Maxous wrote:Toasty - are you calling 2 scummy or is it a 'lolz WIFOM - oh you' kind of vote
I'm not quite sure what you mean by the second part, but...I find WIFOM scummy. This doesn't make 2 OMGOBVSCUM, but its something worth pressuring for.
Rememberance wrote:If the troupe leader is present he can steal other players abilities at night, I'd wager.
Pakunoda provides day chat.
Feitan would be a kamikaze(?)
Beats me who the rest are. There might be a jail keeper or doctor, Machi, maybe.
Hito, while a jester is against the set up, is a kamikaze against the set up? (that is, can there be a mafia that blows up and kills the hammerer? I'll stop asking these questions if they're against the rules.
Why are you trying to figure out the flavor-game connection when you should just be scumhunting? There hasn't been a single death yet and you are already doing this? It's not annoying, it's just pointless this early.
TNE wrote:Obviously... This was a serious non-RVS thing. And I agree with AK. It was quite a weak vote. I have my eye on you
idk, sounds to me like you are backpedalling away from your conviction.
2 wrote:Additionally, you're wrong in your analysis regarding WIFOM. I can go into details about it, but in short: everything in this game aside from votes that leads to a lynch and things confirmed by the mod in non-bastard games boils down to WIFOM. Saying "no" would also be a type of WIFOM with respect to alignment. Your whole argument about WIFOM never being town-motivated is also fundamentally flawed because town sometimes benefit from gambits, just to mention one thing.
We aren't going to get anywhere by arguing scum-hunting strategies. You won't convince me that WIFOM isn't scummy. And saying "no" to a question about putting off a rivalry for the first 3 days is not WIFOM. When I'm talking about WIFOM, I mean posing a hypothetical about what you Would do if of the other allignment.
Also, 7 posts from ^2 in a row? Next time, do it all in one post plz. OMG you did it twice! Use reply not quick reply. Please. Put everything in one post. Like seriously. I will advocate a policy lynch if you keep at it.
erg, I have bad gut feels on Sajin. Not sure why atm.
@Nacho: My ^2 read would best be described as leaning scum, and thus worth pushing. I don't think anyone can truly have a solid read on page 9--let alone day 1.
WHY THE HELL ARE WE STILL ARGUING ABOUT HYDRAS? NO ONE CARES! Even if it is a bad comparison, does it make a person scummy for believing that? NO. so stahp.