NY 162: A Week at the Theatres (Game Over)

[Bacde]

KingdomAces -

Day Mason

Smashbard -

Day Mason

JacobSavage -
roflcopter -
petapan -
Oversoul -
ZONEACE -
PeregrineV -
Bacde -

What does everyone think of this order for claimage?

I like being last so, yes

[ZONEACE]

KingdomAces -

Day Mason

Smashbard -

Day Mason

JacobSavage -
roflcopter -
petapan -
Oversoul -
ZONEACE -
PeregrineV -
Bacde -

What does everyone think of this order for claimage?

My only concern is going after Peta, so I'm okay.

[Bacde]

based on p3-p4 I can safely say that peta and ZONACE are probably not scumbuddies

[JacobSavage]

Meh 2's good enough for me.
Lets get this rolling.


KingdomAces -

Day Mason

Smashbard -

Day Mason

JacobSavage -

Vanilla Townie

roflcopter -
petapan -
Oversoul -
ZONEACE -
PeregrineV -
Bacde -

Rofl, you're up next.

[roflcopter]

that order works for me

vanilla

[Smashbard]

I figured Rofl, being one of the scum, would bring up the whole "If one of the Mason's doesn't die then lynch one of them" while on the same page yelling about town being so stupid that they are throwing the game.

I pretty much knew after I made it blatantly fucking obvious what my role was Day 2 and I didn't die that Scum was setting up the classic "The Claimed Mason's Must Be Scum Because They Haven't Died Yet" fallacy.

But thank you Rofl, for continuing to slip again and again on this final day phase before you die. It just makes lynching you and your partner all the easier.

[Smashbard]

Although you might be in luck, I might just lynch Zoneace today just because I want him dead. His blatant pandering to Bacde, Aces and Myself as 100% town is definitely posturing for town support. lol.

[roflcopter]

yes. obviously. you're so good at this game. how did i not see it before.

[ZONEACE]

Although you might be in luck, I might just lynch Zoneace today just because I want him dead. His blatant pandering to Bacde, Aces and Myself as 100% town is definitely posturing for town support. lol.

If you do that you're an idiot. Just putting that out there. We're too far into the game to be lynching for personal reasons.

If there are 2 scum left in the game as we seem to be assuming (which I agree with) that means we have 7 townies. Lynch me that's 6 townies left, then 5 when we wake up tomorrow. And we've gone from a decent numbers advantage to a dangerously small advantage. A mislynch tomorrow and the game is all but lost.

Whereas, if you decide not to be a bullheaded, spiteful, git we can lynch scum today and still have a good numbers advantage over the scum and a better idea of who the last one is.

[Smashbard]

Your ad hom bullshit defense is only going to make me want to lynch you more.

You seem to be a little bit confused here. No matter how much you stamped your feet and was otherwise utterly useless last day phase insisting again and again "I'm town I'm town", you haven't proven a thing.

I have.

I'd much rather lynch Roflcopter or PetaPan today. But Rofls point of him bussing HD & Mr. Zepher makes for a helluva lot stronger case to keep him alive today than your "If you lynch me you're an idiot" argument.

So if you and Roflcopter are just going to go back and forth insulting me seeing which of your ad hom strategies works out the best to convince me to lynch someone? You're gonna be the one hanging, Zoneace. Straighten up.

[Smashbard]

Just to spell it out for you, this is the part where you start trying to state reasons why PetaPan is a better lynch than you. And just another helpful hint, your case should have nothing to do with "I'm just so town, so you shouldn't lynch me". I don't care whether or not we should lynch YOU, start convincing people why we should lynch someone ELSE.

[ZONEACE]

Your ad hom bullshit defense is only going to make me want to lynch you more.

You seem to be a little bit confused here. No matter how much you stamped your feet and was otherwise utterly useless last day phase insisting again and again "I'm town I'm town", you haven't proven a thing.

I have.

I'd much rather lynch Roflcopter or PetaPan today. But Rofls point of him bussing HD & Mr. Zepher makes for a helluva lot stronger case to keep him alive today than your "If you lynch me you're an idiot" argument.

So if you and Roflcopter are just going to go back and forth insulting me seeing which of your ad hom strategies works out the best to convince me to lynch someone? You're gonna be the one hanging, Zoneace. Straighten up.

Calling you a stubborn oaf is not an ad hom bullshit defense, it's a statement of the obvious. You're refusing you look past your dislike of me. And if you were maybe a little fucking patient I would prove what I'm saying. But I'm not saying anything useful until we get to me on this massclaim okay. If you can't deal with that, then I guess you need to lynch me and go ahead and probably lose the game.

So that's your choice, be patient, get through this massclaim, allow me to prove that Peta is the lynch today, or continue to allow your emotions dictate your play in this crucial, late stage of the game and cost the town what should be an easy win.

