy lynch, and let you guys do it. Guess what? I was right!
Um.. what? How does this make sense?
I thought KX rage-quit. No longer true?
