Wisdom wrote:but found it a good point when Xeg said the same things in different words.
And I have explained several times that Xeg was saying "elvis is possibly scummy for totally backseat driving this wagon without a vote on it"
Whereas you were saying "elvis is scummy for not being cautious about an L-1 vote". If that was a segue from an argument about the fact that elvis had not been interested in voting xeg beforehand at all, then yes, I did miss that part of the argument and I'm sorry.
And if I have one problem with Majiffy it's that he is, in the last few pages, acting exactly like he was acting in Open 454 wherein I led town around by the dick the whole game and he was content to let me do that while soft buddying me but otherwise not interacting with me outside of fluff.
This is why his early pushes made me think yay happy town for Majiffy.
Majiffy has heavily pushed Mothrax and Pala, both of which are probably town, so it's not unlikely at all that this is scum-Majiffy. His reasons were really bad too.
1) Those slots have not flipped yet so if you're town you can't possibly know that much less use it as any credible reason
2) Majiffy is nigh famous for bussing as scum
I am going to revisit his reasons on those wagons though.
I don't care who has flipped and who hasn't; I consider those two town and I've seen Majiffy pushing their lynches for bullshit reasons. It's enough for me.
I rarely see majiffy provide good reasons for his vote. Fuck in a game we played together I found scum and majiffy got all the credit and people just thought I bussed.
majiffy not giving reasons is par for the course imo
Robbed of a scummy for what had to be the best unvote in mafiascum history.
the whole game is dumb and we don't know why we're good at it and nobody knows what is going on and we're all going to have to accept that
@bork
His not budging tunneling annoys me. He's not even willing to consider another lynch. And note that he has tunneled on me in the past.
But it's true that it's not unlike town-Majiffy to be like this.
@Jake
I have to agree with this, and that's why I am not sure whether Majiffy is scum or not.
In post 660, Jake from State Farm wrote:I rarely see majiffy provide good reasons for his vote. Fuck in a game we played together I found scum and majiffy got all the credit and people just thought I bussed.
majiffy not giving reasons is par for the course imo
Can you describe what made this look like Majiffy's town play early on to you? Because I agree but I find I can't articulate it very well.
In post 660, Jake from State Farm wrote:I rarely see majiffy provide good reasons for his vote. Fuck in a game we played together I found scum and majiffy got all the credit and people just thought I bussed.
majiffy not giving reasons is par for the course imo
Can you describe what made this look like Majiffy's town play early on to you? Because I agree but I find I can't articulate it very well.
mainly gut, I don't recall if I have ever played with majiffy as scum but all of his earlier posts reminded me of games we played. I could be reading him wrong but I don't see anything scum motivated. The only thing that really stood out was the vote on mothax who committed what i took as a town tell.
Robbed of a scummy for what had to be the best unvote in mafiascum history.
the whole game is dumb and we don't know why we're good at it and nobody knows what is going on and we're all going to have to accept that
things that read town
post 188 when he calls out CE (interesting note CE basically vanishes and never comes back and is replaced after this so + scum points for CE/Mac)
post 192 - basically repeats post 188 (doesn't want town to forget that)
post 465/466
Robbed of a scummy for what had to be the best unvote in mafiascum history.
the whole game is dumb and we don't know why we're good at it and nobody knows what is going on and we're all going to have to accept that
Blood from a stone! that's a little better and it's making me less wanting to (what amounts to a policy) lynch you. That said I don't know that I have a strong enough scumread on anyone else. If Elvis is replaced hopefully we'll get an extension.
I agree that the Xeg/Elvis pair has a snowball's chance in hell.
In post 671, borkjerfkin wrote:Jake, CE's vote that elvis talked about was very obviously a lazily handled RVS transition. I don't think her points there had any merit.
fair point, well then the point about Xeg I thought was good.
Robbed of a scummy for what had to be the best unvote in mafiascum history.
the whole game is dumb and we don't know why we're good at it and nobody knows what is going on and we're all going to have to accept that
In post 669, Jake from State Farm wrote:
things that read town
post 188 when he calls out CE (interesting note CE basically vanishes and never comes back and is replaced after this so + scum points for CE/Mac)
post 192 - basically repeats post 188 (doesn't want town to forget that)
post 465/466
People replacing out is not a scumtell, so this is null at best and scummy because of scum wanting to accuse someone with shitty reasons at worst.
465/466 is her being tunneled on Xegarus, to the point of ignoring whatever else is happening in the game just to talk about Xegarus. Easily could come from scum. Null at best if we assume she didn't feel like talking about anything else, which seems unlikely to me.
So I am not sure why you are getting town vibes from those.
In post 653, borkjerfkin wrote:And if I have one problem with Majiffy it's that he is, in the last few pages, acting exactly like he was acting in Open 454 wherein I led town around by the dick the whole game and he was content to let me do that while soft buddying me but otherwise not interacting with me outside of fluff.
That was a good time, wasn't it?
In post 660, Jake from State Farm wrote:Fuck in a game we played together I found scum and majiffy got all the credit and people just thought I bussed.
It's cuz I did all the pushing and yelling.
Also lol @ all of Wisdom's arguments. It's like he's never even played with me.
"But, but... SOMETHING MAJIFFY DOES IN EVERY GAME!"
"Yeah but he does that in every game"
"Ok but... but... SOMETHING HE DOES ALL THE TIME!"
"Yeah, but he does that all the time"
Only playing in games at personal moderator and/or 50%+ playerlist request.
That was a good time, wasn't it? 
Only playing in games at personal moderator and/or 50%+ playerlist request.