[Smashbard]

*sigh* You just, can never cooperate with people in a respectful, logical manner can you? Must be why you play Mafia, am I right?

Saying that I'm an idiot or that I'm being a stubborn bullheaded oaf is not a statement of the obvious. It is your opinion of my actions. If you can't even understand a basic difference between facts and opinions than God help you.

You already look bad enough saying that you want to claim AFTER the suspected Mafia targets. Which is always a scum move motivated by wanting to make sure your pre-determined roleclaim goes through safely without risk of a counter claim from those who are you trying to lynch.

So hell, JacobSavage looks more town than you right now because he jumped right in on wanting to be the FIRST to claim. Because he knew a Vanilla Claim was harmless.

But obviously you are posturing as if you have some sort of power role, otherwise you wouldn't have a specific request to claim after any particular player.

If it's an investigative role with a guilty result on Peta, then there's no need for Peta to claim before you. You know he's scum and he should be today's lynch and if you're wrong than we lynch you tomorrow for setting up a desperation mislynch.

If it's anything else, then you're just looking really scummy for not claiming before your stated suspects.

Hence why I am getting more and more inclined to lynch you.

So I'm going to say it again, straighten up.

[ZONEACE]

*sigh* You just, can never cooperate with people in a respectful, logical manner can you? Must be why you play Mafia, am I right?

Saying that I'm an idiot or that I'm being a stubborn bullheaded oaf is not a statement of the obvious. It is your opinion of my actions. If you can't even understand a basic difference between facts and opinions than God help you.

You already look bad enough saying that you want to claim AFTER the suspected Mafia targets. Which is always a scum move motivated by wanting to make sure your pre-determined roleclaim goes through safely without risk of a counter claim from those who are you trying to lynch.

So hell, JacobSavage looks more town than you right now because he jumped right in on wanting to be the FIRST to claim. Because he knew a Vanilla Claim was harmless.

But obviously you are posturing as if you have some sort of power role, otherwise you wouldn't have a specific request to claim after any particular player.

If it's an investigative role with a guilty result on Peta, then there's no need for Peta to claim before you. You know he's scum and he should be today's lynch and if you're wrong than we lynch you tomorrow for setting up a desperation mislynch.

If it's anything else, then you're just looking really scummy for not claiming before your stated suspects.

Hence why I am getting more and more inclined to lynch you.

So I'm going to say it again, straighten up.

I can't wait for you see how wrong you are. It's gonna be great.

[Smashbard]

Oh so now I'm wrong in thinking that Rofl and Peta are scum? Great. Let's lynch you then. Since you absolutely refuse to be helpful.

Vote: Zoneace

[ZONEACE]

Oh so now I'm wrong in thinking that Rofl and Peta are scum? Great. Let's lynch you then. Since you absolutely refuse to be helpful.

Vote: Zoneace

Seriously, you're that in capable of waiting?
You want to put me at L-2 that quickly?

Okay, well, that's it, you've made you're decision.

I won't be posting again (except to avoid a prod) until peta claims. So, you all have a wonderful time today.

[Bacde]

KingdomAces - Day Mason
Smashbard - Day Mason
JacobSavage -Vanilla Townie
roflcopter - Vanilla Townie
petapan -

Oversoul -
ZONEACE -
PeregrineV -
Bacde -

petapan is next

I'm not convinced that ZONEACE is being like he is out of scum motivation, I want to finish the massclaim before analyzing that.

[Bacde]

also ZONEACE stop worrying so much about being at L-2 if you already have a scum voting for you apparently

[Smashbard]

Precisely, if he's so convinced Rofl & Peta are the scum team then he has absolutely no reason to worry about being L-2.

His worrying about it proves that he's not truly sure about his reads. As he fears a scum quicklynch.

I haven't "made my decision" in the slightest. Because I believe Rofl & Peta to be the final 2 scum. So I'm not worried about Zoneace being lynched until the mass claim is complete.

But his ragequit resulting from my vote is very telling.

[petapan]

I'm VT

[JacobSavage]

KingdomAces - Day Mason
Smashbard - Day Mason
JacobSavage -Vanilla Townie
roflcopter - Vanilla Townie
petapan - Vanilla Townie
Oversoul -

ZONEACE -
PeregrineV -
Bacde -

[Bacde]

holy shit oversoul post your claim

[Smashbard]

Does it really matter in what order we go in from Oversoul to Bacde? As far as I know everyone except for Zoneace should be claiming Vanilla. And if Zoneace claims Vanilla as well than we might as well lynch him for making such a hubris over wanting to claim after Peta when he had no reason to do so.

[Bacde]

You don't know what I'm gonna claim

[JacobSavage]

He's going to claim I tin of Tomato Ketchup, I just know it.