Mini 1446, Generic Mafia (Game Over)

[Infinity 324]

Except he didn't claim to have a strong read, he just thought palmar was the scummiest. They're different things.

Are we really going to get sucked into a debate over how strong his read was? It was strong enough to warrant a vote.

Ok

But if you could undstand fegel's reasoning, why couldn't you read the thread and find it yourself?

Gut is a viable reason to vote in RVS, but I don't think it was gut, and I don't think we were in RVS anymore.

I meant early in the game, not RVS. And it was gut, "feels fake" is pretty much gut.

So we disagree.

Ok

I'll leave this to others to decide whether this was bad reasoning

Yep.

Ok

Again, I'll leave this to everyone else

I thought it was evident - apparently you didn't see it the way I did, but I explained it when you asked. If you're calling me Scum for this I assume you think BeastCharizard is Scum, too? Do you have independent scumreads on him, because he still looks obv-town to me. I'd like to hear this.

Nope, I had a null-leaning-scum read on bc before your unexplained town read on him, but he seems townier with you-scum because scum often give unexplained townreads on townies to try to earn their support.

I'm not 100% on HD being town either

But at one point Horus forgot HD had a vote on him so Horus-scum -> HD-town.

[Infinity 324]

I know, but lazy.

Also Infinity dude is almost certainly town so he looks like a cool guy to sheep

I mean, I am a newb, but Bacde is pretty obv town too

...I hope I can be scum sometime so people can say I'm obv town then too

[Fegelein]

I can see a Horus/Beast scum team at the moment.

Really need to get in the mindset of the game, far too much posting going on. But I'll be kind of happy to jump on the Horus wagon, it just sort of died early on.

[JacobSavage]

Votecount 2.6

Zhero [3]

- Fegelein, roflcopter, Horus[/color]

Horus [3]

- Infinity 324, Bacde, Palmar[/color]

T S O[2]

- Human Destroyer, Zhero,[/color]

Not Voting [2]

- BeastCharizard, T S O

With 10 alive, it takes

6

to lynch. The day will end in (expired on 2013-05-23 06:25:38)[/i][/area]

Roflcopter has (expired on 2013-05-16 09:38:00) to respond to his prod before replacement.

[Infinity 324]

Do you not think this post looks like buddying? I mean it's possible they're on a team, but I think Horus would have explained a townread on his scum buddy.

[Bacde]

^^Hey that post also includes a really shitty reason to townread CES

[Infinity 324]

^^ True. Also Horus was the one to hammer, so

More vote on Horus!!!

[Infinity 324]

Wait horus's hammer was 3 posts after that and mentioned nothing about CES in between

MOAR VOTES

[Infinity 324]

3 posts after, meaning Horus only posted 2 things in between.

[roflcopter]

unvote, vote: horus

[Bacde]

hey hey nice to see ya

[Infinity 324]

Thank you Rofl

Two more votes!

[Infinity 324]

Yea so to summarize the Horus case he's scum because of misrep'ing, ingenuous actions to avoid making up BS and hammering his townread CES.

[Infinity 324]

Bacde, I feel like absta in Mini 1433

[Bacde]

you're not absta until you fakeclaim cop with a guilty on me and I have no counter because the only reason I know you are fakeclaiming is my scum knowledge

seriously, that play took balls

[Bacde]

Yea so to summarize the Horus case he's scum because of misrep'ing, ingenuous actions to avoid making up BS and hammering his townread CES.

did he really hammer CES?

lol can we lynch this plz

[Human Destroyer]

hammering his townread CES.

wait

what

[Human Destroyer]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Horus

fun fact: he did the same thing with his tso vote, go look

[Infinity 324]

fun fact: he did the same thing with his tso vote, go look

No, he had a scum read on TSO after tso's "scummy" posts

you're not absta until you fakeclaim cop with a guilty on me and I have no counter because the only reason I know you are fakeclaiming is my scum knowledge

seriously, that play took balls

Lol

I mean the Zdenek/xegarus part.

[T S O]

Intent to hammer. Claim, Horus.

[T S O]

Also I have to say that this feels ridiculously easy. Too easy. I know HD will probably bring this post back up later to say I knew he was Town/Scum, but no-one's offered tangible resistance.

[Infinity 324]

Yeah

That just means he's suffering from a severe case of confirmation virus

It's going around like an epidemic

Don't worry, me and Bacde will figure it out

[Infinity 324]

confirmation bias* lol

[Bacde]

Does anyone here think that Horus is likely not-scum, or at least has a reason to think that Horus might possibly be town?

cuz things aren't looking too good for him tbh

[Infinity 324]

Oh wait

Horus actually explained why he hammered

But that's mainly because of all the self-meta

Which is bad logic, but not necessarily a towntell

Horus is still 85-90% scum