In post 170, Bacde wrote:^^That's sort of a misrep
I gave you clear answers about how I felt about #32 and #36--I just felt like they were scummy
You asked me how posting my opinion without explanation was possibly protown, to which I responded that it can get reactions
So you saying that I expressed my opinion just "to get reactions" is a misrep and probably a big part of why you are misperceiving me--I wasn't posting to "get reactions", I was just posting. And just posting is good because it CAN get reactions
And I haven't avoided your question at all, I've been reiterating my point that it was mostly gut and I just felt like they were scum posts
Why can't you accept that as an answer?
What counts as an acceptable answer to you? Because a LOT of my reasonings in ALL of my games has to do with gut and intuition
When I tried to further explain my reasoning by agreeing with someone else who I felt captured my feelings well, you now say that its scummy for me to attempt to answer your question?
Its weird to me that I've been answering your question all thread, yet you still harp on me about answering it, and when I find someone else's post that expresses my feelings you find that even scummier? I don't understand why you keep asking me questions when you are clearly not going to pay attention to the answers
State how it was a misrep.
You didn't give me clear answers on why you thought they were scummy until you echoed SAS's thoughts. Gut Feeling and getting reactions /=/ answering why you thought the post was scummy properly.
#44 says otherwise. You seemed to be stating that you said it to get reactions in that post, now you're saying that was an unintended effect?
Mostly gut then? So why did you suddenly agree with SAS's reasoning. It's like saying "Oh, I thought that too, but I didn't put it down". It doesn't make any sense. You've not really been stating a clear answer why you think it's scummy, while SAS has done otherwise.
I can't accept that because the reasoning is poor, and anybody can say "Gut feeling this post is Town/Scum". It seems like a get out of jail free card.
An acceptable answer would be something along the lines SAS posted. Pointing out what you found scummy about them. Not just saying "It was gut"
No, it seems like you are completely copying someone else's thoughts, because you only have a "gut feeling" case against me, and when someone actually has a reasonable case against me (although I do disagree with it), you say "Yeah, I was thinking this all along". Had you answered me with this before, maybe we wouldn't be here. It seems very scummy that you would take someone's reasoning and say "I was thinking that all along", especially since your only other case against me is "gut feeling"
No, the problem is, had you answered with that in the first place, before SAS's post, I wouldn't have found it scummy. It just seems that you're trying to use someone else's case against me, when you didn't point it out yourself initially. Also, as I've said, your reasoning was very poor, and now you're taking someone else's better reasoning, and using it as your own.